It’s almost strange, but certainly not very constructive, to think about child and youth care practice without also thinking about women. In my experience at least, the answer to just about any scenario involving children and youth involves at least one, and usually many, women. In fact, the state of children and youth is very closely tied to the status of women in national and in global society. As societies become more and more impacted by migration and transnational connections, the idea that a liberal feminism, centered on the experiences of women generally and white women in particular, no longer serves purpose (it never really did). This means that concepts such as better representation of women in positions of institutional and governmental power, or even franchise rights, have very little impact outside of further widening the gulf between most women on the planet (who are racialized) and just about everyone else. Our social and economic structures, even before the systematized capitalism of modern times, have always forced women into commodifying themselves, either through submission to arranged marriage or through the sale of their bodies. Today, we can readily see women being forced to commodify their children for survival of both themselves and their children. This reality comes into stark focus when walking the streets of major European cities. Inevitably, women will approach with their children in arm, pointing to those children and asking for money. If you won’t give to the woman, perhaps you’ll give to the child.
What is often invisible in these contexts is that the women and their children are living and working under coercion of organized groups of criminals, a social group that has maintained its patriarchal structures without compromise. These days, coercion no longer requires the brute violence it once did. Much of the coercion is well-embedded in capitalist (and sometimes legal) processes of debt and repayment. The reality is that many of the women we encounter in this way, and by extension their children, are simply paying off their debts, which by virtue of extortionist interest rates and massive profit transfers to the organized criminals involved in this kind of panhandling, will likely never be repaid in the woman’s lifetime, placing her children at great risk of shouldering the burden in the future. The debt itself was almost always acquired in the process of migration – escape from war, violence, and interpersonal circumstances of unbearable pain. Ironically, therefore, it is a debt acquired for protection, but one that does not protect. Those impacted are overwhelmingly racialized women. This explains, at least in large part, the lack of interest in the issue in European (and increasingly North American) societies, where these kinds of trafficking schemes operate with virtually no enforcement on the part of authorities (perhaps in part because it isn’t entirely obvious that this kind of organized crime is actually illegal in Europe or North America, but likely also because the visible victims of this are not usually white women).
The scenario I am describing may sound very specific and not applicable to everyone. Most racialized women, including those with significant migration histories, are not panhandling. That is true. But it is one of many examples of how 21st century processes, policies and procedures, in this example related to migration, systematically and chronically place racialized women in positions of extreme vulnerability and untenable decision-making. One might argue that the processes associated with migration are not all that different from those associated with child welfare, youth criminal justice, housing, food security, employment, and others. Across all these contexts, racialized women encounter moments of decision-making that leave them with no meaningful options, with no possibility of enhancing their self-determination, and with limited possibilities of moving out of coercive systems in which the rules are imposed from above and from within pre-existing colonial, white, or otherwise patriarchal structures.
Child and youth care places its focus on children and youth, often in the context of family systems. Our relational practices, our pedagogies, and our approaches to therapeutic change and even treatment all center the child or youth and aim to empower that child or youth to find meaningful pathways of navigating social relations in the world as it is. In so doing, we may be underestimating the impact of patriarchal structures infused with white supremacy and racism on the possibilities for growth for children and youth; and we may also be missing the many ways in which these approaches actually contribute to and perpetuate the oppression of racialized women. There is virtually nothing in our field that centers women, much less racialized women, as agents of care, power, or change. In fact, when we encounter a woman panhandling with her child we wonder about the child much more so than the woman despite that woman giving live to the child every day. Our starting point is the trauma experienced by the child. I wonder if this is limiting and insufficient. And I wonder what would happen if we took a different starting point, abandoned the focus on the trauma of the child, and instead adopted a focus on the structures that place women in positions of commodified instruments for others. This is not really a story about childhood trauma. It is much more a story about a quietly accepted violence against women, notably racialized women, that sets the boundaries of how that child might see themselves navigating this world.
In a profession that fundamentally seeks to center care and relationship as the engine of social relations, a much more radical, racialized feminism may go a long way toward relational practices that center women as the lifeblood of community – the community that will, in turn, provide the nurture and care for the children and youth. It seems to me that we have worked hard to avoid such a radical, racialized feminism precisely by inserting into our discussions concepts such as resilience, attachment, and trauma, all of which serve to sever the agency of women and celebrate the professional interventions that aim to empower children and youth.
It is interesting to me that we work so hard to ensure dignity and humanity in our work with young people. But I wonder to what extent this has required tacit support for the commodification of women. If that’s the case, we should not be surprised that notwithstanding our values as child and youth care practitioners, the systems and institutions in which we work continue to commodify the young people as an extension of ‘women as commodity’. Ultimately, relational practices are certainly a good thing; but these too require integration into a worldview, or a meta-theoretical orientation. And a feminism that fundamentally centers the lives of racialized women seems like a meaningful way to respond to young people whose lives are very much reliant on the fate of their ‘mothers’ (I use the term ‘mother’ not to denote an individual but a community role that is often performed by women, elders, land and nature, and others actively disassociating from the mother/father roles binary).