Well, it has been a long, tough year and it’s not even over yet. Big changes continue in my university, causing significant stress and uncertainty (and heart-breaking disappointment for some). Similarly, there have been big changes within SIRCC (the Scottish Institute for Residential Child Care) which have also caused significant stress and uncertainty. As a matter of fact, we’re no longer SIRCC but the Centre for Excellence for Looked after Children in Scotland, or CELCIS.
Other changes to my own workload, roles and responsibilities have made it a difficult year. Much of the time I’ve felt I’ve been barely keeping up, or rather, not keeping up. And, I moved home; nine months on I’ve still got boxes to unpack and spaces to figure out. Some of these changes have been positive (though definitely not all), but all carried with them a certain degree of stress and anxiety.
And as ever, when things get to be too much, I get sick. Fortunately I’ve just come down with colds, but several bad ones which have taken weeks to get over. Twice this year I’ve lost my voice. Well, twice literally. I’ve also felt a metaphoric loss of voice over the last few months.
Voice, in one sense, can be thought of as the way a person comes across in writing. Different authors have different voices and this voice is made up of their writing style, the words they choose and the subjects they write about. Finding one’s voice can often be the source of anxiety and struggle for aspiring writers.
Voice has also come to symbolise something beyond one’s writing style. According to some schools of thought, voice requires speaking from a place of authenticity. A Google search, using voice as the search term, yields a plethora of websites for advocacy organisations with voice in their titles. Voice has become a term about assertion, agency and being heard. Having a voice is about having a say, or at least having something to say that is deemed worth listening to.
Finding one’s voice, whether spoken or in writing, requires confidence. It also takes energy. Perhaps we all have encountered circumstances in which, due to our own fear, hopelessness or exhaustion, we didn’t raise our voices even though we felt we should. Sometimes there are just too many occasions where we find ourselves in these circumstances. Whether this happens regularly or at pivotally important moments in our lives, the impacts are corrosive.
In a three year study exploring the views and experiences of ‘at risk’ girls, Taylor, Gilligan and Sullivan (1995, p. 3) write compellingly about the importance of voice for psychological development and well being:
Girls’ descriptions of their increasing isolation and psychological distress, including their experience of having no effective voice, regularly preceded overt manifestations or symptoms of psychological trouble, highlighting the opportunity for prevention and also guiding preventive strategies.
Conversely, they found that
A resonant relationship with a woman, meaning a relationship in which a girl can speak freely and hear her voice clearly resounded as a voice worth listening to and taking seriously – a voice that engages the heart and mind of another and calls forth response – was associated with psychological health and development and what are commonly regarded as good outcomes for the girls in this project: no early motherhood, graduation from high school, for some, higher education and social mobility, and a continuing sense of psychological vitality and involvement in life (p. 4).
For me, this column has been an exercise in voice – both in finding my writerly voice and as a platform for exploring ideas and putting forth arguments about how we might think about practice. I have had the good fortune of enjoying resonant relationships with fellow practitioners and academics (including the editors of CYC-Online ); they have enabled me to speak (and write) more freely, with confidence that I will be taken seriously. It is a privilege and a heavy responsibility.
So how have I managed to lose that confidence, hope and energy that enabled me to overcome all of my writerly anxieties and insecurities each month and risk raising my voice (most months, anyway)? I’m pretty sure that the effects of stress and uncertainty, my own and that absorbed from those around me, has been a significant factor. It has felt pretty uncontained. To be fair, there have been plenty of other forums in which I have raised my voice over the last few months (though how effective it has been is another story).
So what does this have to do with Child and Youth Care practice? Well, the importance of voice is useful in informing how we think about our work with young people. ‘You cannot have voice without relationship, [and] you cannot have relationship without voice’ (ibid, p.210). But I wonder, can we effectively provide resonant relationships with young people if we are not also engaged in raising our own voices and engaging in whatever struggles this process entails?
How much is our ability to really listen affected by a pervasive feeling of not being heard, or worse yet, not feeling our voice is worth listening to? Residential child care in the UK is not as well understood or valued as is necessary for us to meet the needs of our kids and their families – not even close. This is due, in part, to the fact that practitioner voices do not adequately inform policy and practice. There has been a history of practitioners not being expected to (or expecting themselves to) articulate a rationale for their practice in a clear and informed way. And when practitioner voices are raised, they often do not resonate with dominant discourses about care, children or professional relationships and therefore aren’t heard.
It is extremely difficult to raise one’s voice when one doesn’t have the words to make sense of complexities or express deeper understandings. Our own struggles to articulate the complexities of the work and speak out against ill-thought notions of good practice, for instance, parallel young peoples’ struggles to articulate their hurt, anger and confusion in ways that will serve them better in this world. For me, reading or hearing authentic words that actually resonate with my own beliefs, values and experiences has been (and continues to be) instrumental in finding my own words – my voice.
As this body of literature becomes stronger and further reaching, it has the potential to change the above mentioned dominant discourses.
Recently, however, I have found myself avoiding that uncomfortable place of trying to voice something that is difficult to put into words. I also see some of my students and fellow practitioners doing the same. It’s easier to let someone else do it. However, I have felt unsettled and a bit dislocated about missing my monthly column, about not raising my voice in this way and about not meeting this commitment. This makes me wonder about others’ experiences of not speaking up, or of not even finding the words. And I wonder how much harder that is when there hasn’t been support for – or even value given to that struggle.
So I guess this is my exploratory, long-winded, somewhat inarticulate effort to argue for the value of articulating one’s beliefs, values and experiences – of finding and raising our authentic voices – even though for most of us, it is an uncomfortable struggle. These voices, spoken and written, carry the potential to engage the hearts and minds of others, furthering enhancing the vibrancy and collective strength of our sector.
Reference
Taylor, J. M., Gilligan, C., & Sullivan, A. M. (1995). Between voice and silence: Women and girls, race and relationship. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.