CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 151 SEPTEMBER 2011

Commandment 5: Encourage Responsibility, Not Accountability

Gerry Fewster

I know a lot about accountability. At my ‘Christening,’ my parents and God signed an agreement that I should become a “good boy,” directly accountable to all three parties, or their appointed representatives. It took a while for me to figure out my part in the contract but, according to evaluations kept by my beloved elder brother, my infant demands were excessive, my howling was intolerable and I did things in public that should only have been done in the bathroom. Not a good start.

Thankfully, God never showed up in those days, although we always passed his house on the way to the park. Still, my parents persevered and slowly I began to understand my obligations. While it was never actually stated, somewhere in my infantile mind I just knew I’d end up with the monsters in the Welton Canal if I didn’t. So I learned to smile a lot, hug my aunts and uncles, say “sorry” to my victims, shed the odd perfunctory tear and shrink in shame for my transgressions. At times of crisis, “I love you Mummy” was a guaranteed life-safer.

At the age of three, I was so successful that my mother actually told the butcher I was a “good boy” and my brother noted in his log that I’d become a pathetic little suck – or words to that effect. By that time, I was smart enough to make sure that my contract violations were rarely spotted and my only punishments were occasional admonishments and transitory bouts of guilt that kept me awake and prevented me from making eye contact for a couple of hours. It was a small price to pay. But then I was sent to Sunday School in the garage beside God’s house. He wasn’t there but his agents were out in force to spell out the details of the contract – as it was written in the big black Policy Manual my Grandmother kept by her bedside. The accountability thing became a pervasive and diabolical trap.

The problem with God is that His monitoring system is impeccable and His evaluations are indisputable. Because He knows all and sees all, He was onto me before I actually said or did anything. Denial was no longer an option – I was a wretched sinner and there was no point in pretending otherwise. I couldn’t even hide my failings from my parents as God was surely spilling the beans at their team meetings. So I hid from my own blackness and continued to keep up appearances as well as I could.

Then there were the consequences. No quick slaps or lost privileges from the Big Guy, only the threat of thunderbolts and eternal damnation – pretty powerful stuff when you’ve only just graduated from diapers. As I discovered later, my parents had foolishly signed the Protestant contract so there was no forgiveness dispensed by surrogate ‘fathers’ in carved packing cases. For me, guilt and punishment were identical. All I had to work with was the “forgive us our trespasses” line but that was too general and I gave up all hope of every getting a favorable evaluation.

When I was dragged off to school I decided my teachers were not part of the Holy alliance so God would not be hanging around the classroom or playground. I wanted to do well, to be accountable, but my grade one teacher made it painfully obvious that my academic potential was no better than my moral and behavioral inclinations. When I was drafted into the school choir I thought it might be an opportunity to get God on my side. So I sang his praises loudly at the daily services in the hope of redemption. But even this was shattered when I was identified as one of the terrorists responsible for the mysterious death of the vicar’s beloved budgie.

I won’t trouble you any further with the details of my youthful struggle to become accountable to a higher authority. Suffice to say that by the time I entered High School I had given up on God, just as He had obviously given up on me. I still had the sneaking suspicion He was watching me playing solo in my bed at night, but since I was already condemned, it didn’t really matter if I did go blind. At the same time, I was firmly convinced that I would never meet the expectations of parents and teachers, so they could all join me in Hell. I did only what was absolutely necessary. I cheated when I could and did everything possible to deflect my accusers and avoid the consequences of my transgressions. The quest for survival was so all-consuming that I had no idea of my own ‘rightness’ and who I really was. But that didn’t seem to matter either.

Then I met my savior – a renegade schoolteacher who made his expectations clear and convinced me of my ability to succeed. At last I had a chance to become accountable and, within a matter of months, my academic performance turned around. To the delight of my parents and the bemusement of my teachers, I was heading for success, and with God no longer in the equation, I delighted in my newfound ability to comply with what was left of the original contract. I still had no idea who I was and made no decisions on my own behalf but, thanks to my mentor, I was on a roll. When I received my Ph.D., my parents and my guide had passed on but I had something to show to whoever might still want to hold me accountable – a professional at last.

Self-responsibility or Accountability: Take Your Pick

So, why have I told you all this? Hopefully, my story has illustrated how the demands for accountability can confuse and sabotage the simple quest of the fledgling Self to become known and expressed through relationships. When we use these external expectations to control children, we may believe we are encouraging them to overcome their assumed deficits and develop their true potential. Well, chances are we will be doing the very opposite – suppressing the Self by imposing our expectations and dishing out rewards for becoming who we think they should be and what we think they should do. This is a very seductive prospect for kids who already feel they are failures in the eyes of significant others and external authority. The successful ones may bask in their achievements, but on the inside, a fledgling Self remains a passive observer, unseen and, for the most part, unexplored.

Self-responsibility denotes the Self in action. People who are self-responsible become the authors of their own lives rather than follow the prescriptions laid down by others. Their central concern is with their own integrity and their sense of worth is drawn from mastery and personal satisfaction, rather than achievement and acclamation. They are more likely to feel ashamed than guilty, and purposefully avoid the role of ‘victim’. What they present to the world are expressions of their own authenticity, rather than images of who they have come to believe they should be.

From a developmental perspective, Self-responsibility, Self-Esteem and Self-Actualization are integrated aspects of the same process. All can be encouraged and nurtured externally, but the essential driving force comes from the inside – an acknowledged Self seeking to become expressed and elaborated through contact with other Selves. Obviously there’s no stage of completion – no absolute state of Self-responsibility. Developmentally, the key issue is to determine in which direction
the person is moving along the continuum and take it from there. The one certainty is that if there is no Self in the action, there can be no Self-responsibility.

So, as a Child and Youth Care professional, you have a choice to make. Do you want to nurture the development of a young person’s sense of Self to become responsible– or are you more inclined to make kids accountable to whatever the criteria your program specifies? Your answer will, of course, depend upon whether you are moving toward Self-responsibility yourself, or trying to be accountable to those who want you to fix kids? Sorry to be so blunt about this, but that’s just the way it is. If you’re ready to support kids in moving toward higher levels of Self-development and responsibility you must work toward creating a space for the Self to find its voice. For this, I would offer the following suggestions. Many of these approaches have been, or will be, discussed more comprehensively other articles in this series.

Self-Work

Always be curious about what a young person is thinking and feeling. Gently let your interest be known, but don’t push. Unless you’re conducting some meaningless diagnostic interview, or investigating a triple homicide, any response to your curiosity is acceptable – including no response at all. If you can’t stand rejection, take another look at your own abandonment stuff before moving on. Keep in mind that the primary object is to invite a fragile, and often fearful, Self to step forward and be known. I like to call this “Self-work”. The focus is upon process rather than content so try not to get hooked on your interpretations or judgments for whatever might be expressed. Focus on being fully present and engaged in the moment – there’s nothing for you to do but show up, so breathe and relax. Above all be patient – remember that, deep down, every kid on this planet wants to be seen and heard by a caring and trustworthy adult ... yea, even that kid.

It’s always possible that Self-work opportunities will arise spontaneously, but a professional will make sure they occur as appropriate. The most spontaneous form is to take a few moments during and event or activity to examine what might be happening on the inside – thoughts and, particularly, feelings. All that matters is for both parties to be fully present and connected. This doesn’t mean the inside experience has to be shared – only that it’s there to be explored. The more familiar and comfortable a person becomes with their inner world, the more they are likely to accept a standing invitation to share.
More predictable opportunities for Self-work can be built into the daily routines. Most of us move through the day with very little reference to the Self, but this is particularly the case for the kids we work with. Setting aside time at the end of the day for reflection often works best.

It’s not about what happened at school or over dinner but what was being experienced on the inside at the time. This is not a counseling session. The object of the exercise is to bring the Self into the action after the fact, as a reflective entity – a vital aspect of Self-responsibility. The skill of the adult during such sessions is to learn how to stay out of the reflective process other than to facilitate and seek clarification where appropriate.

The most direct access to feelings, and the dormant Self, is unquestionably through the breath. Effective breathing releases the natural flow of energy that has been frozen within the Self’s defensive structures and one full breath will often be more effective than hours of talking. In my opinion, learning how to use the breath in this way should be a natural element within the stock-in-trade of all Child and Youth Care practitioners and I will have much more to say about this topic in the next article.

The Mirror in the Face

In the journey toward the rediscovery of the Self, what kids need most is an effective and accurate mirror. I’ve written so much about mirroring over the years because I firmly believe it’s the most valuable skill in the Child and Youth Care tool kit. As this will also be a central topic in the next article, I will offer a brief overview of the concept here and elaborate later.

Within the literature, the term ‘mirroring’ is often used interchangeably with ‘reflective listening’ – a verbal communication technique made popular by Carl Rogers in which the therapist uses his or her own words to paraphrase what the client has just said. This is not what I mean by the term. From my perspective the only mirror that can reflect the Self is another Self. Words are effective to the degree that they express the internal experience of whoever is offering the mirror but there is much more involved when two Selves reflect the experience of each other. This is most powerfully observable in the spontaneous interaction between a mother and her baby. On the surface they may appear to be imitating one another, but beyond the sounds, movements and facial expressions it is clear that each is reflecting the experience of the other from the inside-out.

What happens between the mirror and the subject is more energetic than cognitive or verbal. Professionals who have mastered the art of mirroring are able to engage all facets of the Self in sensing and responding to the experience of an Other. Their very presence offers an unconditional invitation for Others to be seen and heard.

No Boundaries No Self

In order to exist as a separate and known entity, a Self must have a boundary. We define ourselves cognitively and experience ourselves emotionally but the Self is also an energetic presence that moves beyond the skin to make contact with other Selves. Gestalt Therapist Fritz Perls coined the term “contact boundary” to identify this place where one person ends and an Other begins. In Child and Youth Care, we often talk about boundaries when determining how far we will allow kids to impose themselves on our personal lives. Of course, people who have clear and effective boundaries are able to protect the Self by saying “no” but they are also able to make contact by saying “yes”. Because these decisions are made from the inside, they are, by definition, Self-responsible choices that reflect the ever-changing sensitivities at the contact boundary.

Working with kids who have poorly defined boundaries, or have constructed defensive walls in their place, is a delicate and sensitive task that reaches well beyond the scope of this article. Briefly stated, there are three major aspects to be considered. First and foremost, the practitioner must be able to show the way by establishing and maintaining clear personal boundaries that serve to enhance contact rather than create distance. Secondly, conditions must be created in which the young person can explore his or her own boundaries and experiment in sustaining them through relationships. Finally, both parties must be able set their own boundaries while recognizing and respecting the boundaries of the other. This is fascinating relational work and foundational in the development of Self responsibility.

Working With Behavior

While Self-responsibility is essentially the reflection of an internal state, it is also acquired, affirmed and reinforced through behavior. This is important for parents and professionals to understand, since much of their time with kids is focused on actions rather than reflections.

To encourage young people in bringing their Selves into the action, significant adults can move things along by simply enquiring about, and mirroring, unexpressed thoughts and feelings – don’t forget to breathe. Meanwhile, it’s generally the task of the adult to set limits and apply consequences, both negative and positive, for specific behaviors and actions. In moving toward Self-responsibility, the connection between the behavior and the consequences needs to be understood clearly, though not necessarily accepted amicably. The most essential ingredient in the sequence is that the internal experiences are expressed and heard – but NOT debated or turned into a power-struggle. This may mean that the adult must be prepared to tolerate brief outburst of excuses and accusations before getting to the central issue – the authentic feelings of a discontented Self. It is equally important to work through this same process when the consequences are perceived to be positive and the Self can enjoy some well-deserved satisfaction.

As a final note, if you’re looking for a practical behavioral model that incorporates the notion of Self-responsibility, you may wish to read (or re-read) William Glasser’s book Reality Therapy. Written in the 1960’s this still makes far more sense to me than the current psychiatric fad referred to as ‘Cognitive/Behavior Therapy. The basis of Glasser’s thesis is that there are always choices to be made and people can be supported in reviewing their options, making their own decisions and recognizing the outcomes as a Self created ‘reality.’ For me this will always be the preferred alternative to coercing kids into complying with an external authority in the name of accountability. You may or may not agree, but this is just one of the many questions Child and Youth Care practitioners are obliged to consider somewhere along the line.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App