Over the past twenty years or so, I have quite consistently been coaching teams of child and youth care practitioners in residential and day treatment settings. For the most part, it has been a joy to do this work. Overwhelmingly, the practitioners I have met in this work have been wonderful people trying their very best to meet what they believe to be the needs of the young people in their service settings. The kinds of issues and themes that come up frequently during my gatherings with the practitioner teams include the kinds of things that have forever presented challenges. For example, every few years the same issues emerge about how to control behaviours, how much and in what ways young people ought to have a voice in their settings, whether or not young people should have access to Wi-Fi and mobile phones, issues around consistency, racism, gender normativity, peer dynamics, family involvement and many more. I am always happy to discuss any of these issues and themes, and I find that it is much less important to make decisions about these things or to come up with the right answer as it is to engage these things from as many perspectives as possible. Good practice flows from whatever engages individual practitioners enough to remain in conversation with their team members, and to remain open about possible approaches and ways of doing things that might be different from however these things were thought about and done previously.
There is, however, one issue that seems especially challenging, particularly in residential care and treatment settings and in day treatment (special education) settings. For some reason, practitioners keep coming back to this issue and struggle with resolving it either theoretically or in practice. And yet, in many ways, I think this issue is of such foundational importance that it really does require some level of resolution for good practice to even be possible. I can’t really name this issue, but I can describe it, so here it goes.
In almost all settings, there are periods of time when things are going well, and other periods of time when things are not going particularly well. How we define what it means for things to be going well versus not going well is itself, of course, a matter of perspective. In my experience, most teams think things are going well when the environment itself is relatively calm most of the time, when young people living or studying in that environment more or less abide by the rules, and when practitioners feel that they have positive connections with those young people. In other words, things are going well when there is not too much happening. These periods of time where not much is happening inevitably are interrupted eventually. Almost always, the interruption is about one or two young people doing things differently than all the other young people, challenging the rules, having behavioural incidents, breaking things, or generally requiring enormous effort from the practitioners to maintain some semblance of order in the setting. The disruptive young people, who often are relatively recently admitted to the setting, almost always have considerable instability in their lives. For example, they may have experienced multiple previous placements, or there is a great deal of conflict in the family, or there has been repeated worker turnover amongst the workers assigned to work with the young person individually, or with the family. Sometimes, such young people are labelled developmentally or emotionally in ways that the practitioners believe to be outside of the mandate of their setting. Before long, the talk in the team turns toward questioning the appropriateness of the placement: ‘This young person has needs that cannot be met here’; or ‘until there is some family work done, the young person cannot adjust to this program’; or, my personal favourite, ‘there is no treatment happening with this young person; they should not be here’.
These kinds of conversations happen amongst practitioners not because those practitioners want to blame the young person for their troubles; and also, not because they don’t care or don’t like the young person. They happen, most of the time, for two very specific reasons: First, because the young person has impacted the expectations of practitioners about what their workday will look like; and second, because practitioners worry about how the young person will impact the wonderful treatment progress of the other young people in the setting.
What I always find fascinating about these moments is that we work very hard to frame our belief that a young person shouldn’t be here in the language of treatment. Whether it is about the needs of the young person, the dynamics of their family, or simply that treatment isn’t happening the way practitioners might envision that it should, we are fundamentally framing the problem to be a treatment issue. I believe that this fascination with treatment is the source of serious misunderstandings about child and youth care practice and about being with young people in relational ways. I want to cite exactly five reasons for my belief, and if I had more time, I would expand on these a little more. Since I don’t have that time, I will simply state my five reasons and hope that if you are currently involved in one of those discussions about why a young person shouldn’t be in your setting, you will reflect a little on the following:
First, the needs of young people, no matter how they may behave, respond, or impact a particular setting, are always met. It doesn’t matter what we do as practitioners; young people of any age will always do what they feel they must to meet their needs. The needs that are not being met are the needs of the practitioners and the needs of the setting. Let’s make sure we don’t confuse these with the needs of the young people.
Second, there are many ways to think about what we mean by treatment. One way that I think is especially congruent with relational child and youth care practice is that we work with young people to explore pathways to healing. When we say no treatment is happening, we are saying that we stopped exploring pathways to healing. That seems more on us than on the young people.
Third, we have for many years now convinced ourselves of a narrative that focuses on centering the young person. We think of our practice as child or youth centered. It is not. In fact, our practice is program-centered. Conversations about young people who should not be here are conversations about protecting our programs. We don’t really mind excluding young people who challenge our program; we can just replace them with another young person, and in fact, we do that on a regular basis. Our focus is always the program, which we center in our imagination of where we work and that centers us in our practice. Very few practitioners respond to a question about where they work with ‘in relationship’.
Fourth, as soon as we start conversations about whether or not a young person should be here, we almost always find lots of evidence or good reasons why they should not. It seems that we are always right, and that young people confirm that we are right by behaving accordingly. This dynamic is predictable, because young people always know that you don’t think they should be here before you do. Don’t kid yourself; by the time you verbalize that you question whether a young person should be here, you have already provided a thousand non-verbal indications of that belief to the young person.
Fifth, do you ever wonder what ‘here’ means? Is it a location? A space for activity? A space of relational connections? What exactly are we designating as the ‘here’ where the young person should not be? Could it be that the ‘here’ is really a reference to you? And perhaps the ownership you assert about this space? Can you transfer this same logic to some other contexts? Should immigrants who don’t adjust to your way of being not be ‘here’? Should racialized people who don’t perform whiteness not be ‘here’? Who else shouldn’t be ‘here’? And what healing will be possible in spaces from which we banish people? Perhaps our first instinct was right after all – there is no treatment happening ‘here’. We made sure of that.