This past summer a statistic about Indigenous peoples in Canada was passed around my School, in support of a claim about the exclusion of Indigenous people in higher education. The historical exclusion is real, but the statistic about contemporary participation was misleading, and a quick search of Statistics Canada data turns up the accurate data. Yet no one challenged this statistic, at least publicly.
This is not surprising, given the outpouring of empathy for excluded groups in recent years and the critiques of quantitative data as intrinsically racist. There has been a lot of racist research, obviously. But Walter and Suina, Indigenous researchers, argue that equating all research and data, especially quantitative data, with racist research and data is a mistake.
“… this critique, in its valid emphasis of the harm wrought by positivism, tends to scoop up all quantitative research as methodologically similar.” – (Walter & Suina, 2019)
The assumption that data about Indigenous accomplishment always shows exclusion and oppression is a problem. It is common for CYC and Social Work literature to cite the same depressing statistics and to justify one’s own positionality, practices, beliefs, and proposed studies on the basis of the “deficits” of Indigenous peoples. Surprisingly, we have reached a point in which the racists and the anti-racists sometimes agree with each other, and this might be a signal that something is outdated about our interpretations. We might want to be reminded that,
“Within this, the Indigene remains the object, caught in a numbered bind, viewed through the straitjacketing lens of deficit”. – (Walter & Suina, 2019, p. 236).
Fortunately, many Indigenous scholars have already begun to address these issues, including the assumption that Indigenous people do not use numbers. For example, Courtney Skye (2020) of the Yellowhead Institute addressed the pandemic:
“The public has never been more saturated by data – number of new cases, number of new deaths, flattening curves, best case projections and so on – yet there is a remarkable absence of clear, public data on how this pandemic is affecting Indigenous peoples.”
Instead of questioning statistical methods, she called for more statistical data produced by Indigenous people.
Walter and Suina (2019) criticized the assumption that only qualitative methods were appropriate for Indigenous people; they argued that Indigenous methods and data, including quantitative data and methods, would tell a more complete story of Indigenous ways of being. They suggest that numeracy has always been a part of Indigenous cultures. Their recommendations were to a) cultivate technical skills among community members related to survey development, data collection, analysis, and reporting, b) build comfort and understanding regarding research methods among tribal partners, c) advocate for Indigenous research methodologies and Indigenous data sovereignty” (pp. 239-240).
In view of the contributions of Black and Hispanic quantitative researchers and mathematicians to quantitative methods and science over the past 100 years, it would be strange – and unfortunate – if Indigenous people were somehow excluded on the basis of the assumption of innate or cultural differences. Instead, Walter and Suina (2019) say
“… there is broad agreement on the need for data, which meet Indigenous data needs and aspirations. These include, but are not limited to, data that disrupt deficit narratives, data that are disaggregated, data that reflect the embodied social, political, historical, and cultural realities of Indigenous people’s lives, as Indigenous peoples, and data that address Indigenous nation re-building agendas” (p 236).
One good example of this is the dissertation by Eva Jewell (2018), examining Indigenous support for governance apart from the Indian Act in Canada, using logistic regression.
These would be good ideas child and youth care – not just Indigenous researchers. It would be helpful to have more studies of child and youth care life worlds that use quantitative methods. It would be helpful if practitioners and evaluators were numerically facile. Counseling psychology, anthropology and family sociology all make use of quantitative as well as qualitative methods, to their benefit. Child and youth care has much work to do, from encouraging numeracy among clients from excluded groups to using mathematics to improve the field.
References
Walter, M., & Suina, M. (2019). Indigenous data, indigenous methodologies and indigenous data sovereignty. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 22:3, 233-243, DOI: 10.1080/13645579.2018.1531228
Sky, Courteny. (2020). Colonialism of the curve. Accessed at: https://yellowheadinstitute.org/2020/05/12/colonialism-of-the-curve-indigenous-communities-and-bad-covid-data/
Jewell, E. (2018). Gimaadaasamin, We Are Accounting For The People: Support For Customary Governance In Deshkan Ziibiing. Doctoral Dissertation, Royal Roads University. Available at https://viurrspace.ca/handle/10613/8527