CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 271 SEPTEMBER 2021

Wellness in the Post-Secondary Classroom

Patricia Kostouros

Post-secondary teachers have a significant role in supporting wellness in the classroom. In particular, knowing there is an increase in students entering post-secondary education with existing mental health concerns, our classroom supports and strategies need to be considered. It is hoped that the content in this article will spark a discussion about the need for teachers in Child and Youth Care programs to be thoughtful about how they appropriately support all students and how they understand those students who struggle with mental health concerns in their post-secondary classrooms.

Keywords

mental health, post-secondary, wellness, classroom supports, post-secondary self-care. 

 

After many years of teaching in the post-secondary system in a Child and Youth Care program I can attest to seeing more students arriving in class with academic accommodations for mental health concerns, particularly anxiety. Certainly, there is a movement afoot to support young adults who have been in foster care, and have experienced mental health concerns, to complete post-secondary studies (Phillips et al., 2015). With appropriate support and preparation, those with mental health concerns are able to meaningfully engage in their chosen field of study. While many students who enter post-secondary education have existing concerns, some, including those without existing mental health concerns, experience post-secondary stressors such that their mental health begins to suffer.   

Keyes et al. (2012) noted that the onset of a mental health concern is often related to the developmental period of college and university students. Keyes et al. suggested that the prevalence of mental health concerns in the college and university population is increasing. For example, these authors stated that, “mental illness in the form of depression and anxiety is prevalent among college students, a finding consistent with previous studies” (p. 130). These researchers also noted that the absence of a mental disorder does not necessary mean that one is mentally well. In addition, Keyes et al. showed that mental wellness can act as a protective factor.

According to the National College Health Assessment (American College Health Assessment, Canadian reference, 2016) as many as 33% of students feel stressed to the point of it impacting their academic success. While academic success may be affected so is the post-secondary classroom. For example, students with high anxiety and minimal coping skills may be unable to engage in face-to-face activities such as role play, group dialogue or respond to unanticipated questions. Many students who experience mental health concerns need increased support directly in the classroom, not only from academic accommodations for exams and papers. Therefore, post-secondary teachers could create a classroom that reduces stress for all students not only the ones who struggle with mental health concerns. Doing so is likened to universal design.

 It is important to think about mental health not as something someone has or does not have but rather something that is fluid. For example, an individual may have many things going on such as exams, a break up with a partner, unexpected financial burdens or illness. Several stressors at once can affect one’s mental health temporarily, particularly if there is a limited support system. As well, skills that have been acquired to manage stress will also play a part in how one copes with stress and therefore, how mental health is affected. An individual may feel bogged down and even depressed when these things happen all at once, but then the person gets an A on their exam, and their mood starts to shift; hence mental health can change with circumstances. Sometimes, however, an individual’s mood does not change with circumstances and a mental health condition is more fixed.

A Continuum Approach

In an effort to move beyond the dichotomized approach to mental health, Keyes (2002) described a mental health continuum that has both a horizontal and a vertical pole. On one end of the vertical pole is flourishing, meaning optimum wellness, and on the other end is languishing, meaning poor mental health or illness. On the horizontal pole, Keyes (2002) described serious mental illness at one end and no symptoms of distress at all at the opposite end. Keyes (2010) also explained that no one is ever at one end of the pole or the other all of the time. We all experience stressors, as noted above, and this can create less wellness, but may not take us to the extreme ends of the poles. Someone may experience a mental health problem but still flourish.  Those who experience multiple symptoms, making it difficult to engage in activities and relationships, could languish for a period of time. In addition, Keyes (2002) suggested that “mental health is not merely the absence of mental illness” (p. 208), rather, flourishing is emotional and social “vitality” (p. 208) and languishing consists of lower levels of positive functioning.

Interestingly, Keyes (2010) found that most people fall somewhere in the middle and are neither flourishing nor languishing. Keyes et al. (2012) found that of those in their study who had a diagnosed mental health condition, only 2% were languishing and of those without a diagnosis 1.6% were languishing.  Therefore, recognizing that post-secondary students are still growing and developing, it is important to acknowledge that mental health labels are not necessarily static. Students generally move between flourishing and languishing depending on their experiences and how others respond. Therefore, the post-secondary teacher could make a difference in assisting students to maintain their wellness.

Languishing Students and Teacher Role

Before going further, it is important to acknowledge that some students are simply languishing to the point that their academic success is at a higher-risk and they may have to leave their education for a period rather than limp along trying desperately to manage. In these cases, acknowledging the struggle is necessary and sometimes teachers can see behaviours and symptoms that the individual has a difficult time recognizing. Referrals to college and university wellness services or even outside resources could be the best option in those cases.

I have witnessed many students attempt to maintain their studies when they are not well, and this may exacerbate their challenges. Often, this is enabled by well-meaning teachers who want to help. As teachers in helper programs, helping comes more easily to us. However, the students are not the children and youth with whom we work. We need to remember that we are helping students to gain professional skills such as reliability, communication, conflict resolution, problem solving and trustworthiness. These skills will help them do well in their careers. Therefore, if we are going to assist post-secondary students to flourish, or at least not to languish, in our post-secondary classrooms, then it helps to have an understanding about when a student is languishing to the point that deeper help is necessary and completing their studies is no longer a priority. In other words, well-meaning teachers could be contributing to the student languishing when we do not intervene with expectations that the student receive appropriate help.

We are teaching a human service (Child and Youth Care) and although we do need to have boundaries, we also need to be relational. It is the natural inclination of human service teachers to want to assist students when they struggle and in some ways such circumstances may lead teachers to become the ‘helper’ of the students. Of course, such conditions also have the potential for teachers to create dependency among their students, particularly those with mental health concerns.   

If teachers enter into a dual relationship this could also create a therapeutic relationship, which Palmer (2007) noted as inappropriate in a learning environment. When teachers inappropriately take the place of outside supports for their students, it is easy to slip into a therapeutic role. However, boundaries need to be established and both the teacher and the student need to recognize this necessity. Therefore, it is the responsibly of teachers to clarify their relationships with students and to ensure they maintain appropriate limits. If teachers are not clear, then they risk slipping down a slope that is good for neither the teacher nor the student.

Supporting students to access their supports is an important position for the post-secondary teacher to take. One reason is related to the reduction of stigma. When a teacher supports students to use mental health resources and can talk openly about the programs on campus and the need for accessing these services, the message to the student could be that the teacher is aware of and in support of these programs. Talking openly about campus wellness supports can normalize seeking help, and this could reduce stigma. When we allow students to languish and talk only to us we might perpetuate the hidden nature of mental health concerns.  Another reason we would want to talk about accessing services is the knowledge that students who receive information gain mental health literacy, and when they have literacy they are more likely to access services. Mental health literacy leads to students accessing resources when needed (Kutcher, Wei & Morgan, 2016).

It is also important to talk about the differences between those students who take on too much – such as outside work – and cannot tend to their homework, or those who procrastinate, from those who are languishing due to a mental health concern. Those who are struggling with a mental health concern are more likely to express a strong desire to meet expectations and often try hard to succeed but are unable to due to the distress experienced from the concern. For example, a student with extreme anxiety may have difficulty with regulating their breathing or heart rate and therefore, when they attempt to sit still to study, the sound of their heart pumping loudly may cause more fear, creating distorted thinking and making it difficult to concentrate. The student who is procrastinating or working too much will have other reasons for their inability to study or be prepared for classes. When a student says they are tired we might want to inquire about what the cause of the tiredness is; lack of sleep from too much overtime at work, or an inability to sleep due to worry and anxiety.

Components of Wellness

Often when we think about mental health, we think about it in terms of illness and not wellness.  Recognizing when students are feeling and doing well can provide information to use as teachers as to when and what we might want to adjust in our classes.  The components of wellness as described by Keyes (2010) are related to well-being in the areas of emotion, social and psychological health. In his model Keyes suggested that the vertical pole reflects hedonic tendencies, meaning feeling good. The horizontal pole reflects eudemonic tendencies, meaning functioning well, or as Keyes puts it, flourishing.    

Emotional Well-being

Emotional well-being is having a stable positive affect, or generally a positive disposition. When someone feels well emotionally, they are generally happy and satisfied with life. It might be possible to recognize an emotionally well student by noticing a stable positive mood.  These students tend to respond to challenges with an open attitude, excited about learning and typically respond well to feedback, knowing it will benefit them in courses and in life. These are students who take more risks in classes, are often the first to appropriately respond and can keep things in perspective, particularly when the stressors of exams and papers begin to weigh other students down.

 Social Well-being

When someone thinks they belong and are socially accepted then they are more likely to contribute to the positive dynamics of the class. Students who flourish in social well-being are open and accepting of others. These are the students who welcome others to group discussions and projects, even those who are rejected by others. Keyes (2010) described that social well-being includes social coherence and integration. When someone is socially coherent it means they recognize their bond with others in the world and attend to relationships. For students who are not well, we could see more isolation, showing less coherence and integration with others. In addition, the student who is languishing might not strive to belong and may not make efforts to contribute to class discussions or small group class activities.  

Psychological Well-being

To be psychologically well means to have perspective about life and living. An individual who is on the flourishing end of the continuum will accept themselves, knowing that in time and through experiences they will grow personally and professionally. To distinguish a student who is either near the flourishing or languishing end of a pole in psychological well-being you might recognize those who have positive relationships with others, including the teacher, are independent and have mastery in the environment. In a post-secondary class mastery might be taking responsibility for their reading, having it completed, and being able to ask critical questions. A person with mastery will not necessarily know the answers but will be actively curious and able to say so by asking questions, clarifying misunderstandings and can do so in front of others. Those closer to the languishing end will likely be embarrassed to ask questions, will not want to be wrong, are less likely to follow through on homework or readings and will express a desire to be successful but have a sense of hopelessness about their ability.    

Classroom Supports

Often those teaching in post-secondary who also have a human service background have difficulty deciding how strict to be in their role as a teacher while also being a support for those who struggle with mental health concerns. It is clear, however, that a dual role is inappropriate so finding a balance between proper support and referrals, as well as boundary and limit setting, is important. When a student informs a teacher about a mental health concern it might be helpful but it might not. It is helpful when that students knows what they already need and is accessing support but is telling the teacher in case there is a need to change direction in their program. It is not helpful when the teacher responds by lowering expectations and prolonging stressors.

Teachers may want to think about their classroom as a trauma informed environment.  While mental health concerns may not have emerged due to a trauma history, it has been shown that a trauma informed environment can create a health community (Bloom, 2005). For the most part, being trauma informed means that the classroom is safe through being consistent and trustworthy as well as transparent. In addition, teachers encourage peer support and allow for choice and voice. It may be unusual for students to be in a classroom that has this model since they have been prepared since childhood to give over to authority (Petersen, 1992). Sometimes students do not want choice or voice and it can be confusing when they are asked to collaborate. For example, I often ask students how they want to proceed with an activity, something like: “Would you like to debrief after the entire activity or after each station?” It is not unusual for me to receive eye rolls and “Just decide, you’re the teacher.”  Once I explain the concept of shared power, they understand why I ask for input.

Teachers can support those with mental health concerns by potentially taking up ideas that have been supported by the Better Futures program (Phillips, et al, 2015). While the Better Futures program is designed for youth who are or have been in foster care to prepare for post-secondary, some of the concepts are helpful for supporting mental health in any class. For example, the use of peer mentors, coaching, mutual support, information and resource sharing.

Knowing that all students have some level of anxiety in certain activities, it is possible to design them so that students can engage without being overwhelmed. For example, role play might be done with a role for those with social anxiety to use their phone to record and load to the teaching screen (ensuring permission from the role players). The student who is anxious might take notes for the class or find a small involvement in the role play. Of course, if role play is a part of an expected assignment, this can also be modified, for example, having the players complete the task in a campus space that is less intimidating. 

Some students will have test anxiety but will not have a diagnosis that would allow them to use the accommodation resources. There are several anxiety reducing techniques that can be used before and during an exam that benefits the entire class. For example, I give out mandalas and pencil crayons and remind students that when they are relaxed they are more likely to think better. So, when they become anxious due to not recalling information, I suggest they begin to colour; this helps them relax and often they have an easier time with recall. Slides with calming pictures could be playing in the background, without sound. As well, prior to the exam the class could begin with a deep breathing exercise.

In addition, I have created assignments that are directly related to self-care and researched the effectiveness (Kostouros & Bennett, 2017) and continue to do so. In the aforementioned article, we looked at a particular tool known as BreathingRoomTM  (Paccagnan, et al., 2012) which was originally developed as a depression resiliency tool for youth ages 13-24 years old.  Since using that tool, my assignment has morphed into a choice of self-care tools and self-care plans, which is also presently being researched for the effectiveness of having a self-care curriculum.

Keyes (2010) also noted the importance of helping others as a protective factor for languishing. In a class that I no longer teach I had an assignment that was related to random acts of kindness, on which they would report each week. They then wrote a paper about this in terms of how it impacted their wellness. While some teachers might be asking how any of this relates to certain curriculum, my response would be that there are ways to make it relevant and to think about the big picture of how, after graduation, students enter the field and how they care for others because they are able to care for themselves.       

There are many ways for students to engage in wellness outside of the classroom, such as staying physically fit, eating well, engaging in yoga or meditation and being social. Inside the classroom it is more challenging as this is where stressors might increase as teachers talk about challenging concepts, have expectations and describe assignments and due dates.  It can be helpful after describing an assignment to use the strategy of think-pair-share, and have the students discuss what they understand about the assignment and any concerns they might have and come up with questions.  By sharing their understanding and concerns, the potential for peers to support them and to demystify the assignment expectations can decrease anxiety.

Field Readiness

Our goal as teachers in Child and Youth Care is to support students to do well and be well so that they can enter the field ready to support those who will rely on them for support. All human service work is difficult, including Child and Youth Care, and is better achieved when one is healthy and able to cope with the challenges that are inherent in the work. If someone is struggling with their wellness before they even enter the field, there is a good chance that those who need them will not receive appropriate support.   

When we encourage wellness strategies and self-care in the classroom we may assist students to begin a wellness routine that will be carried into their professional life. In this field we know that wellness is necessary and have seen the impact of compassion fatigue. We also know that the system we work within can lead to burnout. Wellness is not something that should be mentioned in a few classes as important then dropped. Self-care needs to be taught, as many students may not have been exposed to self-care strategies. We know that self-care can impact mental health concerns, particularly when stressors from school build. When we add self-care as an expectation we support all post-secondary students to flourish.  

References

American College Health Association. American Health Association-National College Health Assessment II: Canadian Reference Group, Executive Summary (2016).

Bloom, S. L. (2005). The Sanctuary Model of Organizational Change for Children’s Residential Treatment. Therapeutic Community. The International Journal for Therapeutic and Supportive Organizations 26(1): 65-81.

Keyes, C. L. M. (2002). The mental health continuum: From languishing to flourishing in life. Journal of Health and Behavior Research, 43, 207–222.

Keyes, C. L. M. (2010).  Flourishing. In I. Wierner, & W.B. Craighead, (Eds) Corsini Encyclopedia of Psychology.  Wiley & Sons. DOI:10.1002/9780470479216.corpsy0363

Keyes, C. L. M., Eisenberg, D., Perry, G. S., Dube, S. R., Kroenke, K., & Dhingra, S. S. (2012). The relationship of level of positive mental health with current mental disorders in predicting suicidal behavior and academic impairment in college students. Journal of American College Health, 60(2), 126-133.

Kostouros, P. & Bennett, D. (2017). Caring about student self-care. Transformative Dialogues, 10(3).

Kutcher, S., Wei, Y., & Morgan, C.  (2016).  Mental health literacy in post-secondary students.  Health Education Journal, 75(6), 689-697.  DOI:10.1177/0017896915610144

Paccagnan, P., Moritz, S., Rickhi, N., Dennis, C., Malhotra, S., Hart, C. & Cohen, J. (2012).  Recruitment experiences from piloting the LEAP project: an online spirituality based depression intervention for young adults.  Scientific abstract presented at the International Research Congress on Integrative Medicine and Health.  12(1), DOI: 10.1186/1472-6882-12-S1-P166.

Palmer, P. (2007). The courage to teach: Exploring the inner landscape of a teacher’s life. San Francisco, CA: John Wiley & Sons.

Petersen, M (1992). At personal risk. New York, New York: Norton.

Phillips, L. A., Powers, L. E., Geenen, S., Schmidt, J., Winges-Yanez, N., McNeely I. The research Consortium to Increase Success of Youth in Foster Care (2015). Better futures: A validated model for increasing postsecondary preparation and participation of youth in foster care with mental health challenges. Child and Youth Services review, 57, 50-59, doi.org/10.1016/j.childyouth.2015.010

 

Originally published in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 31, No.1, pp50-59.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App