Effective CYC practitioners are competent at managing the behavior of the young people and families in our programs. Most life space work occurs while implementing specific routines or rituals like a family meeting or the daily agenda in a group living situation. Mature practitioners are aware that these programmed behaviors are merely a framework which permits people to create the useful interactions that promote change and growth. If we only focus on doing the prescribed actions, then little real change will happen, people will perform the required tasks, but stay stuck in their habits and beliefs.
Safety is a key component of every life space interaction and behavior management creates safety. This focus on safety typically overwhelms new CYC practitioners but becomes quite manageable after several months of experience. Unfortunately, it also allows everyone to value the comfort of being safe above any need to create change. Practitioners and program managers value programs that run without disruption or distress and young people and families value not having to work too hard at new perspectives. Young people can become very comfortable in meeting simple behavioral goals which do not affect them emotionally.
The focus on external control techniques and procedures, which are embedded in every CYC program, can stagnate both practitioners and supervisors. Yet mature practitioners are very aware that external control is not what people need, once they are safe and stable. The challenge for good programs is to build life space moments when the external controls are removed and self-control is required, since until young people and families practice self-control they will be unable to maintain any gains made in the program.
One predictable result of beginning to loosen external controls is that people will become disorganized and appear to need more structure, but the temptation to restore order must be resisted. No one likes change at first and both the young person/family and the CYC practitioner will be inclined to fall back into safe patterns and welcome the external controls again. CYC supervisors can encourage skilled practitioners to create experiences where people are free to make both good and bad choices and learn from the results. Newer workers will be confused by this approach and should be supported by the supervisor to focus on safety while more experienced staff act differently.
The biggest hurdle to creating experiences of self-control is the overall agenda of most programs, which is good behavior and predictability. Even though we are clear that people need to develop the capacity to be self motivated and empowered, our focus is strongly based on external control and containment.
CYC supervisors are the key players who can begin to change this dynamic by supporting experienced staff to think differently about control and to create risk and challenge for the people in our programs, so that they can safely practice the essential skills needed to be successful.