My logic is the only way to be logical, except for your logic. When my wife and I have differing opinions, which happens sometimes, I try to show her that she is not being logical. This argument never seems to work, even though it makes perfect sense to me. In fact she often responds that I am not being logical, then describes her “truth” which is not logical at all to me.
I also believe that I have a few suggestions which would improve her as a person, which she also rejects, often with several of her own suggestions about how I might improve. This of course does not seem logical or useful to me.
Perhaps my experience resonates with some readers who may also be
challenged by their partner’s logic. We all have our own beliefs about
the world around us, which creates our logic and reasoning.
Last month I described the concept of humility, which I said was the ability to stay curious and unthreatened when confronted with attitudes and beliefs that contradict your own cherished ideas about life truths. The skill needed is to build bridges between my logic and yours, not to convince you that my logic is better.
People who have suffered abuse and neglect usually have a logic about life truths which challenges most of our socially appropriate norms and rules. In fact, when I have tried to use my logic about relationships, social rules and even what is fair and just, their response has been quite frustrating. The more I appeal to common sense (my logic), the more annoying the other person seems to become. Often I can get other Child and Youth Care people on my team to agree with me about my logic, but even the weight of our collective logic fails to be convincing to the youths I work with.
I find that logical consequences, so cherished by me and the rest of the team, often do not fit the logic of the youth, and the frustration evident in the youths’ responses mirrors my frustration at their lack of understanding (i.e. my logical perspective) of what is happening.
I also regularly describe in reports, treatment contracts, and daily logs the logical suggestions that I have created for how they can improve as persons, which I can make them sign, but they do not seem to “own” them (see above description of my wife).
Rather than trying to get the youth to be more logical, I started to
realize that they were very logical already, and that I needed to create
bridges between our differing logic about how the world works.
This is not an easy task in any relationship, but especially when our beliefs are potentially so divergent. Fortunately, one of us is actually getting paid to be more understanding, so the task, while difficult, is possible. Humility is the first step. Next month I will describe a bit more about the task.