Listen to thisThe students who need encouragement the most are often the least likely to receive it. This article presents the attitudes, language, and strategies necessary for effective encouragement, a key to success for motivating low-achieving or discouraged students.
The eminent psychiatrist Rudolf Dreikurs claimed: “The most important skill for raising a child in a democracy is the ability to encourage that child” (1971). Dreikurs considered encouragement to be the single most important quality in getting along with others – so important that the lack of it could be considered the basic influence for misbehavior. Dinkmeyer and Losoncy (1996) concurred that encouragement is the key ingredient in all positive professional and personal relationships.
If encouragement is indeed the most vital aspect of a child's social development, very few educators, counselors, and parents fully realize this fact. Encouragement is desperately needed today. Children and teachers need encouragement like plants need water. Learning the tools of encouragement is fundamental to improving relationships and creating cooperation in the home and in schools.
What is encouragement?
Encouragement is positive feedback that focuses primarily on effort or
improvement rather than outcomes. Encouragement is recognizing,
accepting, and conveying faith in a child for the mere fact that he or
she exists. The child does not have to be “the best” to be a
full-fledged human being. With encouragement, a child feels worthwhile
and appreciated regardless of the results he or she achieves.
Encouragement separates the deeds from the doer so there is no such
thing as “good” or “bad” children. Encouragement assumes that children
are intrinsically motivated and will cooperate and learn for the
satisfaction that comes from it.
Encouragement has been incorrectly described as “nonevaluative feedback in hopes of gaining compliance” (Kohn, 1996). On the contrary, encouragement is not praise, reward, or language used to gain compliance. Praise is judgmental, extrinsic, and controlling, perpetuating a discouraging superior-inferior relationship in which the child must consistently both please the authority and prove himself/herself. Praise always contains an element of judgment and evaluation. Whereas praise is given only when one achieves “good” results, encouragement can be given any time, even when things go poorly.
Encouragement is founded in Third Force Psychology and Adlerian principles, a hopeful, phenomenological, humanistic, perceptual, and purposive psychology (Evans, 1989; Evans, 1997; Meredith & Evans, 1990). Adlerian psychology has been demonstrating and using the principles and practices of encouragement for more than 55 years. According to Adlerian psychology, encouragement is the process of developing a child's inner resources and providing courage to make positive choices.
Encouragement is an attitude
Encouragement is not a step-by-step method or set of specific techniques
to make students behave. Rather, encouragement stresses a fundamental
attitude or “spirit.” Technique alone cannot create a democratic and
cooperative atmosphere. The attitude of encouragement rejects the unduly
pessimistic view of children and their motives (e.g., “students will
likely revert to less cooperative ways without powerful reinforcement or
recognition” [Albert, 1992]). Following this line, to be encouraging,
adults must believe that children have a positive desire to solve
problems and make changes. When this attitude is lacking, encouragement
is nothing more than another technique to coerce children.
Schools and programs that embody an encouraging attitude follow six practices (Carlson, Sperry, & Dinkmeyer, 1992). Such programs:
Make relationships a priority;
Conduct respectful dialogue;
Practice encouragement daily;
Make decisions through shared involvement (classroom meetings);
Resolve conflicts;
Have fun on a regular basis.
The statements below contrast encouraging statements that imply faith and respect with discouraging statements that convey doubt and disrespect.
THE LANGUAGE OF ENCOURAGEMENT
(Evans, 1995, Dreikurs, Grunwald, & Pepper, 1982)
| Encouragement "I think you can do it.” "You have what it takes.” "You’re a hard worker.” “What do you think?” "I could use your help.” "It looks like a problem occurred." "What can we do to solve the problem?” |
Discouragement "Here, let me do that for you." “Be careful; it’s dangerous.” "Don’t forget your assignment.” "Let me give you some advice.” “When you’re older, you can help.” "I told you to be careful.” |
| Encouragement "You put a lot of effort into your work.” "you’re a fine person.” "I know you did your best.” |
Praise "I’m proud of you when you do well.” "You did better than anyone else in the class.” "Next time, if you work harder, I know you can get an A instead of a B+.” |
When conducting workshops, I ask school personnel: “What inhibits a sense of belonging in your school?” Not surprisingly, the answer typically consists of those things that discourage students: comparative grading, win-lose competition, focusing on mistakes, focusing on outcomes, unreasonably high expectations, overambition, labeling children, and the level system. Together, all of these common practices pit parents against parents, parents against students, students against students, and students against teachers. In short, they create a climate of discouragement.
Shared decision making, on the other hand, in which students are allowed make choices regarding their own education, can help foster a climate of encouragement. Students can participate in class planning, create rubrics, and work in teams. They can learn to evaluate this work through portfolios and self-evaluations and can be trained to conduct student-parent conferences instead of parent-teacher conferences. Discipline and planning take place during classroom meetings, which allow students to make decisions about the operation of the class, resolve conflict, and give encouragement. The more students are involved in the decision making of the school through activities such as these, the more they feel a sense of belonging and connection. The more connection they feel, the more courage they have to participate and contribute, which results in a more democratic and cooperative classroom.
Psychological hardiness
Along with social interest, encouragement develops psychological
hardiness in the individual. Psychological hardiness is recognized as a
personality characteristic that effectively buffers stress, allowing the
individual to function adequately and cope with life’s challenges in a
way that creates meaning and purpose in life (Kobasa, 1979). These
individuals have a positive and realistic view of self, positive and
realistic view of others, and an openness to experience (Combs, 1992;
Evans, 1995; Evans, 1997).
Positive and realistic view of self. People who feel encouraged like themselves. They see themselves as adequate and are kind to themselves even when they have poor results. These individuals believe whatever they contribute is useful and this alone gives meaning to their lives.
Positive and realistic view of others. By accepting ourselves, we are able to accept others. Encouraged people have a high degree of empathy for others. They are comfortable with human nature and can allow others to be themselves without controlling them.
An openness to experience. Encouraged people do not fear mistakes, are open to their experiences, and are free of success and failure. They realize all learning involves mistakes and they view mistakes as opportunities for development. To encourage this openness to experience, John Leanes, the principal at Carwise Middle School, has done away with the fear of failure in his school. He encourages mistakes by telling his students they “fail forward” toward learning.
Discouragement
No corrective effort of a child's misbehavior is possible without
encouragement. The worse the behavior, the more encouragement a child
needs. Yet, children who misbehave are most likely to receive the least
amount of encouragement. Discouraged children need a chance to feel
appreciated and respected. Yet, instead of building them up, we tear
them down; instead of recognizing their efforts and improvement, we
point out their mistakes. Instead of allowing them to feel like they
belong through shared decision making, involvement, and meaningful
contributions, we isolate them even further through various means of
control and punishment.
Most adults are skilled at discouragement, having received more than their share. We have learned how to yell, threaten, nag, interrogate, criticize, reward, punish, and isolate when problems arise. As much as teachers and parents love children, we often end up treating them with little trust and respect.
Our very educational system is mistake-centered, stressing the negative value that hardly anyone is good enough as he or she is. Education promotes this value under the assumption that growth and improvement occur from pointing out mistakes and creating dissatisfaction with oneself. Teachers have been trained to spend much of their day, in various ways, pointing out the mistakes children have made. Many feel obligated to correct and prevent these mistakes, not realizing how fundamentally discouraging it can be. As a result, children learn that mistakes determine their value. They learn that by doing nothing, they can succeed in not making a mistake and avoid the evaluation, criticism, and ridicule that follows. Entire groups of students procrastinate and do nothing simply to avoid the humiliation that comes with making a mistake.
What can be done? Half the job of encouragement lies in avoiding discouragement. But before this can be accomplished, teachers and other adults must learn to distinguish encouragement from discouragement. Most commonly, teachers discourage students in five general ways (Dinkmeyer & Losoncy, 1996; Evans, 1989, 1996):
Overambition/setting high expectations or standards;
Focusing on mistakes to motivate;
Comparing one student to other students;
Making pessimistic interpretations;
Dominating by being too helpful.
The following list of attitudes and behaviors compares the characteristics of encouragement to discouragement.
The Tools of Encouragement
Listed below are two basic tools of encouragement that adults can use to
create relationships with young people based on mutual respect and
dignity, enhance a child's sense of belonging, and develop his or her
social interest and psychological hardiness (Dinkmeyer & Losoncy, 1995)
Focusing on effort or improvement
Encouragers learn to focus on effort and improvement rather than perfect
results. Focusing on these elements strengthens a child's courage to
move forward. Instead of being burdened by limitations, the focus is on
individual progress. Any movement is recognized as progress toward
reaching a goal.
|
ENCOURAGEMENT |
DISCOURAGEMENT |
|
Hopeful view of people’s nature |
Hopeless view of people’s nature |
|
Individual's behavior is purposeful |
Individual's behavior is caused by outside forces and victimization that may have occurred in the past |
|
Satisfaction comes from work, learning and belonging – intrinsic motivations |
Satisfaction comes from rewards and acquisition – extrinsic motivation |
|
Influence without strings |
Control, force, and fear |
|
Equality as human beings |
Superior-inferior relationships, sitting in judgment |
|
Chatting – talking with |
Advising – telling to |
|
Effective listening |
Ineffective listening |
|
Recognition, acceptance, and appreciation |
Moralistic praise and approval, bribing |
|
Being ourselves, fine as we are |
Pleasing and proving |
|
Challenge, stimulate |
Pressure, threaten, coerce |
|
Invite, offer choices |
Command, boss |
|
Cooperative atmosphere – helping and being useful |
Competitive atmosphere – winning or losing, success or failure |
|
Value and use emotions |
Fear and control emotions |
|
Uniqueness and creativity |
Obedience and conformity |
|
Recognizes effort and improvement |
Recognizes only tasks well done |
|
Courage to be imperfect |
Fear of mistakes |
|
Freedom with order |
Order without freedom |
|
Natural consequences |
Rewards and punishment |
For example, your five-year-old son is playing soccer in the neighborhood league. He is hesitant to get involved and unsure of what to do. Consequently, he stands back and watches the other children play. During the game, the ball rolls toward him. He kicks the ball, but in the direction of his own goal. What can you do? Some parents would correct his mistake and yell at him to kick the ball in the right direction. The encouraging parent would find something of value that focuses on his effort and say, “Did you see the way your foot contacted that ball,” or “Way to kick the ball!” or “By hanging in there long enough, you got to kick the ball.”
Focusing on strengths and assets
When students do poorly, schools typically focus on identifying their
weaknesses, limitations, deficits, or disorders. The encouraging
teacher, on the other hand, knows how to turn so-called liabilities into
assets. An essential encouragement skill is recognizing and expanding an
individual's strengths, and assets.
For example, 14-year-old Karen is stubborn and rebellious. She wants to do things her own way. When the teacher assigns her to write an advertisement on the value of drinking milk, she does the opposite. She interviews all the students who do not drink milk, and writes on how people dislike milk. Instead of engaging in a power struggle with Karen, the teacher could reframe her rebelliousness as a sign of self-determination and ability to think on her own. Instead of criticizing Karen, the teacher could recognized her desire to be an independent thinker. She writes on the top of her paper, “You display a desire to be an independent thinker and approached this assignment with initiative and creativity.” By using an encouraging attitude, the teacher can avoid a power struggle, which may allow Karen to reduce her rebelliousness in the future and improve the relationship between them.
Conclusion
Today, in an era when so many teachers, parents, and students feel
discouraged and without hope, encouragement is desperately needed. While
encouragement is not a new psychological idea, relatively few educators
fully utilize this valuable concept. Based on mutual respect and dignity
and on focusing on a person's strengths rather than weaknesses, the
tools of encouragement are essential for creating a stimulating learning
environment. As more and more educators are discovering, encouragement
is a key element in restructuring and improving our schools.
References
Adler, A. (1931). What life should mean to you. New York: Putnam.
Albert, L. (1992). An administrator’s guide to cooperative discipline. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
Carlson, J., Sperry, L., & Dinkmeyer, D. (1992). Marriage maintenance: How to stay healthy. Topics in Family counseling & Psychology, 1,84–90.
Combs, A. (1992). Perceiving, behaving, becoming. Washington, DC: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Corley, D. (1991). The effects of teacher-written positive comments on the locus-of-control of fourth- and fifth-grade spelling students. Dissertation Abstracts International, 52, 204-1205.
Dinkmeyer, D., & Losoncy, L. (1996). The skills of encouragement. Delray Beach, FL: St. Lucie Press.
Dreikurs, R. (1971). Social equality. Chicago: Alfred Adler Institute.
Dreikurs-Ferguson, E. (1989). Adler’s motivational theory: An historical perspective on belonging and the fundamental human striving. Individual Psychology, 45, 353–61.
Dreikurs, R., Grunwald, B., & Pepper, F. (1982). Maintaining sanity in the classroom. New York: Harper & Row.
Evans, T. (1989). The art of encouragement. Athens, GA: University of Georgia, Center for Continuing Education.
Evans, T. (1995). The encouraging teacher. In G.M. Gazda, F. Asbury, M. Blazer, W. Childers, & R. Wallers (Eds.), Human relations development (5th ed.), 261–69. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Evans, T. (1996). Encouragement: The key to reforming classrooms. Educational Leadership, 54, 8 1–85.
Evans, T. (1997). Development and initial validation of the encouragement scale educational form. Journal of Humanistic Education and Development. In Press.
Evans, T., Corsini, R., & Gazda, G. (1990). Individual education and the 4 R–s. Educational Leadership, 48, 2–56.
Evans, T., & Corsini, R. (1994). First stop grousing! The Family Journal, 2, 70. Griffith, 3., & Powers, R. L. (1984). An Adlerian lexicon. Chicago: The American Institute of Adlerian Studies, Ltd.
Kobasa, S.C. (1979). Stressful life events, personality, and health: An inquiry into hardiness. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 37, 1–11.
Kohn, A. (1996). Beyond discipline. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
Linden, w. (1996). Adler and organ music. Unpublished manuscript.
Meredith, C. W., & Evans, T. (1990). Encouragement in The family. Individual Psychology, 46, 187–92.
Sharma, S. N., Sharma, J. P., & Malti, R. (1984). Role of teacher analysis in teacher education programs. Indian Journal of Psychometry & Education, 12(1–2), 11–17.
Wilburn, K. T. (1983). Encouraging others to change their behavior. Journal of Employment Counseling, 20(2), 8 1–87.
This feature: Timothy Evans (1997) The Tools of Encouragement. Reaching Today's Youth, Vol. 1 issue 2 Winter 1997. pp. 10-14.
