There can be no doubt that Child and Youth Care practice with families is complex and demanding. In this chapter we provide you with some ‘food for thought’ as you begin your work with families. We want to offer some stimulus to encourage you to begin to reflect upon various aspects of working with families.
Child and youth care practitioners who engage with families are not family therapists in the normal or traditional sense of that term. Nor are they social workers, psychologists or some other human services professional, although many of the tasks, philosophies, and skills across the various professions are quite similar. Child and youth practitioners are professionals in their own right and, as such, we believe, should practice within a Child and Youth Care framework. We are not therapists although our work is genuinely therapeutic. We do not follow the models of other professions, although we learn from, and in many cases contribute to, them. We believe that in order to be an effective practitioner with families, the Child and Youth Care worker must know, and be fully grounded in, our own profession and the way in which we consider family in our field.
It seems simplistic to say so but all of us have previous experiences that are relevant to our current interactions as practitioners. These experiences greatly influence how we work with people. Our previous experiences of trying to be helpful, of working with families, of receiving help themselves, or of working independently may be of importance to the practitioners. The same holds true for families. Previous experiences with social workers or with police or other helpers of trying to obtain help and of having strangers in the house may all be relevant for the family. And, of course, the previous history of practitioners and families are relevant to the others as are our own experiences as members of families. Family, in whatever form we understand it, significantly influences all of us (Fewster, 2004). The importance of history cannot be denied. When we enter in to a situation, or have an experience, we search for ways to make sense of that experience (this will be discussed more in the chapter on meaning-making). One of the most powerful influences on how we experience and interpret that experience is our previous experiences of similar situations.
As an example of this imagine for a moment that a practitioner is going to visit a family who lives in a particular neighbourhood. The last time that this worker visited a family in this area she was thrown out of the family home by a mother, angry and possibly threatened with something she thought the worker had said. It is impossible for the worker not to be influenced by the previous experience she had when going now to visit this new family. She may be scared, hesitant, determined, cautious and maybe even excited as she uses her framework of previous similar experiences to prepare herself for this new encounter.
Imagine, too, that the family who is waiting for the worker to arrive has made numerous attempts to obtain help, although in a more traditional, office based, form. They did not believe that any of the previous attempts had been helpful. The help has not seemed to resolve the problems they were experiencing. As they wait for the worker to arrive, they are likely thinking about these previous experiences. The question to ask then is how will their current expectations be influenced by these previous experiences? How might their expectations be different if all of their previous experiences had resulted in positive outcomes? How might this impact on their current expectations?
It may be helpful if we explained this a bit further. For example, how families initially see us is influenced by all of the other experiences they have had with ‘helpers’ before us. It is important to be aware that we are often not seen an individual when members of families first meet us. Rather we are seen as a combination of every other ‘helper’ they have every interacted with throughout their lives. If their experiences have been helpful then they are likely to assume that we will be helpful. If their experiences have been negative then they are likely to assume that their experiences with us will be negative. This may not be fair to us but it is just the way it is, not just for families but for all of us. We all often tend to initially judge what is about to happen by what has happened in similar situations in the past.
Reflective Questions
When we work with families we need to be aware of how we are influenced by our perceptions of previous experiences. As we prepare ourselves for our encounters with families, we need to ask: What am I bringing to this encounter from my own previous history? How might my experiences in my own family influence what I will be doing and ‘seeing’? What experiences have I had as a worker that might influence me? What similar situations have I encountered? And how do these help or hinder me now? As we work with families, we need to try to understand how our and their previous experiences may influence on our encounter.
Opening up the Definition of Family
We mentioned in the opening chapter of this book that family may well be who you consider it to be rather than what you consider it to be. While historically the definition of ‘family’ was confined to a married couple and their offspring, or included the broad extended family, we have seen a change in the definition to reflect the greater inclusiveness and reality of a contemporary society. Family has probably always defined in a broad and ‘non-traditional’ manner by some of us although it is only recently that these ways of seeing family has become more widely accepted. It is not uncommon now, for example, to see the definition of family in Child and Youth Care practice as: the members of a biologically connected system who have impact, or the potential for impact, on the young person in care or, persons not biologically related who have assumed roles traditionally occupied by biologically related persons. The following example illustrates this point:
Marcie, 15, was admitted to the residential treatment programme with the understanding that she had ‘no family’. She had been in the care of the system for six years and in that time had had no ‘family contact’ of any kind. Her mother had died a few months after Marcie was taken in to care and her father was unknown to the social services system. No-one had any idea of who he might be. Her maternal grandparents were also dead. Her paternal grandparents were, of course, also unknown.
Marcie was always reactive at those times when other young people had family contact. Weekends when parents and siblings visited, holidays, and vacations were times when staff expected that Marcie would ‘act out’ in response to her sense of being alone and without family. As Marcie stayed in the residential treatment centre it was painful for the staff to observe. They became determined to find family for Marcie, for they operated under the assumption that everyone needs family.
To make a long story short, the staff began to search for family and here is what they found:
The staff of the programme made contact with all these people each of whom was interested in contact with Marcie. At the time of the next holiday, Marcie had to make a choice as to which ‘family member’ she was going to go and visit. She came into the center with ‘no family’ and she left with an aunt, an uncle and two sisters, all of whom were as real a family for Marcie as any biological relatives could have been. When one broadens one’s definition of family, there are often ‘family members’ to be found.
Reflective Questions
The Advantages of a Child and Youth Care Approach to Working with Families
A Child and Youth Care approach to working with families is inherently different than other approaches. It is founded in the values and beliefs of Child and Youth Care and because of this we suggest it has certain advantages over other approaches. Primary among these characteristics is the fact that Child and Youth Care practitioners work with families in their environments, in their homes, not in an office detached from the daily life of the family. This is consistent with the characteristic of our approach to being with people as they live their lives’. We help people learn to live their lives differently in the places where those lives are lived.
This holds true whether the Child and Youth Care practitioner is engaged with families from the base of a residential or a community programme. Meeting with families in their environment is consistent with the principle of Child and Youth Care work of ‘meeting them where they are’ (Krueger, 1998). While there have been arguments made both for and against working with families in their homes, here are some of the advantages, as we see it, of doing so:
Reflective Questions
Some of the Demands of Child and Youth Care
Family Work
Working with families is a difficult and challenging form of Child and Youth Care practice. Yet, at least in the initial stages, everyone wants to do it. Interestingly, in our experience, most people at first think it will be easier than residential work. We have seen a rush over the years to work with families as if one could simply reach out and make a difference. In the end it turns out this is far from reality. Here are a few of the reasons people have cited as to why, or how, family work is difficult:
Some people might argue that getting started in working with families is easier if one has not been previously employed in a residential environment because the worker does not have to adapt from working in one context to working in another. One does not have to ‘make the shift’ (Shaw & Garfat, 2004) from one environment to another and, quite frankly, some of the habits which have been developed in a residential programme do not have to be undone or relearned.
However, we believe that the practitioner who has previous experience in a residential environment, and who learns family work as a part of the transition of a residential environment, brings to the work a number of advantages. Residential work is, perhaps, the best environment in which to learn a Child and Youth Care approach. In the context of support, guidance and a familiar environment, the practitioner grows through the developmental stages of becoming a competent worker (Phelan, 1999), learns to think systemically, develops the ability to respond quickly, becomes familiar with ‘surprises’ and develops an organised approach to her work. She learns the process of ‘doing with’ (Garfat, 2001) which is essential to effective work with families. She also learns a range of creative ways of working with the challenges that young people can throw at us.
As well, when the practitioner learns about working with families as a part of a programme transition, he has time to adapt and to try on different approaches. He is not forced head first in to full engagement in this challenging work.
However, make no mistake, when one is making the shift to working with families after having developed skills in working with individuals, special challenges arise. As Shaw & Garfat (2004) have noted, not everyone should do family work because not everyone is up to this type of challenge.
Indeed, it is possible to identify the characteristics of Child and Youth Care practitioners who are effective in working with youth and families. The following chapters identify more of the characteristics of this approach, and of those who seem to be able to use it effectively.
This feature: Chapter 2 of Garfat, T. and Charles, G. (2010). A Guide to Developing Effective Child and Youth Care Practice with Families. Cape Town: Pretext Publishers.