CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 271 SEPTEMBER 2021

Entanglements: The personal is political and vis a versa

Hans Skott-Myhre

I am often struck by the kinds of arguments that simplistically pose one thing against another. I have spent most of my career, as an online worker, supervisor, and academic arguing that life is an ecology that can’t realistically be split into sets of two. For those of us who are committed to life space work, it is crucial that we take the “life” part of that phrase seriously and resist the temptation to divide the world into abstract social categories such as children, adults, families, individuals, male, female, raced, and so on. While these are sometimes an easy shorthand we use to find common descriptions of the world, they are also brutal modes of exclusion for those people who don’t recognize themselves in these ways of speaking. They create frameworks that include and exclude rather than complex webs of living creative capacity that affirm difference.

To break the world of living things into linguistic truisms that claim to describe the way things are, is to act within a set of power relations that forecloses and denies. Indeed, following Foucault, I would argue that all language is saturated with power relations and that to imagine there is any neutral ground where one could be free of power is a dangerous delusion.

In that sense, all sets of relations are inherently political and entail the negotiation of power across any given social ecology. If we think of politics as a complex expression of force, then the power being negotiated is literally the flow of life as it manifests in the creation of all things living and inanimate. Power is not something anyone can possess or command. It always exceeds any ability to control or contain it.

In this view of power relations, the ability to assess the ecological conditions that give rise to assertions of force that restrict and restrain living capacity becomes the grounds for liberatory or even revolutionary action. In another term, the ability to perform an ecological reading of the conditions and expressions of force within any given social configuration is the basis for our ability to increase the capacities we have for expression and creativity. We might well say that, to understand the logic of any social system, such as capitalism, that seeks to parasitically feed on life, is essential to defend and protect future generations.

In this sense, politics and the political cannot be reduced to any kind of reductive analysis. Instead, we need models that acknowledge and encompass a complex and dynamic reading of our current situation as anything other than fixed. There are certainly those who would suggest that the current system is too powerful and effective to be successfully challenged. They would argue that there have been too many failed attempts over the scope of its historical trajectory. Indeed, they might suggest that we simply need to figure out how to survive within the belly of the beast with as much dignity and grace as possible.

For myself, I would point out that all empires fall and that as Martin Luther King said, “the arc of the moral universe is long but bends towards justice.” Without a doubt, we live in a time when the dominant system of control is the most extensive and effective the world has ever known. Global capitalism saturates every corner of the globe at every level of our daily lived experience. Any reasonable analysis would have to acknowledge its all-pervasive influence. In that respect, it is a bit like the Borg on the old series Star Trek. The Borg, in that series, is a cybernetic organism that comprises a hive mind. As an organism it appropriates the technology and knowledge of other species by forcibly transforming individual beings into drones.

Clearly, there are resonances with global capitalism and the viral spread of media and virtual platforms across all elements of our lives. In fact, one could argue that our very sense of identity is increasingly mediated through our representations of ourselves on social Media platforms. The Borg’s claim is that resistance is futile because its mode of appropriation and exploitation is inevitable and constitutes a drive towards perfection that is evolutionarily predetermined. For some of us, this also feels true of the current state of Empire. It can seem at times, as though resistance is futile and that global capitalism is the end of history. It will always be like this.

Of course, there is no actual historical necessity for capitalism to persist. It is simply one way to organize a society. There are an infinitude of other options and possibilities. But the force and scope of capitalism in our time can make any substantive change seem unrealistic. Indeed, sometimes it feels as though the more we analyze the way capitalism controls its subjects, the more it can seem hopeless that we will ever escape its grasp.

Foucault was once accused of providing detailed analysis of modes of social control in such a way as to make any resistance appear hopeless. He responded by saying that reading his work in this way was an error. That in fact, within every account of domination and control there were also accounts of perpetual and ongoing acts of resistance. He argued that all systems of control and discipline are always failing, because they are trying to contain and restrict the creative force of life itself. Systems of Empire are constantly having to modify their methods of control to account for the fact that living force is defeating their old approaches all the time. It is a process of ongoing struggle, but life is always escaping, creating, and  bending the arc of history to its advantage.

I raise all of this in light of concerns being raised by some of my colleagues about a “political turn” in CYC. This is a concern that has been articulated on and off over the years and it seems to be centered around a binary framework which poses politics against individual care. As I understand it, there is a worry that if we get too involved in trying to shift social conditions, we will lose track of caring for individual young people we encounter in our work. The argument seems to be that there is a clear division between working relationally with young people and being an activist who work towards greater degrees of equity and justice.

Underlying this is an apparent assumption that working with young people as individuals can be done without engaging the broader field of social injustice. That it is possible to escape the political and just work with kids. Indeed, there may also be a fear that if we consider the broader political landscape and bring it into our work, we will be so distracted by politics as to lose sight of the young person in front of us. We might start reading them as simply a representation of our political ideology. If we see them as oppressed or living under conditions of oppression, we might start to see them as victims and maybe even encourage them to take on a victimized persona. It has been suggested that clinical fields such a social work have taken on this political trend to the detriment of their practice. Not only has the world not gotten any better, but they are doing less and less good work with individual young people.

Not surprisingly, I don’t find such arguments very convincing. I teach and work in a Social Work and Human Services Department with a clinical practice focus on the Social Work (MSW) side and a relational approach quite similar to CYC on the Human Services side (BSc). Both programs take an overtly social justice orientation to their practice and I would have to say I have not seen it negatively impact the work our students do with individuals either clinically or relationally. Instead, I would say it broadens and deepens their ability to engage and deal practically with real world issues of injustice and inequity. From my perspective, to split the personal from the political is both inexplicable and a strong political statement in and of itself.

As I have been arguing all along, politics and relations of force saturate all aspects of our lived experience. When we encourage a certain myopia by putting on political blinders in order to do our work, it could be argued that we are simply supporting the existing status quo. When we don’t engage the forces of poverty, injustice racism, exclusion, and bigotry as they impact on the loves of the person in front of us, we lose the opportunity to assist a young person in challenging the status quo that is so toxic to them, their family, and community. I would argue that if we resist this call to a kind of false political innocence, then far from opening up an identity as victim, we have the opportunity to join young people in creating a better world as an engaged and active citizen.

In this regard, perhaps we could borrow the old feminist slogan “the personal is political.” That is to say that all politics is built from ground up in an infinitude of small person to person interactions, that when put together form our sense of what society is and what we can do as social beings. Certainly, our work as CYC practitioners is one of these interactions that moment by moment, interchange by interchange, builds the world in which we all live. After all, what we call the political system is created and sustained by us. It is our work that keeps it going.

Recently, there have been a number of manifestos by young people accusing adults of betraying them. These have been predominantly focused on climate change and the fact that adults are still doing almost nothing to avoid an ecological disaster for future generations. It would seem to me, that when we suggest that we should step aside from politics and focus on the young person in front of us, we are taking a very narrow view of what care looks like. How can we legitimately claim to be building trust, while betraying the future in which they will live? Can we honestly say that their ability to breath, drink clean water, not have their homes washed away or destroyed by fire, earthquakes and so on is outside the scope of our work? This seems to me almost willfully negligent. Certainly, an increasing number of young people are claiming just that. They are saying loudly that adults need to be more accountable to the future.

The political and the personal are profoundly and deeply intertwined. They cannot be separated. Anything we do or say in the company of young people is a political act that either supports the status quo or moves to try and change it. There is no place of innocence. We are either complicit with a system that is overtly toxic to the future of the young people we serve or we can work together with them to create a new future. Either way is political and the political is always personal, whether we want to admit it or not. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App