When CYC practitioners accept the validity of the Threshold Concepts that build relational skills, they begin to reduce the focus on their own logic about values and strengths and become more centered on the person being helped, rather than seeing behavior through a personal filter which privileges their own values and life logic.
This is a big thought to digest for most readers and is appreciated more completely after a few years of practice. It becomes more understandable as mature practitioners realize that they are most successful when they don’t create reliance on themselves or expect that their behaviors and life strategies are better ways to live that the young person or family should acquire.
I would like to quote a recently created concise description of our field by Heather Modlin at a CYC retreat at the Cavan Summit in Ireland in June:
The practice of Child and Youth Care focuses on understanding and responding to the needs and rights of children, youths, and families within their unique context. CYC is relational and occurs in the life space, through the continuous creation and utilization of everyday moments and shared experiences to promote holistic growth and well-being. - (Modlin: June, 2022).
We very readily agree to these statements about our field, but resist changing our common-sense stances which insist that we each have the best answers to how to be successful in life.
To return to my title, the challenges faced by developing professional CYC practitioners include consistently pushing back against program dynamics that value external control to maintain a well-run environment rather than supporting people to become more self-controlled.
Level 2 practitioners experience resistance from other staff when they allow young people or families to be more in charge of their lives and face criticism for not being consistent with the approaches used by less skilled and newer staff members. CYC supervisors can unfortunately also be members of this chorus, which is a source of great job dissatisfaction for skilled practitioners.
However, when Level 2 practitioners begin to accept a new view of self-in-practice, they experience greater job satisfaction, both internally and from the responses from young people and families. The concept of maintaining a “one-down” stance, which means they allow the person being helped to lead the way, now becomes both clearer and more logical. As the Treatment Planner and Change Agent (Phelan, 2016) strategies with the person being helped to create useful learning, he/she can now see how being too self-involved was a deficit and is reinforced to become more open to listening without personal assumptions.
These new ideas about self-in-practice are included in the threshold concepts which support relational CYC practice and once understood and accepted by the developing practitioner will permanently change how he/she defines the work of CYC practitioners.