CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 271 SEPTEMBER 2021

Needs-based and Desire-based Practice in Child and Youth Care

Kiaras Gharabaghi

The Characteristics of Child and Youth Care Practice (Garfat et al., 2018) are quite explicit in situating our practice as needs-based. In simple terms, we are to gear our practice to be responsive to the needs of individual young people and ideally, we determine those needs in partnership with the young person. Being responsive to needs is intuitively a good idea. When needs are met, other things become possible. Still, the framing of the practice as needs-based gives rise to some potential tensions. For example, needs refer to things that should be present but are not. In other words, they refer to gaps, or deficits, in the way a young person’s life at a given moment manifests. This is challenging in a practice that aims to be strengths-based and creates at least a language tension with respect to the longstanding binary of strengths versus deficits. It also can create a logic that isn’t entirely true; we may be tempted to think that other things are not possible because specific needs have not been met. Perhaps most fundamentally, there is always the question of how we situate the concept of needs. Why are some things considered a need? Who determines what is needed to live life well? Whose worldview and whose lived experiences are impacting this process, even when young people themselves are partnered with practitioners in determining their needs?

Sometimes the construction of needs is quite explicitly political, or at the very least convenient, for those in positions of power. For example, in schools, young people are told they have needs related to character traits and values, such as being respectful, honest, trustworthy, tolerant, and so on. Even a mild exploration of what that really means provides clarity that this need is a need of the school for students that are compliant with and conforming to institutional norms. Why do young people have a need to be respectful and honest? Most ‘successful’ and powerful leaders in our societies are neither of these things; just think of recent American presidents, South African presidents, or well-known corporate leaders at Amazon, Facebook or Google. They did not get to what they understand to be the ‘good life’ by ensuring that these kinds of needs are met.

A different way of constructing child and youth care practice is to focus on a desire-based approach. Instead of focusing on the needs young people identify in partnership with practitioners, we focus on the desires they identify for themselves and for their present and future lives as well as for the memory or narrative of their life already lived. I am borrowing the term ‘desire-based practice’ from Eve Tuck (2009), a Native American scholar who coined this term in the context of research approaches in and with Indigenous communities. Desire is a much more unruly concept than needs, largely because it isn’t constructed on the bases of empirical, rational or objective criteria. Instead, desire can include many different elements that range from our sexual identities and practices to our spiritual orientations, our relationships, our economic Self and our political engagement in the society around us. Another characteristic of desire is that it is difficult to measure or identify when a desire has been met or achieved. In fact, desire is much more dynamic than need, often shifting its orientation and substance with little warning. And yet, all of us are in the business of pursuing desire in one way or another, and sometimes we learn in the process that we need things to help us pursue our desires more effectively or more meaningfully. In that process, needs are generated through the pursuit of desire instead of being determined as a foundation for rendering desires realistic. At the same time, sometimes we may pursue our desires and find out that we don’t really need some of the things we thought we would need; the pathways to desire are plentiful and quite varied, a journey filled with choices, opportunities, and failures.

Needs and desires are not mutually exclusive. One might even argue that we have a need to pursue our desires, just as much as we desire to have our needs met. Therefore, thinking about the framing of our practice is not a binary exercise of deciding to go with a needs-based approach over a desire-based approach or vice versa. But it is a way of resolving tensions in our practice differently, and it offers an opportunity to resolve what is sometimes constructed as the binary of individually based, interpersonal practice on the one hand, and system-focused and often advocacy-centered practice on the other hand. This binary is described and discussed in Jack Phelan’s article in this journal from last month (August 2021) and you can read about it here:  https://cyc-net.org/cyc-online/aug2021.pdf. Overall, I take no issue with Jack’s arguments about the importance and the value of interpersonal practice, but I disagree with the premise that a system and advocacy focus on practice somehow distracts from or renders less meaningful or effective interpersonal practice. I think instead that when this dynamic is observed (and I too have observed it), it is a function of insufficient competence and poor practice rather than some inherent relationship between dialectical movements in what Jack has constructed as a binary.

A desire-based practice allows us to center ways in which young people not only view their own developmental pathways and relational engagements (which indeed calls for an interpersonal practice), but also the society, the communities, and the spiritualities that engulf these (which calls for a more system and advocacy-focused practice). In short, to the extent that our field has always been interested in some version of Bronfenbrenner’s ecological perspectives, a desire-based framework for practice simply renders what Bronfenbrenner represented as an only partially dynamic system as a fully dynamic system. It essentially mitigates the containment elements of Bronfenbrenner’s concentric circles (in which sub-systems are literally contained in their entirety by other sub-systems).

Needs that flow from the pursuit of desires are anchored in fluidity. Much like a boat anchored in soft and muddy ground beneath the sea cannot be static, desire-based practices call for constant fluidity in our engagements with particular young people and young people as a social group. A needs-based practice is anchored in the material world as it is. The boat is trapped by its connection to rocks and other more static and set objects underwater. It must endure whatever comes its way. If the weather turns bad, it must endure it. If other boats crowd its space, it must endure it. If people invade the boat’s deck, it must endure it. In short, it seems to me that needs-based practices have, as their best-case scenario, the effect of helping young people endure – which is why resilience as a concept is inadequate from a social justice perspective. It is the concept of the status quo. Desire-based practices have, even when they fail, at least the effect of opening possibilities for living life on one’s own terms and shaping life in community such that needs serve desire rather than desire being limited to what we are told our met needs will allow.

References

Garfat, T.; Freeman, J.; Gharabaghi, K; Fulcher, L. (2018). Characteristics of a Child and Youth Care Approach Revisited. CYC-Online, 236.

Tuck, E. (2009). Suspending Damage: A Letter to Communities. Harvard Educational Review, 79 (3), 409-427.

 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App