The thing about death is that it is inevitable. I was going to write that sentence differently when I set out to write this column. I was going say that inevitably, if you do CYC work long enough, you will encounter death. But upon reflection, I decided that stating it as being an event bounded by our work was misleading. It is misleading, in that death is everywhere around us all the time. At any given moment that might not be immediately obvious, but someone is dying in our community every hour of every day. The fact that this is not a part of our lived experience for most of us, is rooted in a certain distance that we maintain from the lived actuality of death.
In fact, we compartmentalize death in an almost infinite number of ways large and small. We create hierarchies of death so as to distance ourselves from it. Insects die in our immediate vicinity with some regularity, but for the most part, these deaths are not worthy of serious consideration (of course small children know better and mourn the death of all things). Small birds and mammals deaths are at times sad to us, but more regrettable than notable. That is unless the animal has a personal relationship to us, such as a pet. The extinction of entire species seems to escape our lived experience, outside of a concern about how the loss of other beings might threaten us. In fact, even the genocide of other peoples in other parts of the world, or just outside our neighborhood, generally only bothers us at a relatively abstract level. Most of the time we feel bad about it, but not enough to warrant the kind of grief and rage necessary to mobilize us to stop it. For most of us, the truth is that death has to hit very close to home to have a demonstrable impact.
To return to the opening sentence with that in mind, I would suggest that death is a part of the work we do and that we tend to deny that actuality with some force. Outside of suicide, we seldom seriously engage the fact that people die in CYC work. But they do, and they include the young people we encounter in our work, our co-workers and the family members of the young people. And these are just some of the people who can and do die while we are working in the field.
There are, of course, a number of ways that we shield ourselves from the actuality of death in our workplace. The first and foremost is to act as though death is an anomaly and that in many cases it is preventable. When a young person dies in our care, we bracket it as an exceptional event that requires particular attention. And to some degree this is true. The loss of someone we have built a relationship with is tragic and deserves the dignity of grief and remembrance.
On the other hand, we are often trained to treat death in our work as a clinical or administrative failing. If we had done things differently, not missed the cues, engage at a deeper level, followed the right protocols, death could have been avoided. And again, this can also have some truth to it.
Certainly, there are times when the organizations we work for are insufficiently attentive to the care needs of young people and families, or we find ourselves bound by protocols that simply are ineffective and in some cases harmful. Or we wish that the young person, family member, co-worker would have taken better care of themselves, not engaged in risky behavior, stepped away from their addiction, or seen the good in themselves that we saw. And to some degree all of that rings true as well.
All these reactions and thoughts are utterly impossible to avoid. They are the ways in which we seek to be able to make sense of death and perhaps even reverse it somehow. For many of us, we desire the ability to be able to go back and have it all happen differently. We want desperately to make death go away.
In all of this, we seek solace in the possibility that if we could learn what went wrong in this death, then we can prevent future deaths. We sometimes seek a kind of perverse value in any particular death associated with CYC. We look to see if we can somehow turn it into a learning. And again, perhaps there is some truth in this as well. But what kinds of learning?
Death has many lessons without a doubt. But I would argue that to learn them, we must face the fact that death is inevitable and will happen and does happen in programs all around the world, all of the time. That is to say, that in order to learn anything substantive from death, we would need to have a relationship with our mortality and the mortality of others that is not based in denial or fear. Relational work is central to the work we do with young people, families, and communities, but sometimes we seem to forget that those relationships are with bodies and those bodies are mortal.
The understanding that our work with others is corporeal can be obfuscated by peculiar ideas we have of who others are. We can see others as personalities, selves, sets of behaviors or beliefs, constellations of emotions or reactions, or existing beyond the body. Indeed, we could misread the excellent admonition from Garfat et al that our work is done in the in between, between us as meaning that relational work occurs outside the bodies involved. This is of course a rather perverse misreading of some very wise counsel. Nonetheless, I would suggest that at any given moment in our work with young people, families, and communities we would prefer to forget that they are bodies and that we are a body.
It is sometimes uncomfortable to engage with another body with all its messy corporeality. It is hard enough to take our own body-embeddedness in full stride. To not automatically separate ourselves from our bodies in precisely the way I just wrote that sentence i.e., our bodies or the bodies that belong to us.
This way of speaking implies that there is an us separable from the body. That who we are transcends the body itself. This fundamental scission of our self from the body may well be at the root of our inability to engage directly with death, or at another level entirely, death as an integral part of life.
Our denial of the body as the starting point of who are and as the genesis of our lived experience has the tendency to distance us from other ecological sets of material relations such as the land, other species, and corporeal collectivities of consciousness. We can begin to think that we are exempt and perhaps superior to the myriad living communities in which we are involved. Our allegiance might be to some realm outside the messy relations of the earth and all that it produces and that produce it. We could think, as Plato did, that the earth was a corrupted version of a realm of perfect form and that the perfect realm outside this earth was our proper domicile. This line of belief can lead to a sense that we need to fix the corruption and imperfections of the world by referencing a better and more perfect world. A world only we as humans can access through either reason or faith.
The idea that we, as humans, are exceptional and have qualities of thought and behavior well above the world of nature, with what we see as its savagery and chaos, can give us the sense that we can escape the implacable logic of the body. The body logic that operates on the basis of what actually composes and decomposes every aspect of who we are day in and day out. Of course, it is this body logic that will kill us in the end, but it is also the body logic that gives us life. The same patterns that connects atoms, molecules, cells, and flows of electrons into the organs that create the body, are the same patterns that dissemble and redistribute all of what make us. In that sense then, life and death are just part of the flow of things. Of course, we would prefer that we could stand outside of this process and that the body is simply a shell that we inhabit or a temporary domicile of the soul. And perhaps that may be true.
On the other hand, if we are to face death, I would argue we must face ourselves as embedded in the flows of life. Death needs to be a part of our experience of life because we are dying and being reborn all of the time as atoms flow through us and our organs decompose and regenerate day after day, year after year until we are assimilated into a much broader ecological community as the ground out of which new life is formed. The body that we are is part of a much larger body, or put in another term, a community body in which all elements of the earth are corporeal entanglements from which we cannot be separated. There is a matter of factness in this view of our many relations. But perhaps that very matter of factness can allow for a depth of relationship to death that allows for a more complete experience of our grief at what may appear to be an end, and our joy at the re-inclusion of the one we thought lost back into our community body.
An example of this is the second line style of jazz in New Orleans funerals. In this tradition derived from pre-colonial African ceremonies, blended with elements of Christianity, the line of the jazz funeral leaves the cemetery with a funeral dirge played at the front of the procession made of up the family and mourners. But shortly after advancing beyond the cemetery gates, a line of people, literally behind the first, begins to form the second line. This is started by the drummers, who act as a backbeat for the rest of the band, and also establish a beat for the second line. This second line is a group of family, friends and other celebrants who carry umbrellas and begin to celebrate the life of the deceased by dancing and partying through the streets with the band.
This series of meaning produced musically regarding the affective and communal response to death is both a combination of collisions between multiple lines of force including lines of domination played through European parade structures, instrumentation and burial practices and persistent lines of alternate assertion including African beliefs about death, community structures, and musical form. This is an assertion of a community of bodies entangled with rhythms and memories and projections of life and acknowledgments of death. It has a celebratory matter of factness of the moments of transition that make up our common life world.
In a recent interview on NPR filmmaker Sterlin Harjo, who created the series Reservation Dogs, discussed his Indigenous community’s relationship to death. He defines death as a part of the experience of life that is “community driven.” Death on the reservation, he tells us takes place within a context in which, “your cousins are like your brothers and sisters. Your aunts are your extended parents, and you're close to your elders and everyone's a part of this tight community.” Harjo notes the frequency of death on the reservation and the ways in which it brings the community together. Like the second line, music plays a key role, “And our songs, the songs that we sing, there's these spiritual songs that we sing that mostly get sung and you hear them at funerals, and it's all about facing death and mortality head on.” In this tradition, funerals are places of gathering,
There's something really beautiful about a funeral in our community, where everyone comes together and it's really funny. And you're getting to see people that you haven't seen in a long time and you say, "I love you," to people that you wouldn't normally say, "I love you" to. It's just a part of being in a community.
The sense of matter of factness, blended with humor and sorrow and the ability of songs to help us to face death and mortality head on is a powerful assertion of death as a part of life. Harjo goes on to discuss the ongoing relationship that Indigenous peoples have with those who have died.
In the culture you're taught that they're not gone and that you can still speak to them and talk to them and there's ghost stories and things like that. But I just grew up with this sense of magic, and there's a sense of like we can communicate, we can reach people in other places, and there's ceremonies for it and there's different things.
The complexity of death and its implications for how we live life, how we love each other, and how we build all our relations is more central than we might think to our work in CYC. To build our relationships with the young people, communities, families and co-workers in a way that acknowledges our common corporeality and mortality stands the possibility of a profound sense of shared family or community. Death is, after all, something we all share. To share it in a way that affirms life and living can be a powerful way of engaging our work. The Lakota have a phrase that I would like to end with here, Mitakuye Oyasin. It translates roughly: to “all my relations.” It is in that spirit I dedicate this column to all who have gone on and all who will —that is to say “all my relations.”