How do we know when we are doing good work? Sometimes it is obvious, but usually it is not. We are prone to overestimating our own ability, and we are poor diagnosticians of the well-being—or problems—of children and youth and we are terrible at identifying the effects of our work or predicting long-term outcomes. These are not comments on the state of the field or of your or my practice—they are problems of being human in fluid situations.
Given these challenges, does a CYC degree help to be good at the work? If we set aside bureaucratic legal and professional requirements, what curricular components are necessary for a good post-secondary education? There is some evidence from counseling, education, and other related fields that degrees and qualifications are not sufficient and that it is necessary that “practitioners practice their practice.” In fact, practicing is more important than one’s qualifications.
Maybe having a diploma is enough. If so, what type of diploma? For example, Thompson Rivers University has a Child and Youth Care Diploma program at its campus in Williams Lake, B.C. The courses include two child and adolescent development courses, an introduction to working with children impacted by trauma, interpersonal communication and helping relationships, introduction to non-aversive interventions, human service practice in Indigenous communities, and an introduction to Canadian social welfare.
If these course are organized so that students practice intensively and learn to think about their practice, and receive feedback on their practice, it is enough. The number of required courses in North American CYC or youthwork programs varies from two to over 35. Two is probably not enough, and 35 is way too many. Further, the content varies widely, but it is not the number of courses in one’s degree that unites good programs or that distinguishes good practitioners from poor practitioners.
Similarly, work in recent years on fieldwork, for example by Jenny McGrath, Carys Cragg, and others has found that CYC programs have anywhere from 200 to 2000 required hours of fieldwork. Is it the number of hours that is important? Probably not.
Instead, it seems to be the same formula across professional fields. Here’s a summary of what we know from studies of therapists/counselors:
Using a sample of practitioners working in real-world settings, the researchers found… that therapist age, gender, years of experience, professional degree or certification, caseload, and theoretical approach were not significant predictors of effectiveness (Beutler et al., 2004). By contrast, the average number of hours clinicians spent in solitary practice outside of work targeted at improving therapeutic skills was a significant predictor of clinician effectiveness. (Miller, 2016, p. 258)
How do you get to Carnegie Hall? Practice, practice, practice. Not charisma, charm, a magic black box, or years of experience. As the old saying goes, you can have 20 years of experience or one year repeated 20 times.
Some studies have found that paraprofessionals (practitioners without a professional degree) who practice their skills are better than professionals who do not, and if both practice, there is little measurable difference between them. The lesson here is that in one’s degree program you should learn how to practice your skills and how to obtain and receive feedback.
The quality and skill of the practitioner matters more than the treatment or care method, theoretical assumptions, devotion to ideologies, or variability in children and youth—anywhere from 70 to 97 percent of the variability in quality is practitioner skill.
Some people name this approach “continuous improvement”—collecting data and information about one’s own practice and learning from it. Miller (2016) frames it as “deliberate practice:”
Deliberate practice means setting aside time for reflecting on feedback received, identifying where one’s performance falls short, seeking guidance from recognized experts, and then developing, rehearsing, executing, and evaluating a plan for improvement. In addition to helping refine and extend specific skills, engaging in prolonged periods of reflection, planning, and practice engenders the development of mechanisms enabling performers to use their knowledge in more efficient, nuanced, and novel ways than their more average counterparts (Ericsson & Staszewski, 1989, cited in Miller, 2016, pp. 257-258).
Another name for this type of continuous improvement for the benefit of deliberate practice is “feedback informed treatment (FIT).” If students and practitioners receive feedback on their practice, and practice their practice, they improve. If fieldwork is organized so that participants receive focused, deliberate feedback and opportunities to exercise their new skills, they will improve faster and need fewer hours to learn.
What makes these simple principles powerful is including clients in the feedback. Research in effectiveness in teaching, in counseling and therapy, in social work, and in education suggests that it is important to include data from clients. Long lists of qualifications, values, assets, theoretical commitments, or identities are only meaningful if they can be demonstrated to help young people grow and change. Lists of courses, trainings, qualifications, are also not useful unless the skills are practiced and data is collected and fed back to you to help you improve. Miller’s (2016, 2015) work focuses on feedback from client data, and in the next column I will discuss how this is done in CYC settings.
Reference
Miller, S. D., Bargmann, S., Chow, D., Seidel, J., & Maeschalck, C. (2016). Feedback-informed treatment (FIT): Improving the outcome of psychotherapy one person at a time. In W. O. O’Donohue & A. Maragakis (eds.). Quality improvement in behavioral health. Springer International Publishing.