Supported by
ListenThe morning at work began the way many winter mornings do in a schoolyard. The sky was bright, the snow was packed down, and the students arrived full of movement before the day had even really begun. We welcomed them off their transportation, offered breakfast, and watched them spill out across the yard looking for somewhere to put all that energy.
As my primary students rushed toward me with hugs, questions, and cold little hands, I found myself moving through the familiar winter script that has become part of working in a school.
“No, the play structure is still closed.
The swings too. We cannot use them until spring.
I know. I wish there were snow hills too.
Yes, it is cold, but we do not go in for another fifteen minutes.”
The children responded in the way children often do. They adapted. They created games from what resources were left to them. Winter tag. Snow forts. Running patterns into the yard. Making something out of not enough.
By second recess, I looked over and saw that my students had found a small patch of joy. A tiny stretch of ice in the schoolyard. Slippery, crowded, imperfect, and absolutely full of life. They huddled over it together, giggling, sliding, wobbling, falling, and getting back up again. For a moment, it felt like they had found a little piece of magic in an otherwise restricted winter landscape.
And, almost immediately, I felt the other truth alongside it.
I was probably going to have to stop it.
That is one of the tensions that lives quietly inside Child and Youth Care work, especially in institutional spaces. We are often standing at the intersection of joy and policy, between what children need in the moment and adult responsibility. We learn to hold both the child’s experience and the system’s limits at the same time. We know that fun matters. We know that risk, movement, and play matter. We also know that safety expectations are real, and that part of our role is to carry manage these risks.
As I approached the children on the ice, I heard laughter shift into crying. I saw one fall become several. It was clear that the moment had changed. It was time to intervene.
I could not help but laugh a little at the familiar pattern that followed. The same students who had run to me in tears about scraped knees now insisted they were completely fine. They promised they were not even hurt. They swore it would never happen again. They would be extra careful. It was obvious how much this little patch of ice meant to them. It was one of the few places in the yard that still felt fun, open, alive. Being the adult responsible for shutting it down felt, in that moment, like being the person asked to put out the last light.
As I insisted the group moved away, disappointed, already beginning to negotiate what game might come next.
All but one.
My last primary student remained standing on the ice. Arms crossed. Lip out. Face tight with anger. Small tears gathering in his eyes. Then he shouted, with full heartbreak and full conviction, “You just can’t close this ice. It’s the only magic we have left. I’ll never leave.”
In that moment, I not only saw, but felt the connection in how me and this child had seen the winter snow from our windows today. I realized I now had a choice. I could move straight into limit setting. I could remind him that the rules were the rules, that everyone had to follow them, that it was only fair. And none of that would have been untrue.
But there was another possibility too.
I could respond to the meaning of the moment for this young person, not just the behaviour.
As I started walking toward him, I could see his body tense. He looked ready for a battle. Ready to defend something important. Ready, maybe, to be misunderstood. Instead, I walked right past him, then turned and held out my hand.
“I really need your help with something,” I said. “Will you walk inside with me?”
He looked surprised, but he took my hand.
We walked through the school together, hand in hand. As we walked, I told him how much I loved his passion for fun and play and ice. I asked him to tell me more about the magic winter brings him. He began to talk. Really talk.
He told me about sliding on ice, tobogganing, climbing snow hills, and the joy of moving fast in winter. He told me how much fun it was. How exciting. How he thought other people loved it too.
The more he spoke, the more it became clear that this was never just about a patch of ice. It was about freedom. Delight. Movement. Possibility. It was about the emotional life of play.
Before we got to where we were going, I told him the truth.
I agreed with him.
I told him how much joy it gave me to watch him have fun. I told him I admired his passion. I told him I understood why ice, slippery play structures, and damp swings could feel magical. Then I also told him that the rules were not mine to change. That every school had safety rules like these. That even when joy was real, I was still responsible for safety.
I explained to him that I care deeply about the children at our school. And that part of caring is protecting them, even when they do not like it, even when I do not like it.
Then we walked out the back exit to the big yellow gravel bin.
I handed him a cup and filled one with gravel for myself and another for him. As we carried them back toward the yard, I told him we were going to work together to make the schoolyard both safer and still fun for everyone.
At first, it seemed that he did not believe me. His body carried that heavy slump children get when disappointment has already settled in. He trudged toward the ice patch holding his cup of gravel like it was proof that the magic was over.
Then I said, “Okay. You’re the official fun tester.”
He looked up at me, confused.
“I’m going to sprinkle a little gravel on the ice,” I told him, “And I need you to make sure all our snow forts can still be reached in a fun way!”
Something shifted. Not all at once, but enough.
I spread just enough gravel to make the surface safer for standing and walking without taking away the experience entirely. My newly appointed Official Fun Tester stepped onto the ice with deep suspicion. I encouraged him to try his favourite ice dance. To pretend he was skating. To see what still felt possible.
This moment has stayed with me because it reminded me of something essential in Child and Youth Care.
Children do not only react to limits. They react to how those limits are conveyed. They react to whether they feel dismissed or understood. They react to whether the adult enters the moment as an enforcer only, or as someone willing to join them in making sense of what has been lost and what might still be possible.
Too often, when children protest, adults move quickly to the surface. We respond to the refusal, the attitude, the tears, the shouting. But relational practice asks something deeper of us. It asks us to wonder what the behaviour means. What is being defended. What is being grieved. What is being communicated beneath the words.
This student was not simply refusing a direction. He was protecting magic.
And once I understood that I could respond differently.
I did not need to pretend the rule was not real. I did not need to give the ice patch back. I did not need to abandon safety to be relational. But I could honour what mattered to him. I could invite him into the problem solving. I could preserve dignity. I could make room for participation instead of defeat.
That is one of the quiet gifts of relational CYC practice. It reminds us that empowerment is not the absence of limits. It is the presence of voice, meaning, and shared process inside those limits.
What mattered that morning was not only that the children stayed safer on the ice. What mattered was that one child moved from powerlessness to participation. He was no longer the child being dragged away from the last bit of fun in the yard. He became the child helping to protect the fun. Helping to reshape the moment. Helping to carry the responsibility.
That is a very different experience of care.
In school settings, it can be easy to become flattened by routine. Winter rules. Recess transitions. Supervision expectations. The thousand small moments that can start to feel repetitive or procedural. But children are never experiencing those moments as just routine. They are living them fully. The closed structure is not just a closed structure. The patch of ice is not just ice. The gravel bin is not just gravel. These moments carry emotion, imagination, disappointment, conflict, and possibility.
Our work is to meet them there.
Sometimes that means setting the limit.
Sometimes it means grieving the loss with them.
Sometimes it means handing them a cup and inviting them back into the story.
