CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 284 OCTOBER 2022

The Role of Child and Youth Care Practitioners in Promoting Belonging for Youth with Disabilities

Emily Eirikson

In recent years, Child and Youth Care Practitioners (CYCPs) are working more with young people with disabilities. 13% of Canadian youth aged 15-24 live with disability, and as such are likely to be present in any setting where young people are gathered (Statistics Canada, 2017). CYCPs may also work in disability-specific settings and roles, as educational assistants, support workers, child life specialists, behaviour interventionists, and more. However, Child and Youth Care is only beginning to engage with disability studies scholars, concepts, and perspectives. A search of major Child and Youth Care journals (including Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, CYC-Online, the Child and Youth Care Forum, and the International Journal of Child, Youth and Family Studies) returns minimal results related to practice with children, youth, families and disability. This lack of engagement means our field is missing out on the most current knowledge and approaches in supporting these young people. Some might say that disability is beyond the scope of CYC practice and that CYCPs are not properly trained or equipped to engage with young people with disabilities (Gharabaghi, 2010). However, I would be inclined to agree with Marshall (2017) who proposes that we “forget any notion of specialized ‘fixing’ or ‘intervening’ with these young people” (p. 67) and instead focus on what we as CYCPs bring to the table in terms of relational, reflective, strengths-based practice. In fact, the CYC value of relationships and commitment to social justice is particularly relevant to ongoing conversations in disability studies that critique the current dominant ideal of inclusion, from its conceptualization to its implementation. This paper will introduce some key disability studies concepts and explore their alignment with CYC principles, discuss the difference between inclusion and belonging, then argue that CYCPs are well-positioned to work alongside young people with disabilities and move beyond inclusion to promote belonging.

Key Concepts in Disability Studies

The field of disability studies emerged alongside the disability rights movement in the late twentieth century. Writing in 1980, Victor Finkelstein provided an important reminder that we are all needy and dependent on various aids, technologies, and conveniences of modern life (Finkelstein, 1980). He drew attention to the fact that able-bodied people have molded the environment in response to their own needs and abilities, but disabled people were left out of that process, and as such are disabled by the environment. This idea is the foundation of the social model of disability, a term coined by disabled scholar and activist Michael Oliver in his 1983 book (Tregaskis, 2002). The social model locates the problem of disability in the environment rather than in the individual by distinguishing between impairment (a “functional limitation within the individual”) and disability (the “loss or limitation of opportunities to take part in the normal life of the community”) (Tregaskis, 2002, p. 458). Essentially, the social model states that individuals are primarily disabled by society, not by their impairments (Oliver, 1983). With insights like these, the social model shaped the beginning of critical disability theory. The social model also aligns well with a CYC strengths-based approach that resists pathologizing the individual to instead position the environment as the location of the problem and target of intervention. Practitioners can strive to remove barriers and create accommodations in the environment that enable the young person to live, work and play to the best of their abilities, honouring their uniqueness and dignity, rather than pressuring them to change to fit in.

Disability studies also introduces the concept of ableism, in other words, discrimination against disabled people. Ableism is manifested in places, practices, policies, and perspectives that assert a preference for nondisabled people. Hehir (2002) writes eloquently on the ways that ableism may impact practice with young people:

The devaluation of disability results in societal attitudes that uncritically assert that it is better for a child to walk than roll, speak than sign, read print than read Braille, spell independently than use a spell-check, and hang out with nondisabled kids as opposed to other disabled kids, etc. In short, in the eyes of many educators and society, it is preferable for disabled students to do things in the same manner as nondisabled kids. (p.3)

Again, the concept of ableism is a useful tool for CYCPs seeking to address oppressive systems that negatively affect children, youth, and families. It also highlights the importance of each practitioner’s commitment to examining their own beliefs and prejudices and their impact on practice. As Bishop (1994) writes, we are “marinated” in the oppressive attitudes of society (p.97). These attitudes may include the idea that disability is inherently negative, undesirable, and inferior, when it is an inevitable aspect of human experience and an expression of human diversity.

History and Critiques of Inclusion

For centuries, the dominant approach to caring for people with disabilities in North America was through institutionalization (Cameron & Valentine, 2001). Prior to the period of institutionalization people with disabilities were present in the community, albeit occupying a lower status and social role, for instance begging in the street (Finkelstein, 1980). As industrialisation and capitalism increased in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century, the measures of how bodies were valued changed (Jenks, 2019). Disabled bodies were characterized as passive, dependent, and therefore in need of special attention, treatment, and care (Finkelstein, 1980). Institution such as asylums were opened under the premise of supporting and treating people with disabilities, but ultimately served to segregate them from their communities (Conrad, 2020; Finkelstein, 1980). In the 1700s Canadian institutions housed the poor, the elderly, orphans, and the “insane”, with more specialized institutions for people with intellectual and psychiatric disabilities opening in the 1870s (Dunn & Langdon, 2016). These institutions operated under policies of separation, isolation, and charity, and abuse ran rampant under the guise of treatment (Dunn & Langdon, 2016). There was no support provided to families who did not want to put their children in institutions (Dunn & Langdon, 2016). The development of institutions also facilitated the development and proliferation of professionals and experts, and while the existence of these professionals popularized feelings of positive concern, it also reinforced stereotypes of neediness, incompetence, and an inferior social role (Finkelstein, 1980).

Ideals of inclusion took precedence in the 1960s and 1970s during the disability rights movement, consisting of activism on the part of disability organizations, parents, and, increasingly, self-advocates (Conrad, 2020; Dunn & Langdon, 2016). This included the independent living movement which began in California in the late 1960s and spread from there, with independent living centres run by and for people with disabilities opening in Canada in the 1980s (Dunn & Langdon, 2016; Jenks, 2019). Similarly, in the community living movement, parents and caregivers fought for their child’s right to education, recreation, vocational programs, and small-scale residential services rather than institutions (Dunn & Langdon, 2016). These struggles would continue for decades. For example, the first Canadian institution for the intellectually disabled opened in 1876 but had peak occupancy in 1968 with 2600 residents and did not close its doors until 2009 (Dunn & Langdon, 2016, p. 31). And yet, the deinstitutionalization process was criticized for happening too quickly and without adequate community supports in place (Conrad, 2020; Dunn & Langdon, 2016). Canadian authors Dunn and Langdon (2016) describe the resulting social services for people with disabilities as fragmented and contradictory, remarking that “many people have become institutionalized within the community, experiencing the same conditions of dependency, categorization, separation, isolation and stigma as individuals in institutions” (p.35). It seems that the ideal of inclusion may not be translating into practice.

In fact, research on inclusive programs such as summer camps shows mixed results: they may promote acceptance or provoke rejection and ridicule (D’Eloia & Price, 2018). D’Eloia and Price (2018) found that a lack of reciprocity in relationships between disabled and nondisabled campers was most prominent in competitive activities, in structured buddy roles that created a helper/helped dichotomy, and when participation was hindered by skill limitations. In contrast, friendships were most achievable when roles are balanced and the environment is accessible. This poses a challenge when camp programs tend to be designed by nondisabled adults for nondisabled youth and retrofitted to include youth with disabilities. In a study of relationships between disabled and nondisabled campers, Devine and Parr (2008) also found that hierarchies exist. Nondisabled campers did not see any benefits of inclusion for themselves and described “allowing” disabled campers to participate with them. Thus, an inclusive structure can camouflage social inequities that prevent belonging.

Furthermore, inclusion has been heavily critiqued for reinforcing normativity and pressuring the individual to fit into mainstream society (Hall, 2010). In particular, inclusion has been shaped by neoliberal discourses where an emphasis on (financial) independence, self-sufficiency, and consumerism translates to ideals of paid employment, independent living, and presence in mainstream community settings (Renwick et al., 2019). Children with disabilities are targeted with behavioural interventions and social skills training to help them “fit in” – in other words, to conform to the expectations and comfort level of the nondisabled majority. Marshall (2017) invites us to wonder, “how many young people with disabilities think about why they are being targeted for an intervention when, perhaps, it was those around them that needed the interventions most?” (p.59). Furthermore, defining inclusion as presence in mainstream settings departs from research where individuals with disabilities report finding belonging in segregated spaces, such as Hall’s (2010) consideration of two arts-based, disability-exclusive organizations where members found safety, support, friendships, and opportunities to provide valued contributions. Examples such as this suggest that current definitions of inclusion do not necessarily correspond to or take into account the lived experiences, preferences, agency and needs of disabled people (Strnadová et al., 2018). The policy trend of inclusion may have increased physical presence, but not genuine social engagement.

Young people with disabilities have important things to say about their experiences of inclusion. Teachman et al. (2020) combined visual methods and interviews with 13 Canadian youth with cerebral palsy aged 15-24 who use augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) to understand how these youth make sense of inclusion. Many described feeling safer and more comfortable in segregated spaces, and feeling unsafe, frustrated and tired from dealing with strangers who stared, behaved rudely, or did not take the time to listen to them. These youth found belonging by creating positive “microspaces” of inclusion, where they were safe, known, welcomed, and connected to others in ways that transcended spoken communication, often with family members. The authors concluded, “there is an urgent need for systemic shifts past idealized notions of inclusion as a journey by disabled persons towards mainstream, ableist social settings. Instead, attention should be paid towards studying and promoting social spaces where the status quo has been disrupted and alternative ways of being in the world are positively valued” (p.1119).

Defining Belonging

What is frequently missing from experiences of inclusion – genuine acceptance, reciprocal relationships, a valued role in community – may be summarized by the concept of belonging. Belonging was famously identified as a human need by Maslow (1943), and this conceptualization has resonated through the decades (Abulof, 2017; Baumeister & Leary, 1995). Indeed, experiencing a lack of belonging has been found to impact young people’s learning and development and can result in negative and potentially long-lasting effects on physical and mental health (Kwan et al., 2020). In contrast, a qualitative study of Australian youth aged 8-16 with a range of disabilities described wellbeing as feeling supported, included, respected, valued, and capable and defined “a good life” as having friends, family, and personally meaningful things to do (Foley et al., 2012). By this definition, wellbeing is nearly synonymous with belonging.

Minimal research has been conducted to define belonging from the perspectives of people with disabilities. An Australian study combined themes from the literature with data from focus groups with disabled adults to describe four dimensions of belonging: belonging as identity, belonging as relational, belonging to place, and belonging as a contributor to society (Strnadová et al., 2018). The focus group participants identified barriers to belonging as well, which were summarized under the title “the way others see me” and included prejudice and bullying. Similarly, the Voices of Youth project engaged 13- to 24-year-olds with intellectual and developmental disabilities in the Greater Toronto Area and used a grounded theory approach to construct a framework for belonging (Renwick et al., 2019). Using abductive reasoning and iterative analysis, researchers drew on the qualitative data to develop a theory in which belonging was associated with four concepts: engaging with similar people, having social relationships, negotiating meaningful roles, and navigating norms and expectations to find a good fit. A key finding was that “belonging was tied to the quality of interaction and acceptance by others, rather than simply being included” (p.953). The participants expressed longings to be invited to birthday parties, movie dates, and other social outings reflective of genuine, reciprocal friendship, and for their participation in community life to be met with positive responses. These two studies highlight the important distinction between inclusion and belonging.

Another Australian study used pictorial mapping and photo-rich methods to investigate lived experiences of belonging and exclusion for 30 young people with intellectual disabilities aged 12-25 who lived in small towns (Robinson et al., 2020). Some youth found their small-town neighbourhood to be supportive, while others found it stifling, but most youth reported a sense of belonging. For these youth, belonging was a mutual experience and included elements of feeling accepted, respected, safe, comfortable. When there was congruence between how the youth saw themselves and how others related to them, they felt valued and understood. Youth also described experiences of not belonging, such as facing challenges in their family lives, feeling lonely, desiring more or deeper friendships, and feeling uncomfortable or unwelcome in places. The authors noted that “receiving positive or negative responses from others was crucial in how young people felt able to engage (or not) with a wide range of people and settings” (p.64).

Salmon (2013) provides another critical Canadian perspective on youth with disabilities, inclusion, and belonging. Through interviews with seven pairs of friends aged 15-20 and adults who observed the development of these friendships, it became clear that participants felt a greater sense of belonging when with peers who shared the disability experience, and that they used self-exclusion as a strategy to find belonging, safety, and sustainable friendships with similar peers. This study challenges the ways in which relationships between disabled and nondisabled youth have been positioned as the “gold standard for inclusion” (p.348), when, in reality, youth with disabilities routinely experience rejection by their nondisabled counterparts and seem to not be recognised as potential friends. The authors cite research demonstrating that the most stable friendships for youth with disabilities were between peers who were in the same segregated classroom for multiple years. All these findings suggest that an emphasis on inclusion in mainstream spaces may not be meeting the social and emotional needs of young people with disabilities, and that the attitudes and response of the community are an important factor in creating belonging or not.

Conclusions and Implications for CYC Practice

This preliminary review of the literature suggests that further research from the perspectives of youth is needed to inform inclusion policies and practices that reflect what is important for young people, and to promote belonging in ways that are meaningful to them. Despite the limited scholarship on this topic, it seems apparent that a key ingredient of belonging is reciprocal feelings of respect and care. Because people with disabilities continue to face stigmatisation in mainstream settings, segregated spaces can be safer, more comfortable, and more likely to provide a sense of belonging. These disability-specific places, activities, and relationships must be seen as equally valuable, while not losing sight of the end goal of renouncing oppressive attitudes and systems to co-create a society where all ways of being belong. Child and Youth Care practitioners who are committed to social justice and the flourishing of young people can gain new insights from the field of disability studies and use their skills in strengths-based relational practice to work alongside young people to combat ableism, respect each person’s unique way of being in the world, and promote genuine inclusion and belonging for all.

References 

Abulof, U. (2017). Introduction: Why we need Maslow in the twenty-first century. Society, 54(6), 508–509. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12115-017-0198-6

Baumeister, R. F., & Leary, M. R. (1995). The need to belong: Desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 117(3), 497–529. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.117.3.497

Bishop, A. (1994). Step 5: Becoming an ally. In Becoming an ally: Breaking the cycle of oppression (pp. 93–104). Fernwood Publishing.

Cameron, D., & Valentine, F. (Eds.). (2001). Disability and federalism: Comparing different approaches to full participation. Published for the Institute of Intergovernmental Relations, School of Policy Studies, Queen’s University by McGill-Queen’s University Press. https://www.queensu.ca/iigr/sites/webpublish.queensu.ca.iigrwww/files/files/pub/archive/socialunionseries/Cameronvalentine.pdf

Conrad, J. A. (2020). On intellectual and developmental disabilities in the United States: A historical perspective. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities, 24(1), 85–101. https://doi.org/10.1177/1744629518767001

D’Eloia, M. H., & Price, P. (2018). Sense of belonging: Is inclusion the answer? Sport in Society, 21(1), 91–105. https://doi.org/10.1080/17430437.2016.1225819

Devine, M. A., & Parr, M. G. (2008). “Come on in, but not too far:” Social capital in an inclusive leisure setting. Leisure Sciences, 30(5), 391–408. https://doi.org/10.1080/01490400802353083

Dunn, P., & Langdon, T.-L. (2016). Looking back, rethinking historical perspectives and reflecting upon emerging trends. In G. Larson & J. S. Robertson (Eds.), Disability and social change: A progressive Canadian approach (pp. 27–44). Fernwood Publishing.

Finkelstein, V. (1980). Attitudes and disabled people. World Rehabilitation Fund. https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/library/finkelstein-attitudes.pdf

Foley, K.-R., Blackmore, A. M., Girdler, S., O’Donnell, M., Glauert, R., Llewellyn, G., & Leonard, H. (2012). To feel belonged: The voices of children and youth with disabilities on the meaning of wellbeing. Child Indicators Research, 5(2), 375–391. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12187-011-9134-2

Gharabaghi, K. (2010). Expansion to what end? CYC-Online, 139. https://cyc-net.org/cyc-online/cyconline-sep2010-gharabaghi.html

Hall, E. (2010). Spaces of social inclusion and belonging for people with intellectual disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 54, 48–57. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2788.2009.01237.x

Hehir, T. (2002). Eliminating ableism in education. Harvard Educational Review, 72(1), 1–33. https://doi.org/10.17763/haer.72.1.03866528702g2105

Jenks, A. (2019). Crip theory and the disabled identity: Why disability politics needs impairment. Disability & Society, 34(3), 449–469. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2018.1545116

Kwan, C., Gitimoghaddam, M., & Collet, J.-P. (2020). Effects of social isolation and loneliness in children with neurodevelopmental disabilities: A scoping review. Brain Sciences, 10(11), 1–31. https://doi.org/10.3390/brainsci10110786

Marshall, N. (2017). Child and youth care and disability rights: Listening to young people, challenging our practice. Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 30(2), 55–69.

Maslow, A. H. (1943). A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review, 50(4), 370–396. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0054346

Oliver, M. (1983). Social Work with Disabled People. Macmillan Education, Limited. https://public.ebookcentral.proquest.com/choice/publicfullrecord.aspx?p=5641414

Renwick, R., DuBois, D., Cowen, J., Cameron, D., Fudge Schormans, A., & Rose, N. (2019). Voices of youths on engagement in community life: A theoretical framework of belonging. Disability & Society, 34(6), 945–971. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2019.1583551

Robinson, S., Hill, M., Fisher, K. R., & Graham, A. (2020). Belonging and exclusion in the lives of young people with intellectual disability in small town communities. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities, 24(1), 50–68. https://doi.org/10.1177/1744629518765830

Salmon, N. (2013). ‘We just stick together’: How disabled teens negotiate stigma to create lasting friendship. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research, 57(4), 347–358. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2788.2012.01541.x

Statistics Canada. (2017). Persons with and without disabilities aged 15 years and over, by age group and sex, Canada, provinces and territories [Data set]. Government of Canada. https://doi.org/10.25318/1310037401-ENG

Strnadová, I., Johnson, K., & Walmsley, J. (2018). “… but if you’re afraid of things, how are you meant to belong?” What belonging means to people with intellectual disabilities. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 31(6), 1091–1102. https://doi.org/10.1111/jar.12469

Teachman, G., McDonough, P., Macarthur, C., & Gibson, B. E. (2020). Interrogating inclusion with youths who use augmentative and alternative communication. Sociology of Health & Illness, 42(5), 1108–1122. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9566.13087

Tregaskis, C. (2002). Social Model Theory: The story so far. Disability & Society, 17(4), 457–470. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687590220140377

 

From: Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, Vol 34.3, pp40-50

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App