CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 283 SEPTEMBER 2022

“Not for Wimps”

Garth Goodwin

Definitely not the case at my work! Experience is everything and 9/10 of the graduates we hire only last maybe 6 months. High risk/lots of violence and crisis involved, most new hires will leave and go to the school board because it’s a more controlled setting. I’ve been in the field for 14 years, and I’m finding that more recently we’ve had to train new hires on simple theories. I’ve had a lot of placement students that have refused to do anything hands on (including paperwork) and they’ve had a lot of attitude/entitlement issues - some never even finished their placements. [1]

The above statement was Amanda Lauren Volgyesi’s response to a recent query by Rosy Bear regarding the influence of experience and/or education on child and youth care practice. It played right into a few of my hang-ups about practice: turnover and dedication. Associates have spoken with me about the profound challenges engaging youth hires in the work. That word, that notion seems to be at the heart of the matter as we are living through an age where work is taking a bad rap indeed. The Great Resignation it has been termed, the post pandemic reluctance to return to the grind of real work following layoffs and being on the dole often in 1st world countries. It is not all over the more menial work out there. Hotel maid and airline ramp rat positions going begging are joined by professionals in nursing or even medical doctors who refuse to work without a vibrant lifestyle to their satisfaction being possible. Many of us who chose to fly soon found out what a mess the world is literally in. This column is to remind folks that child and youth care practice is a profession, one requiring an extensive period of apprenticeship in the years with the individual largely being his or her own guide taking the very best of mentorship offered from supervisors, colleagues and yes, charges, the youth in your care. If ever there was a profession dependent upon reality, keeping it real, it must be this one. Further, finding an employer/supervisor who is also a professional is also a big ask as the majority answer only to themselves, their employer or agency mission ignoring the field for the most part. This column explores aspects of a profession built on passion.

For many starting out as a child and youth care practitioner begins with the vital, often under compensated and virtually solo overnight shift. Your interview is hardly over, and you are being asked if you can start tonight. Whatever is your first shift, it will not be conventional. Nothing is and in essence nothing can be in the wide world of scheduling shifts. The hours of work nicely clip by a few hours the conventional 9 to 5 world. Morning shifts often begin at seven a.m.  when wakeups, breakfast and getting all out the door is the usual drill. Your evening shift begins in the afternoon at 3 p.m. just in time to welcome the youth back from their days, clobber supper together and plan something for the evening. Finally, at 11 p.m. you get to give changeover informing that overnight person about the day and leaving. Conventional living goes right out the window with shift schedules which may be fixed often according to seniority or rotating with everyone sharing the pain, each in their peculiar way or flex time with shift swapping entering the mix. If you go off at 11 and return at 7, that is a back-to-back that yields you a stretch off when complete. I literally worked every Sunday day shift for my entire career to satisfy the demand everyone, but the supervisor work a shift on the weekend. It was not until late in my career that I got to live the 9 to 5 lifestyle and found it restrictive. It all went so fast and there was a sense of no time for anything often.

The life altering hours are one thing but then you find yourself in what can often be a hostile world in which your charges, the young people you are to care for totally do not want to have a thing to do with you and your colleagues assert their hard-won seniority leaving you to find your way. It helped to have the mentorship of David McDonald who himself as supervisor was a pioneer in therapeutic group care. He practiced the unconditional acceptance he wanted you to practice towards young persons and colleagues. The key is the self, yourself is at the center of a team reality sharing a rather complex reality with the purpose of inspiring health and positivity. That complexity is challenged with each new referral arriving and even more so with the leave taking of a long-term key team member. Both upset the balance of the group and can do so from the degree of a bump in the road through to a full-blown tilt, the end of a program as it was once practiced.  In my day Bruno Bettelheim with his university-based program for emotionally disturbed youth and master’s degree candidates underscored the need for a few years of absolute dedication was the example. Today it would be Edmonton’s MacEwan University’s Jack Phelan who approached the experience of the practitioner cautioning that the first few years are devoted to digesting the complexity. In his bio on CYC-Net Jack writes:

“In fact, unless you believe that you are getting personal benefits from the work, you won’t last very long. The biggest deterrent to enjoying a Child and Youth Care career is not the youth and families, but adult co-workers and supervisors who do not allow good treatment to occur, insisting on orderly behaviour over real change.”[2]

Jack points to the self above reminding us that the central key is the self. I recall the early years dealing with two sisters, both adorable, both sniffers, both slashers and now confirmed both young people with a traditional indigenous Mother on assistance who may have been a victim of residential schooling who shared a profound poverty of being hopeless. When they sniffed and slashed, they went there, a literal dead space where you could only look out at nothing and use a blade to feel sensation, any sensation. Both also had the greatest smiles as did their mother and for moments they could forget themselves and have an honest laugh about something. It is those moments that you build on. Such moments and an appreciation for complexity serve you well as a practitioner as well as the fact that you have a team to coordinate with. You see, it is never about you. You may feel that way drawn to this kind of work as you are a seeker yourself. Such considerations are essential but for your own time. On shift, it is all about the youth in your care, their health and well being and shared understanding of your team members. Change especially human growth is often a story of repeat, rinse and repeat again. Care and consistency need to balance providing a foundation and the freedom that allows for novel thought, trying something new, being different. Somewhere in our relationships with youth, or perhaps over a lot of such somewhere, change happens and wellbeing becomes a reality. The young person takes from there, often becoming an ally in the group process and you are freed to attend to another.

As a boomer my generation was one of the first, being post war and affluent, to experience choice and contemplate change, to give peace a chance. The young adults out there looking for work today had all of that in spades, a global pandemic and a guaranteed annual income for much of it. Small wonder their perceptions are a bit skewed. My deepest regrets are for those who pay for and undertake a full degree in child and youth care and then hit the wall, resign and sadly never look back. The majority who try this work leave just as they should be getting it, perhaps they are getting it for many, their turn in a group home was a highlight of their lives. No one wants to be in care. Still, societies have always needed caregivers for the destitute and the abandoned. Add in the pace of change and that need for care becomes more complex. Trust me, there are many out there such as Amanda above who practice on in the greatest profession that wasn’t understanding both experience and education play a part, one which ideally could be supported as it is for educators with defined educational assists. One of my more profound realizations was the amount of care it takes to build a human being who has lost his or her way. I don’t know how all this change will shake out but for those who have walked away, perhaps they will reassess and return. They are very much needed.

[1] CYC-Net Discussion Group on Facebook, August 8, 2022, Rosy Bear query. www.facebook.com/groups/intcycnet

[2] https://cyc-net.org/People/people-phelan.html

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App