CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 284 OCTOBER 2022

On The Wrong Side of History

Mark Smith

 

Editor’s Note 

This month we welcome back Dr Mark Smith from Scotland as a regular contributor to CYC-Online. Mark has been threatening a return to the regular contributors panel of CYC-Online having previously contributed monthly columns for over a decade. We are indeed fortunate that he has followed through on his threat! Welcome back, Mark.

 

I’ve a feeling I promised a comeback to a regular CYC-Online column a while back and it didn’t materialise, as I became ground down in what I remember Leon Fulcher calling, the administrivia of academia. I’m hoping it may be different this time round as I approach the final years of my academic career and intend to spend it drawing some of my writing together. In many ways my writing career, if it didn’t altogether start on CYC-Net, was certainly honed here; it is where I got into the writing habit that is key to academic writing. It is hard to believe that it is almost 20 years ago since I started to do a regular column. Returning to do one (I hope) will give me the opportunity to reflect on how some of my thoughts have developed over that period. As an aside, I am teaching a dissertation class to our social work students this semester and have been speaking to them about academic writing and how the act of writing does not just capture our thoughts but helps us construct them.

In columns I wrote in the past, I often picked up on a current news item as a prompt for my writing.  For much of this month, there has only been one news item in the UK – the death of Queen Elizabeth. Hold the condolences! I am not writing this column with a heavy heart. As an instinctive republican, I have never considered Queen Elizabeth (or any Royal) to be my queen (or king). I don’t bear the person of the dead Queen any ill-will - she just has never registered as a significant figure in my life. More broadly, I consider the institution of the monarchy to be an anachronism …. There I’ve said it! Others over the past couple of weeks have got into trouble for having the temerity to speak out against the period of extravagant and compulsory emoting orchestrated by the media, who I guess have been preparing this story for the past couple of decades and needed to milk it for all its worth.

If you’re reading this column from elsewhere in the world you would be forgiven for thinking that I am some outlier in expressing such seemingly discordant views. I’m not – around 30% of population of UK and around 40% in Scotland would express broadly republican or otherwise antithetical views on the monarchy, around the same proportion would be staunchly monarchist with a further ‘soft’ third in the middle, who might go either way. Many of those who lined the streets likely did so, less out of a sense of grief than a sense of history. Personally, I’m not against tradition, but I could think of other events to mark.

I should be able to leave things at this – some people marked the passing of the Queen, others didn’t and still others couldn’t care less. But we weren’t allowed such viewpoint diversity – as I signal above, people were arrested for expressing views, or even for holding posters objecting to aspects of the monarchy. Public figures, footballers among them, were castigated for failing to show respect by refusing to wear black armbands or to sing the national anthem. Those subject to such censure were either Irish or Scottish, both of which nationalities, whether one agrees or not, might point to good reason not to recognise, and certainly not to celebrate, the monarchy.

What has this got to do with CYC, you might ask? Well, it merely exaggerates broader cultural trends to impose moral constraints on what we are allowed to say, and more importantly, what we’re not allowed to say, all done under a banner of being virtuous or being on the right (or wrong) side of history. I still have enough of the (materialist) Marxist about me to hang on to his dictum to question everything. Yet, in the current climate, the very act of questioning can put one on the wrong side of history – and when that happens, your views do not need to be engaged with but can be peremptorily dismissed on the premise that some people might find them offensive – often, I suspect, by those who do not want to have to engage with them. Being on the wrong side of history is an odd place to find oneself. As a republican, with strong socialist views, I can now find myself cast as ‘alt-right’ by those who often don’t have sufficient political or historical baggage in their lockers to know their left from their right. As I say, an odd feeling …

Francis Fukuyama might describe the situation we find ourselves in as the end of history, where we have reached some perfect consciousness, where all is settled and we don’t have to struggle anymore. I am reminded of Stan Cohen, who is best known for his sociological work on moral panics but who was also a social worker by background. His advice to social workers was that they should ‘stay unfinished’ – thinking that something is settled and that you think you have the answers (invariably the right ones) forecloses dialogue and debate and at times disagreement. Yet it is only from this space of friction that we can take the field forward. I look forward to contributing to some of these debates. I will be joined in this by a colleague of mine, Sebastian (or Seb) Monteux from Abertay, Dundee’s other university. Seb will introduce himself next month. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App