CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 272 OCTOBER 2021

‘Zoning In’ to Daily Life Events that Facilitate Therapeutic Change in Child and Youth Care Practice

Leon Fulcher

Introduction

Therapeutic Use of Daily Life Events with young people in out-of-home care is frequently a policy aspiration of Human Service organizations, often without clear appreciation for what it means to live with, and influence the lives of, challenged and challenging young people during important periods in their lives. The reader here is invited to ‘zone-in’ on a handful of Child and Youth Care principles (Garfat & Fulcher, 2011) that assist Child and Youth Care Practitioners to enter ‘zones of proximal development’ in shared life spaces with particular young people as Carers in designated out-of-home placements. Duty of care obligations and responsibilities impact on a variety of ‘zones’ that deter- mine whether therapeutic use of daily life events actually provide opportunities for young people to achieve developmental outcomes that matter during their placement(s) in out-of-home care. Implications for practice and supervision of out-of-home care practices are briefly examined. 

Principle 1: Participate with People as They Live Their Lives

At Conference Workshops or Keynote Addresses, Henry Maier used to remind Child and Youth Care Workers, Supervisors, and Managers that BEFORE a word gets spoken, the whole Sensorimotor stage of cognitive development has been activated. Maier (1979) further argued that Specialized Behaviour Training with young people is most successful when Bodily Comfort, Differences, Rhythmicity, Predictability, and Dependability components of his Core of Care have been activated in daily life spaces with peers (Smith, Fulcher & Doran, 2013). Maier showed how relationships play a significant role in determining whether a young person achieves developmental outcomes that matter to that young person, and to her or his family members and community. Social capabilities and competencies build upon personal attachments. Nurturing self-management and enriching a child or young person’s behavioural repertoires are closely linked to quality relationships with Carers.

Principle 2: Working in the Now

The Child and Youth Care field has become increasingly aware that learning is a social process rather than just, or even primarily, an individual, deep-brain learning process. Social learning happens in groups, or as Maier noted, at the very least through relation- ships. While contemporary Western psychological theory focused more and more on individual deep-brain learning processes, the Russian psychologist Vygotsky was arguing that learning and cognitive development takes place firstly on a social plane before it is subsequently incorporated into a young person’s cognitive schema. Knowledge and meaning are socially constructed by the particular parties involved in the social learning process – teachers or out-of-home carers and learners – rather than information merely transmitted from one person to the other, as more traditional views of teaching and learning might suggest (Stremmel, 1993).

Through the assistance of a more capable person, a child is able to learn skills or aspects of a skill that go beyond that child’s actual developmental or maturational level, such that development follows the young person’s potential to learn.

Principle 3: Doing ‘With’, Not ‘For’ or ‘To’

From 1926-30, Vygotsky investigated the development of higher cognitive functions of logical memory, selective attention, decision making, and language comprehension. This young Russian psychologist studied three different angles: first trying to understand the ways in which humans use objects as aides in memory and reasoning; second, how children acquire higher cognitive functions during learning; and third, ways in which learning trajectories are shaped by different social and cultural patterns of interaction. A central theme in Vygotsky’s work related to what he called the ‘zone of proximal development.’ Essentially, children or young people grow and can be supported in their personal and social growth towards the next stage of development through the guidance of appropriate adults or more skilled peers.

This ‘zone of proximal development’ is socially mediated and is shaped through dialogue and relationships in daily life events in their life space. Adults may be accorded a role as ‘more knowledgeable others’ in working with children, to help these young people to identify and develop personal and social skills. Peers also play a role in mediating personal and cognitive development, and especially social development (Emond, 2000).

Principle 4: Responsively Developmental

Vygotsky’s idea of ‘zone of proximal development’ lends itself to working with groups of young people because it is fundamentally social, and also broadly educational rather than individual and problem-focused. It reinforces the importance of relationships and thus provides a robust psychological underpinning for the therapeutic use of daily life events in social education or social pedagogy. Tragically, Vygotsky died of tuberculosis in 1934, at the age of 37, in Moscow, with much of his seminal work unpublished until the 1980s. Building later on the ‘zone of proximal development’ idea, Eichsteller and Holthoff (2010) concluded that learning takes place when young people actually leave their comfort zone to explore wider dimensions of their environment, thereby extending their learning zone to the extent that young people review capabilities and extend the potential limits of their abilities. Pushed too far, young people enter a panic zone, where lack of knowledge and understanding – along with resultant anxiety – often inhibits their ability to learn.

Alongside young people, Child and Youth Care Practitioners encourage them to step out of their comfort zones and into their personal learning zone.

Principle 5: Intentionality of Action

To create opportunities where young people can engage with optimal learning opportunities, she or he needs to experience a degree of safety and trust in their learning moment. The level of challenge each young person faces must offer a manageable fit with how they view their own capabilities. It is here that their ‘zone of proximal development’ assumes considerable meaning in practice. Think of how many times as a Child and Youth Care Practitioner one might have heard a young person say ‘I’m in the Zone!’ This may have been around a sporting activity such as basketball or football, or an art, sculpturing, or photography activity! For that reason, Child and Youth Care Practitioners must remain attentive to this other ‘zone’ where opportunities for learning and achievement of developmental outcomes that matter can be nurtured intentionally. One might intentionally offer and arrange events and experiences that balance the right amount of challenge with the offer of learning opportunities, enabling children and young people to achieve incrementally and at their own appropriate pace and level. Experiences of achieving developmental outcomes that matter provide a relational platform for continuing success. As Powis et al (1989) noted, a young person who lacks confidence in all areas of her or his life may just need achievement in one area from which to gain self-confidence sufficiently to shift personal attitudes about her or himself and experience enhanced performance in other areas of their life.

Therapeutic Use of ‘The Zone’ in Daily Life Events with Young People

Child and Youth Care Practitioners can help children and young people in out-of-home care to explore opportunities where learning isn’t a painful or frustrating experience. Carers might begin more directly with what really interests this young person and how – together – might we build on those interests to create realistic and achievable learning opportunities through daily life events we share whilst living together.

Young people quite readily and willingly respond to personal coaching activities from a Carer with whom they feel respect- fully engaged. This highlights the importance of Child and Youth Care Practitioners connecting pro-actively with each child or young person received into out-of-home care. It means engaging without waiting for that young person to make the first move. In the absence of such intentionality on the part of each Child and Youth Care Practitioner, it is easy for negative peer group cultures to emerge which undervalue education (basic reading, writing, and arithmetic) and survival skills for daily living as young adults.

Learning to enjoy and achieve begins through relationships that have personal meaning for each young person. Enjoyment and achievement are not rigid expectations in Child and Youth Care Practice. Instead, enjoyment and personal achievements are natural results when we engage and operate in relationships that build with intentionality through each young person’s ‘zone of proximal development.’

Within such relationships – encountered in the present and unencumbered by past feelings – young people find opportunities to experience themselves in new ways. These new ways of being in their world begin to weave together daily life experiences and personal stories that reinforce themes of competence, mastery, trustworthiness, happiness and, perhaps most importantly, hope (Phelan, 2001). During such moments, communication frequently occurs through the senses and shared experiences in daily living, not simply through words. Child and Youth Care Practitioners may recall times when they engaged with young people through arduous physical activities, such as a long cycle ride or a challenging hill walk. During such times, communication is often non-verbal, based more around presence, relationship, and ‘doing or being with’. Such shared experiences offer powerful opportunities for identifying and engaging in teachable moments in this young person’s ‘zone of proximal development.’

Supervision of Carers Working in ‘The Zone’ with Young People

A variety of ‘zones’ require consideration in the daily and weekly supervision of Agency Carers and Supervisors seeking to apply this ‘zone of proximal development’ idea in their daily work with young people in out-of-home care.

Zoning In

Effective supervisors ensure that Carers are zoning in on what are important responses with young people. Responsive practices that nurture develop- mental achievements and promote resilience amongst young people in out-of-home cares involves more than reacting to a young person’s behaviour, or the behaviours of a group of youths.

Zone Offence

Good supervisors encourage Carers to influence the Personal Care and Education Plan, and to use it as a guide. Responsive practices involve intervening in a planned manner which considers each young person’s current developmental stage and needs, and the context which relocated that young person into this out-of-home care placement.

Zone Defence

Thoughtful supervisors encourage Carers to consider alternative Plans B and C so that when one approach doesn’t seem to be working, there is always a back-up plan. This helps with responding with each young person placed in out-of-home care in a manner consistent with how she or he experiences her or himself at any moment in time. 

Zone Press

The more Carers take account of particular developmental requirements each young person brings with them into out-of-home care, the more responsive each Carer will be in their pro-active use of daily life events with that young person. Stay close to that young person and their ‘Zone’. This matters throughout that young person’s stay in out-of-home care, however short or long.

End Zone

Health and welfare services promote ‘evidence-based practices’ with children and young people in out-of-home care. Few of these services attend closely to ‘practice-based evidence’ (Parsonson, 2012). Responsive supervision reinforces ‘good enough caring in each young person’s zone of proximal development’. The idea is to address the particular developmental needs and achievements that each young person brings with them into out-of-home care and ensure that they continue to achieve throughout their placement(s)!

Zoned-Out

Attentive supervision picks up immediately when it seems that Carers are not in sync with a young person in their care. When a placement is disrupted or breaks down because of less than expected change, so it is that personal care and treatment plans are commonly amended without any systematic scrutiny of whether there is evidence to show whether this placement was addressing the needs of this particular youth in the first place.

Loading Zone

Any agency which accepts local government commissioning or enters into purchase-of-service contracts to provide out-of-home care, legally accepts a duty of care mandate from the State – through legislation which lays down criteria around which the supervision of each young person in out-of-home placement and their conditions of residence are reviewed (Fulcher, 2000).

No Parking Zone

The duty of care mandate for out-of-home placements offers each child, young person, and family a minimum guarantee not to be harmed or made unsafe through ‘as therapeutic as possible’ use of daily life events with young people placed with designated out-of-home Carers. No parking zones extend to offices and to hiding away completing administrivia!

Tow-Away Zone

Supervision of each Carer requires regular and also ‘as needed’ contact so that agencies demonstrate accountability and compliance around issues of personal liability as well as vicarious liability (that which holds agency management liable through failure to supervise) for the duration of each young person’s stay in out-of-home care.

Safety Zone

Telephone and on-site supervision can be supplemented through Carer Groups, Peer and Buddy-Supervision, Telephone Ladders, and Team Supervision. Each of the Child and Youth Care Practice principles highlighted at the start of this article also apply in Carer Supervision.

Re-Fueling Zone

Whether by telephone or video conference, on-line forums, face-to-face meetings with individuals, couples, foster families or groups and teams of Carers, weekly and monthly supervision needs to review particular accounts of how Carers participated with young people as they lived their lives during recent days and weeks.

Speed Zone

Invite Carers to slow down, share, and reflect upon actual scenarios from recent encounters with the young person(s) in their care, inviting detailed accounts of scenarios when they experienced working in ‘The Zone’ with this particular young person in the past few days – and how these experiences left the Carer feeling since.

Zone of Proximal Development

Actively explore a couple of examples involving learning moments where this Carer entered ‘The Zone’ in their proximal attachment role, willingly able to share accounts about ‘Doing With’, not ‘For’ or ‘To’ a youth in their care.

No Passing Zone

Supervision may usefully explore recent stories and concrete examples which show how this Carer demonstrated her or his capacity to engage in responsively developmental caring with the young person in their care during the past seven days. Be specific and don’t let key themes slide by as unimportant. This key supervisory theme explores how the Carer has consciously entered, or attempted to enter, this young person’s ‘zone of proximal development’ with the aim of nurturing learning outcomes.

Restricted Zone

Good supervision explores how much time is spent in an office or with writing up Care notes when opportunities are there for engaging with young people. Supervision helps to nurture and reinforce intentionality of action amongst out-of-home Carers. The aim is to instil a duty of care message that ‘re-active care is a no-fly zone’. Carers thus learn that they are expected to re-frame daily life experiences with young people in out-of-home care into potential opportunities for pro-active learning for life as a young adult. Here the Supervisor is working in each Carer’s ‘zone of proximal development.’

Some Closing Thoughts on Comfort Zones

A central premise underpinning the therapeutic use of daily life events involves professional recognition that ‘the other 23 hours’ (Trieschman, Whittaker & Brendtro, 1969) are every bit as important as the hour of one-to-one counselling or episode of behaviour management training that gets mandated in a young person’s personal care and treatment plan. The 24-hour curriculum provides powerful opportunities for learning. That curriculum extends well beyond formal classroom experiences. There is research evidence showing how the educational attainments of poorer children actually deteriorates and these children start falling behind their peers during school holiday periods, when these children aren’t at school and are living in social environments with restricted opportunities. Such deterioration is less discernible during the school term (Alexander et al, 2001). Findings such as these should encourage Child and Youth Care Practitioners to more actively create and nurture learning opportunities in the proximal zone of development for each child or young person in their care. This holds, whether that young person is richer or poorer, and it needs to remain Carers’ focus, throughout the course of that young person’s life in out-of-home care. Whether a young person is living in foster care, in supervised kinship care, in receipt of after-school care, engaged in a care leaver programme, receiving in-patient hospital care, attending boarding school, or committed by law to a super- vised residential group care centre, each young person’s ‘zone of proximal development’ merits respect and engagement. When Carers aren’t ‘working in the zone’ with young people, it’s not surprising to find youths such as these ‘zoned out’ from whatever Carers are trying to do. Take time ‘outside your Comfort Zone’ to reflect on how ‘zones of proximal development’ – that relational place nearest to our point of connection with a young person – impacts daily in child and youth care work.

References

Alexander, K., Entwisle, D. & Olson, L. (2001) Schools, achievement, and inequality: a seasonal perspective, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, vol 23, no 2, pp 171–91.

Eichsteller, G. & Holthoff, S. (2010) Social pedagogy training pack, ThemPra Social Pedagogy Community Interest Company.

Emond, R. (2000) Survival of the skilful: An ethnographic study of two groups of young people in residential care, unpublished PhD thesis, University of Stirling.

Fulcher, L. C. (2002) The Duty of Care in Child & Youth Care Practice, Journal of Child and Youth Care Work. 17, 73-84.

Garfat, T.& Fulcher, L. C. (eds) (2011) Applications of a Child and Youth Care Approach, Journal of Relational Child and Youth Care Practice. Volume 24, Numbers 1-2.

Maier, H. W. (1979. ‘The core of care: Essential ingredients for the development of children at home and away from home’, Child Care Quarterly. vol 8, no: pp 161-173.

Parsonson, B. S. (2012) The case for practice-based evidence to support evidence-based practice. Journal of primary health care, Vol. 4, No. 2, 98-99.

Phelan, J. (2001) ‘Experiential counselling and the CYC practitioner’, Journal of Child and Youth Care Work, Vols 15 and 16, special edition, pp 256–63.

Powis, P., Allsopp, M. & Gannon, B. (1989) ‘So the treatment plan’. The Child Care Worker, vol 5, no 5, pp 3-4.

Smith, M., Fulcher, L. C.& Doran, P. (2013) Residential Child Care in Practice: Making a Difference. Bristol: Policy Press.

Stremmel, A. J. (1993) ‘Introduction: Implications of Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory for child and youth care practice’, Child and Youth Care Forum, vol 22, no 5, pp 333–5.

Trieschman, A., Whittaker, J. K. & Brendtro, L. K. (1969) The other 23 hours: child-care work with emotionally disturbed children in a therapeutic milieu, New York: Aldine De Gruyter.

 

This article was originally published in Garfat, Fulcher & Digney (2013). Making Moments Meaningful in Child and Youth Care Practice. Cape Town: Pretext Publishing and then in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 26, No.2 pp22-27

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App