CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 152 OCTOBER 2011

Relatedness and Control

Varda Mann-Feder

One of the significant dilemmas Child and Youth Care Workers face is reconciling the need for relationship with the necessity of providing control. This article reviews two major theories that have contributed to the view that attachment and discipline are mutually exclusive. However, a review of research findings suggests that it is only through the integration of relatedness and control that optimal growth and development can be encouraged. Implications for practice are outlined.

Child and Youth Care Work is a demanding profession in which the practitioner is confronted by multiple and sometimes contradictory mandates. One of the significant dilemmas Child and Youth Care Workers face daily is reconciling the need for relationship with the necessity of providing control. How can the role of attachment figure and disciplinarian be reconciled? How can discipline, even necessary punishment, be provided without destroying trust and security?

The literature of the helping professions has not always helped us to deal with the difficult problem of integrating relatedness and control. Traditionally, views on this topic have been polarized. This is because two distinct conceptual frameworks that have competed since their inception have dominated Western thinking about how human beings are socialized and develop internal controls.

Theoretical influences

Psychodynamic theory, originated with Freud but including contemporary models such as Attachment theory, was the earliest approach to espouse views about human development and child rearing.

This theory champions the primacy of emotional relationships, especially early adult-child relationships, and teaches that self-control comes from relatedness. This theory also privileges relationships as the central tool in any therapeutic intervention. Psychodynamic theory explains that acting out and poor self control in young people result from relationship deficits in early life. Individual behavioral difficulties can only be addressed through the provision of a relationship with a non-punitive, nurturing adult whose focus is to interact with the youth in a close loving manner. The idea here is that once the child begins to experience the reliable and predictable satisfaction of needs that a loving relationship provides, a sense of security will emerge which also promotes self-control. Psychodynamic theory goes on to say that any approach to child management other than this will not have any lasting effect on behaviour, because only relatedness can stimulate the development of internal controls.

The implication for practice is that, paradoxically, discipline is best served through acceptance, permissiveness and an emphasis on relationships. “Nurturance must come first. Nor will limit-setting responses alone be effective with patients who have been deprived in their early life of both limit setting and nurturance. For them, acting out behavior has been a cry for attention and love” (p.11, Wilson & Soth, 1985). Some authors even exhort the worker to tolerate minor behavioural lapses whenever possible in favour of a more long-term goal of instilling security and the motivation to become self-disciplined. Implied in this model is that closeness with adults inspires respect for rules and the wish to maintain approval, while the explicit role of disciplinarian actually negates the closeness. “ In essence, the successful therapeutic approach to action-oriented individuals is based on reducing the unrelatedness that all these youngsters have” (p.367, Symonds, 1974).

Learning theory first emerged as a reaction against psychodynamic theory. Major criticisms were that change strategies that rely on the development of relationships are time consuming and expensive and do not address the specific problems of individuals whose behavioural functioning has been problematic. The major assumption of learning theory (advanced in its most radical form by Skinner) is that all behaviour is learned, and reflects each young person’s individual history of reward and punishment. The consequences of actions influence whether or not an individual learns self-control and acting out has little to do with early experiences with relatedness. If a young person engages repeatedly in inappropriate behaviour, it is because this behaviour has brought benefits to the individual in the past. Even punishment can be gratifying, especially if the youth has gotten attention and/or notoriety though negative behaviour. In a learning model, any adult can manage behaviour if they are adept at manipulating the consequences of a young person’s behaviour consistently. “The better one understands the principles and theories of learning, the better one will be at changing behavior” (p.110, Stein, 1995). The internal state of the youth is irrelevant — as is the relationship with the intervener.

Both psychodynamic and learning theory have had a powerful impact on the evolution of Child and Youth Care Work, as is evident especially in models of residential care (Whittaker, 1981). Both theories held a fascination for me at different times in my career. Early on, I was trained in the use of Behaviourism or radical learning theory. I came to my first job in a Child and Youth Care setting with a passionate belief in contingency management, which in our context meant point and level systems that relied heavily on rewards to modify behaviour (Craig, 1999). I spent many a team meeting designing behavioural charts, discussing the merits of reinforcement over punishment and assisting Child and Youth Care Workers in identifying relevant rewards. We never concerned ourselves with who would dispense these rewards, or what the relationship context would contribute. In fact, as a consultant, I stressed that all Child and Youth Care Workers involved with the youth needed to respond in exactly the same way in relation to the “target behaviours” — the critical ingredient was the provision of consistent consequences. This often proved to be a very effective technique for specific behavioural problems. The youth in question did learn prosocial alternatives and soon complied to earn rewards. But as many authors have pointed out (Schaffer, 1979) the application of learning theory is most effective in promoting change in discrete behaviours. It does little to instill an overall sense of self-control. At the same time, the charts and points assumed monumental importance in the daily interactions between Child and Youth Care Workers and young people, creating a distance that was difficult to overcome. The relationship was between a youth and the team, who acted in concert as behavioural technicians.

Over time, I became disenchanted with learning theory. It began to feel mechanistic, overly simplistic and like I was advocating a cookie cutter approach to our work. Many young people who experienced this model seemed to learn within the structure provided, but it was less clear that any more lasting change in behavior was occurring. As stated by Bettleheim, “The fundamental issue is the creation of conditions that will not only allow but strongly induce a child to wish to be a moral, disciplined person” (1985, p.52). There was little evidence that learning approaches had any long-term impact on moral development, self-control, or self-discipline.

With the emerging popularity of Attachment theory in the 80’s and 90's, and the thriving literature of Child and Youth Care Work, which stressed relatedness and synchronicity (Fewster, 1990: Garfat, 1998: Weisman, 1999), my thinking began to change. A crucial ingredient in any intervention had to be relationship, and not just the relationship to a program or a team. The relationship had to be specific and intimate, involving one identified adult whose task it was to make a meaningful connection with one young person. This dyadic interaction was necessary to compensate for the inadequate early attachments experienced by most children and adolescents in our care. The critical elements in this relationship included unconditional acceptance, responsiveness, reliability, and a capacity for attuned interactions. “Being present is not enough, it means visible involvement in the children’s daily lives, beyond the tasks of being supervisors or appraisers of their behavior” (Maier, 1994).

My subsequent discussions with Child and Youth Care Workers focused on relationship issues. Discipline was now secondary and could only be a long-term goal. Intervention planning meetings involved identifying the person who would devote time and energy in investing in a young person. We looked at ways to create opportunities for high quality dyadic interactions and debated on issues of selection — should a primary worker be selected or should the young person’s preferences prevail? How could natural affinities be taken into account and what were the implications for the team? In advocating an approach more in line with Psycho-dynamic theory, discipline became a contentious issue.

The responsibility for socialization and teaching normative behavior is an inevitable responsibility for any adult who cares for young people. It is also unavoidable that limit setting, in the short term, creates tension, conflict and, at times, arouses hostility.

In many instances, the young person’s connections to a Child Care Worker are tenuous and tentative, reflecting early deprivations and a reluctance to trust. It soon became common, in some settings, to separate the role of attachment figure from that of disciplinarian. If limits had to be set or if a consequence for negative behaviour was needed, someone other than the “special worker” would step in to exert control. A kind of “good cop, bad cop” model evolved in some programs, leading to tensions in the team and splitting reactions in the youth. Were we further ahead?

Research contributions

It turns out that there have been major efforts to clarify the interaction of relatedness and control through research. The application of findings in two areas will be described below, but the punch line is the same similar: internal controls are acquired in the best possible way when behavioural restrictions are provided in the context of a nurturing relationship. The relationship context matters a great deal, as does the provision of structure and limit setting. Relatedness does promote control, but only when consistent discipline and limits are provided by the adults who have a specific and warm connection to a young person. Not only does this combination promote age appropriate behavioural functioning, it also impacts positively on overall adjustment. Henry Maier suggested this years ago. In 1987, he explained: “Social capability rests upon personal attachment. Children learn most readily from those who have meaning for them. It is essential to keep in mind that the most potent behavioural treatment goes hand in had with a sense of reciprocal closeness and attachment” (p.118).

The research on parenting styles grew out of a need to clarify the specific aspects of parental behavior that impact on children early in life. Over time, investigators identified four consistent and reliable dimensions of parenting style: warmth, control (as contrasted with permissiveness), consistency, and democratic decision-making (as contrasted with autocratic functioning). These dimensions can be measured, and are relatively stable over time (Baumrind, 1971). Researchers, in trying to capture the complexity of parent child interactions in real life, began to examine combinations of the parenting style dimensions, and relate them to observations of child behavior. This work, which began with families of young children, has been extended to adolescents, and reflects multiple studies over many years (Santrock, Mackenzie-Rivers, Leung & Malcolmson, 2003).

The most powerful and consistent finding of research in this area is that warmth and moderate control correlate significantly with self-esteem, altruism, coping, achievement and age appropriate self-discipline (Bee & Boyd, 2002). Contrary to the predictions of many psychodynamic theorists, permissiveness with warmth correlates significantly with non-compliance, low self-esteem, domineering tendencies and immaturity (Santrock et al, 2003). On the other hand, the absence of warmth in the presence of control correlates with compliance, but also is strongly associated with aggression towards the self, poor self-esteem, fearfulness, unhappiness and poor communication skills (Baumrind, 1971).

This research strongly suggests that the dichotomy between relationship and control is misleading. The weight of the evidence, though admittedly correlational, suggests that both are needed to promote behavioural competence and positive adjustment. A supporting finding of direct relevance to our work, is that in the absence of warmth, more extreme and punitive disciplinary techniques are required to elicit cooperation. On the other hand, there is no evidence that control interferes with warmth between adults and young people.

A model developed after Skinner within the parameters of learning theory was that of observational learning. Associated with the work of Bandura, this model posits that many complex social behaviors are learned through imitation, and through the observation of consequences for others. In this theory, internal states do influence the acquisition of behavioural controls, because in order to learn, youth people must watch and remember (attend and retain) what has been modeled.

The Bandurians have widely researched the process of learning, and specifically the conditions that influence successful attention and retention. A major finding of this research is that we all attend differentially to different models and that how we attend reflects relationship issues. It turns out we learn best from individuals who we admire, we identify with, and with whom we have a warm connection (Shaffer, 1989). In addition, the more verbal contact we have with the model, and the more that is explained, the better our learning will be, especially in relation to inhibitory controls (Brody & Shaffer, 1982).

These findings suggest that even within a learning paradigm, relationships facilitate the acquisition of discipline. A further contribution is that verbal communication and explanations of discipline enhance learning and further create conditions for the integration of self-control.

Final thoughts

Competing theories in the literature of the helping professions have led to a false dichotomy between the concepts of relatedness and control. It is now abundantly clear that practitioners of different orientations have had to acknowledge the critical importance of integrating discipline with warmth and acceptance. To choose one over the other deprives young people in our care of appropriate developmental conditions.

Another implication of the research is that warmth works best in concert with moderate control, that emphasizes verbal contact and rational explanations of behavioral restrictions (Brody & Shaffer, 1982). Too much restrictiveness has been found to create resentment and increase the likelihood of an adversarial situation, while at the same time creating dependency on external structures and an incapacity for initiative (Santrock et al, 2003).

In the final analysis, the greatest challenge may be to consider the balance between relatedness and control as it relates to us as interveners. Wilson & Soth (1985) acknowledge that most individuals who practice with young people are forced to face their own needs for control as part of the initiation into the work, and that often this takes the form of a crisis. Our perceptions of our own competency may be at issue when the youth in our care are defiant or noncompliant. There is a real risk that our needs for control may, at times, dominate over our needs to connect. At the same time, we need to be aware of our own issues with attachment and how this can play out with the young people in our care. Relatedness and control are not at odds, but are in fact complementary. The best evidence available to date would dictate that we provide moderate control in the context of warm, available relationships with adults and that we encourage development, not compliance for its own sake. As stated eloquently by Fox (1994), “kids can be loved (affirmed) and managed while they are becoming ‘empowered’”. It truly is this combination that is at the heart of our profession.

References

Baumrind, D. (1971) Current patterns of parental authority. Developmental Psychology Monographs, 4 (1, pt 2).

Bee, H. & Boyd.D. (2002) Lifespan Development (3rd Ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Bettleheim, B. (1985) Punishment versus Discipline. The Atlantic Monthly, Nov., 51-59.

Brody, G.H. & Shaffer, D.R. (1982) Contributions of parents and peers to children’s moral development. Developmental Review, 21, 31-75.

Craig, G.J. (1999) Human Development. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Simon & Shuster.

Fewster, G. (1990) Growing together: the personal relationship in Child and Youth Care. In Anglin, J., Denholm. C., Ferguson, R. & Pence, A. (Eds.) Perspectives in Professional Child and Youth Care. New York: Haworth.

Garfat, T. (1998) Questions – relationships. Online discussion on CYC-Net. See here.

Maier, H. (1987) The core of care: essential ingredients for the development of children at home and away from home. Developmental Group Care of Children. New York: Haworth.

Maier, H. (1994) Attachment development is “in”. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 9 (11), 35-52.

Shaffer, D. (1989) Developmental Psychology: Childhood and Adolescence. (2nd Ed) Pacific Grove, California: Brooks/Cole.

Stein, J.A. (1995) Residential Treatment of Adolescents and Children: Issues, Principles and Techniques. Chicago: Nelson.

Symonds, M.(1974) Therapeutic approaches to acting out. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 18(3), 362-368.

Weisman, V. (1999) Relationships? What is it we do... It is what we do. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 13(2), 125-131.

Wilson, M.R. & Soth, N.B. (1984) The staff member’s crisis of control in Psychiatric residential treatment: from countertransference to personal influence. Residential and Group Care, 2(4), 3-14.

This feature: Mann, Varda. (2003) Relatedness and Control. Relational Child and Youth Care Practice Vol.16 No.3 pp 10-14

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App