CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 283 SEPTEMBER 2022

Concerning Health

Hans Skott-Myhre

As many of my readers know, I am prone to annoyances and pet peeves. I have had several them over the years I have been writing this column including mental health, developmental theory, psychopathology, disciplining young people, pseudo community involvement, and lack of a serious political positioning for the field under the increasingly dangerous living conditions for young people as we enter the 21st century. This month, I want to add one more pet peeve to the list and that is the ways in which health is becoming a neo-liberal buzz word.

One of the observations that I have made over the years, is that the more we hear a term repeated across all forms of social media, institutions of education, and governmental funding initiatives, the more likely it is that whatever is being named over and over again is either in danger of social extinction or already absent from our social fabric.

In my reading of our current social, this is true of the nuclear family, actual education for young people, caring for kids, communities, countries, and democracy among others. While we incessantly reference these terms as social structures that we value, in fact there is little evidence that they exist as significant material actualities. Most certainly there are pockets of all of them surviving on life support, but while we talk about them, we don’t actually believe in them in ways that really matter. In other words, we don’t live in those spaces with any degree of integrity or commitment. That is not to say, that for any number of us, we aspire to the notion of community, or family, or education, or caring. It’s just that the ways in which we have organized society don’t meaningfully include the kinds of social investment we would need to keep these social structures alive.

The organization of social structures often appears to be out of our control, but I would like to remind us that we produce society as much as it produces us. Without our tacit support, no social system can be sustained over any length of time. Which is why the question of what we believe to be the actual state of affairs is critically important. In relation to the representations of investments in various social institutions and practices related to young people, I would argue that it is key that we be able to discern actual material investment from symbolic representations of investment.

To give a simple example, the proliferation of messages from social institutions, such as politicians, government agencies, educational institutions, and various forms of media relating to children as our future and the importance of caring for young people are largely abstract representations of care. They are saturated with contradictions and antagonistic sets of relations that operate in direct opposition to caring for young people. If we actually cared for young people, we would not organize society in such a way as to subject them to an ever-proliferating cycle of violence, an education system fully inadequate to their needs in the 21st century, a job market that condemns them to harness their creativity to the dictates of an economic system designed for maximal exploitation and appropriation, and communities incapable of providing minimal degrees of safety and support.

The message, that we as a society care about young people has little or no basis in actual social reform. We as adults, parents, and CYC workers bandage and triage as best we can, but we do not seem to have sufficient political will to change the fundamental social logic that drives the kind of society in which actual care for young people becomes inordinately difficult, if not impossible, on any kind of broad scale. Put simply, enough of us continue to believe in the current system of global capitalism to sustain its dominance and logic. Either that, or we believe that capitalist institutions are unassailable and that any attempt to challenge the hegemony of corporate rule is a fools errand.

There are of course, dissenters and those who have become disenchanted with genuflecting to the economy as the ultimate arbiter of what can and cannot be done to remediate pain and suffering, or even more ambitiously to create a society that promotes all living things as valuable in and of themselves. But even those of us who have desires for an alternative system of value find it difficult to step out of the vortex of capitalism’s hold on the way we live our lives. That is not to say that another way of life and a new social form is not forthcoming, it is simply to say, that on any given day, it can be hard to discern where it might be emerging.

That said, I am a firm advocate for the necessity of a new social system of value that would truly take care as a central defining principle. I am old enough now to believe that I very probably won’t see that change, that will be provenance of future generations. However, from what I see in my students and other young people I encounter, I am optimistic. From where I sit though, the future for the next few generations looks to be pretty difficult. As a global society, we seem quite determined to commit suicide as a species. We are literally killing ourselves and each other, both directly through acts or war and interpersonal violence, and indirectly through climate change, and the cascading extinction of other species.

So, why the optimism? I remain optimistic because I am not a determinist. I don’t think in terms of the inevitable. For me, the future is unknowable and full of random acts and intersections, the impact of which can’t be known. The beauty of having been involved with young people, their families and communities for the past 45 years, is that I have had the opportunity to see innumerable impossible and seemingly hopeless situations make an utterly incomprehensible turn around. I can’t count the number of lives that appeared to be headed into a spiral of slow suicide, suddenly turn around and move in an entirely different direction. Since I find Foucault’s argument that society is built out of the micro-interactions of everyday life, I see no reason that a new social form might well be being produced in ways that I cannot imagine.

Of course, I have to acknowledge the lives that did not turn around in time. There have been losses to violence, suicide, disease, and addiction. There is no guarantee that things will ever turn around in time for any given body to survive. But there have been enough survivors who are now thriving for me to at least consider the possibility that we as a global society might just turn things around in a time and in ways I probably won’t see and can’t imagine.

One thing seems clear to me though. If we are to turn things around, it will have to be done in a fully material way. The world of abstract signifiers that would have us believe in ghosts of social forms that are either in danger of extinction or already extinct has to be left behind. In some cases, we will need to revive and breathe life into them by living their reality in the realm of lived experience. In other cases, we will need to acknowledge the loss of some social forms and create or produce new ones that better suit our needs. In either case, we need to quit relying on the institutions of neo-liberal cyber capitalism to tell us what we need or who we are.

In regard to those social systems that might need invigoration, I would count health as a key exemplar. Certainly, there is nothing more personal in term of our needs or even our identity than our health. Our health is what allows us the capacity to act and create using the unique configurations of our bodies over the course of a lifespan. The health of our bodies is our most intimate relationship because our bodies are foundational in the construction of who we are and how we live our lives. Of course, we might also add our minds here, but that would be to perpetuate the peculiar idea that our minds can be separated from our bodies. That our thoughts, emotions, and the physical corpus of our body can be seen as somehow separate from one another. Or, that the self is somehow a distinct entity that resides in the body but is not the body. Our current view of our health would seem to be built on a framework that fragments our bodies into an array of component parts and at the same time localizes the genesis of the healthy body in ways that radically separate us from the ecology of bodies in which we are embedded.

Perhaps, what troubles me most about health is that the term health is quickly becoming an instrument of the neoliberal disciplinary apparatus. It is Foucault who noted that under industrial capitalism, our bodies were shaped to the needs of the factory though instrumental modes of physical training in the school and in the home. The concern of industrial capitalism wasn’t so much a healthy body, as a useful body. There were of course, social trends that emphasized heathy eating and exercise throughout the 20th century. At the end of day, however, the body was really a site of discipline and regimentation. What was a stake was the physical body itself as an essential instrument in the industrial process.

With the decline of industry and the redeployment of bodies into the role of consumption rather than production, we begin to see a social reconceptualization of the healthy body. In the 20th century health was largely defined as an absence of disease. If a body wasn’t sick, it was healthy and could go to work. This model shifts as we enter the 21st century and we begin to define health, not just in terms of pathology, but as a something to which we aspire. As an ongoing process of self-improvement, in which we get healthier, not just healthy.

In this model, each of us is required to take responsibility for our health by engaging in projects of constant self-monitoring and activities that improve our bodies and minds. We receive messages from all sides of the social spectrum from our families, schools, workplaces and the media about the necessity of being hypervigilant about unhealthy behaviors. These social institutions provide us with a seemingly endless array of programs and formulas for healthy living. We are told that if we adhere to the regimes of health promotion we can beat addiction, fight off disease, have successful and fulfilling relationships, become mentally healthy, and maximize our bodies capacities.

This magic kingdom of self-care promises us something called health through activities related to health promotion. The promise would appear to be a kind of inoculation against the emotional, psychological, and physical vicissitudes of contemporary life. We are presented with an ever expanding array of magic bullets from psychopharmacology to yoga, to exercise regimes, walking, running, psychotherapy, addiction recovery programs, spiritual wellness retreats, endless dietary regimes, self-help coaches, and so on. Each of these in turn promises a kind of self-improvement that will give us better health.

But just what better health means seems a bit elusive. In some regards, it seems as though health is a moving target that is just out of reach. In another respect, health might be the successful adjustment to 21st century cyber society. Or perhaps, health is achieving a mind/body balance in a world seemingly throwing us off balance on a regular basis. One might wonder if health might simply be an absence or minimization of psychic/emotional/physical pain? Is it a kind of armoring against trauma? Can we escape the effects of a suicidal society by taking care of ourselves? In all of this, are we just whistling past the graveyard? Are we using health and well-being as a kind of mythical shielding from the actuality that we are dying, our ecologies are dying, and our society is dying? 

What does seem clear is that health is a booming industry. In terms of research, commodities, and services there is a lot of money to be made if one can parlay our anxieties about health into some kind of program that can be marketed. And in the neoliberal marketplace health is a major seller. Our well-being is a global commodity that is being traded at all levels of the global cyber economy. We can find the cypher health in almost all new initiative related to social services and if it hasn’t arrived in your CYC granting platforms, I predict you will see it soon.

At the end of the day, the trouble is that our well-being is not an individual matter. No amount of self-care or individualized health promotion will create an ecology that is healthy for our bodies and minds. We live in an ecology that either sustains us or does not. Health and well- being are not individual attributes. They emerge out of collective practices of caring for each other and the world in which we live. We are a collectivity of bodies that all impact each other in ways that no individual can control. The amount of pollutants in our air and water supply that have toxic effects on our bodies in the form of cancers, hormonal mutations, or neurological disorders cannot be wished away by healthy eating. The psychological devastation of a society that is inherently traumatic cannot be remediated through individual psychotherapy or recovery programs. The anxiety that takes its toll on our bodies and minds is not an individual issue but constitutes an emotional/psychological pandemic premised in the way we have uprooted ourselves from any kind of meaningful labor.

These are the real threats to our actual material health and they require a reconfiguration of the fundamental ways we have organized our society. Until we begin that work, the words health and wellbeing are just marketing slogans used by the very institutions that are killing us. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App