CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 152 OCTOBER 2011

Commandment 6: Get to Know Kids from the Inside-Out

Gerry Fewster

When all the guff is pushed aside, most Child and Youth Care workers are expected to perform two basic tasks. The first is to eliminate behaviours that adults have deemed to be unacceptable. The second is to ensure that the problems don’t reoccur by changing the way kids think and feel about themselves and the world those same adults have created. This bottom-line contract is what I like to call the Management and Meddling, or “M&M,” Imperative.

Please don’t misunderstand me. I’m not suggesting we shouldn’t try to change behaviours that are offensive or self-defeating. There’s no pleasure in being around kids who persistently abuse themselves and others – particularly if the ‘other’ happens to be me? And, to be honest, some our most effective tools are designed to control behaviour, especially in residential settings where we have the power and call all the shots.

In the meddling department, we have a tempting smorgasbord of theories and techniques generously provided by our friends in medicine, psychology social work. Of course we don’t offer treatment or therapy (how pretentious would that be?) but most of those nifty intervention techniques we like to brag about have been borrowed from the psychotherapy folks who are professionals with fee-paying clients and licences to practice. When it comes to measurable outcomes, however, only the good old chemical fix, along with its adjunct, cognitive-behaviour therapy, seem to have any hope of demonstrating statistical significance. Ah well …

My purpose here is not to condemn, or even question, the foundations of Child and Youth Care practice. I only want to point out that they are essentially ‘outside-in’ strategies. By this I mean that the practitioner (the adult) is both the initiator and agent of change while the recipient (the kid) is the willing or resistant respondent. Whatever the program brochures might say, almost in variably it’s the adult who determines what’s to be changed and what the outcomes should look like. And it’s the commitment and skill of the adults that provide the resources to make it all happen. When all is said and done, it’s these things that determine whether practitioners are considered to be effective, their practices valid and their programs funded. There’s nothing inherently wrong with this. If we waited for the kids to decide what they want to change, and how they want to go about it, we’d be herding them into geriatric centres. Yet, something is sadly missing.

The problem is that kids who have been exposed to an outside-in regime, tend to develop and outside-in mentality. They see themselves as beneficiaries or victims of their circumstances, depending upon whether they’re considered to be winners or losers. So whether kids chose to thank me for changing their lives, or blame me for the abuse I inflicted upon them, I am equally disturbed. Their inability or unwillingness to see that they have the resources within themselves to create the lives they want keeps them stuck in their own quagmire. At the heart of the matter, they have no idea who they are, what options are available and how they might take charge of their lives. The missing piece is their inability to look at themselves, to reflect upon their experience and to take action on their own behalf.

The Inside-Out Alternative

Traditional outside-in methods identify the practitioner as the primary agent of change.

For the most part, they are based upon some notion of deficit or disability used to justify professional intervention. Inside-out approaches, on the other hand, are based upon the belief that all kids have the inner resources and potential to create their own lives in their own way. The initiator may still be the adult but, from the outset, the focus is upon the subjective experiences of the young person rather than some popularized label and predetermined plan of action. In this way, the process of change moves in the opposite direction. The primary skills of the practitioner are relational sensitivity and responsivity, rather than medical-style diagnosis and intervention and the enduring stance is one of persistent curiosity. In some ways this is similar to the ‘client-centred’ approaches advocated by Carl Rogers in the 1960’s although the issues and the context are quite different.

Assuming an inside-out perspective isn’t an immediate all-or-nothing stance. Most kids, and particularly those in trouble, are raised and educated through external contingencies and controls. As a consequence, they create their own ways of protecting a fearful Self from hostile or neglectful world. Any sudden attempt to change the rules, however well intended, will more than likely be treated with suspicion and resisted, thereby strengthening the defensive armour. What’s called for is an incremental shift that builds trust and gradually draws attention to what’s happening on the inside. This usually requires considerable patience on the part of the practitioner, but pushing too hard, slapping a label on the resistance, or resenting the resentment, will only serve to strengthen the defensive walls.

Sometimes, it’s necessary to hang onto the faith that there isn’t a kid on this planet who wouldn’t want to be seen and heard by a trusted and caring adult. On the other side, by coming to understand a young person’s inner world, a professional will be in a position to respond to that world and employ only those methods that promote the development of an effective self – from the inside out. Using external rewards, for example, may bring about the desired changes in behaviour but there’s all the difference in the world between a reward that enhances self-efficacy and one that confirms the very opposite – even though the behaviours may appear identical. Only by understanding the individual’s subjective experience is it possible to make such distinction.

The Role of the Child and Youth Care Professional

In making this case, I’m not suggesting that Child and Youth Care professionals should begin to think of themselves as ‘therapists’. The role of therapist can never be assumed by anyone who exercises control or authority over his or her clients – it’s that simple.

However much we might like to deny the much-maligned power-differential, it’s a reality that will never go away. Personally, I believe it to be an essential ingredient of child and youth work – one that makes it possible for us to go straight to the heart of the matter.

The Child and Youth Care relationship may become a meeting of selves, but trying to turn it into a meeting of peers is counter-productive and just plain silly. In the first place, most of the kids we work with do not choose to work with us, so our very presence in their lives is an authoritarian imposition. Secondly, most of their recurring difficulties are actually developmental interruptions that have been created through their relationships with significant adults – parents and caregivers in particular. These must be resolved if the youngster is to move on and, in many cases, the Child and Youth Care professional is the ‘ideal’ adult authority with whom he or she can work through the omissions and transgressions of the past.

Some Child and Youth Care folks dislike placing themselves in this role for a variety of reasons but, whether we like it or not, kids will continue to turn us into surrogate parents and project their hopes and anger in our direction. This isn’t detrimental to the work, it’s an opportunity to bring about change. We are talking about classical ‘transference’ and effective professionals will know how to recognize it, be comfortable with it, and incorporate it into their practice. This doesn’t mean they will slip into the ‘counter-transference’ trap by becoming pretend parents – only that they will stand firmly enough in the adult role to allow the youngster to do the necessary developmental work that couldn’t be accomplished around Mommy and Daddy. This may sound like a complex and delicate process, which of course, it is. The trouble is that very few practitioners are trained to work with this powerful aspect of the Child and Youth Care relationship. Perhaps the day will come when this, along with many other relational tools, becomes part of our collective professional package.

Returning to the central theme of this article, we need to ask whether it’s possible for us to see and hear kids for who they really are, given our place of authority and the expectations placed upon us (see paragraph one)? On the other side, will kids ever trust enough to reveal their inner world and risk exposing their tremulous selves to an ‘authority’ figure with a hidden agenda? If the inherent power differential prevents us from being therapists, are we able to become listeners or witnesses? The simple answer is to all of the above is ‘yes’ but there are many obstacles conspiring against this prospect, and most of them belong to us.

First we have to suspend the belief that relationships are convenient vehicles through which one person is able to modify the experience or behaviour of another. This doesn’t work in Child and Youth Care any more than it works in marriage. When the object of the exercise is for one person to see and hear another, there can be no other agenda and what emerges is a relationship that is in an end itself. But Child and Youth Care folks do have agendas – lots of them. They’re in our minds when we devise programs, plan activities and try to discourage Crystal Moffat from carving up her arms with a razor blade. And with every agenda there comes a desired outcome, a chance for “success” and a favourable evaluation from those who exercise their authority over us. It’s the work, folks it’s what we do. The question is, can we bracket-off our assumptions and aspirations to simply hear what Crystal has to say about her inner world without jumping in to make everything right? Well, as Mr. Obama used to say “Yes we can” but, just like the beleaguered U.S. President, we face many formidable challenges along the way.

Allow me to make a few suggestions for practitioners who wish to see and hear kids for who they really are and lay the foundations for working from the inside-out.

Showing-Up

The first essential step is to ‘show-up’ – to bring the unadorned adult Self to the party. Only an authentic Self can make contact with another Self. There are two aspects to this. The first is to be aware of all those tempting and subversive little agendas that are still sticking to your intentions and let them go. The second is to become aware of your own internal state – your thoughts, feelings and physical sensations – they are all parts of the same system that is you. By far the most direct access to this information is through the breath. In opening up your awareness, sit down comfortably with your feet firmly grounded and notice how you’re breathing – fast, slow, deep, shallow etc. Then take a couple of deep belly-breaths and close your eyes. Notice any physical, emotional and cognitive shifts. Repeat this until you feel fully connected to your internal experience. Then open your eyes and, from that inner place, make contact with the outside world of objects, colours, smells, etc. When you can switch back and forth freely between the inside and the outside, you are ready be fully present with another without losing your Self in the process. From this place, the task is one of inviting the more unsure Self of the youngster to come forward – to the place we call the “contact boundary.”

Staying Curious

Just because you’ve made your-Self available, doesn’t mean the other Self is going to come rushing out with open arms. In all likelihood, this will be an unfamiliar, even threatening, experience for your young partner, so you might expect defences to be strengthened as the sincerity of your invitation is put to the test. It could take a while, so it’s usually best to begin the process in short scheduled sessions – say 30 minutes of ‘together time’ after school. You may get the silent treatment, superficial chit-chat, recursive questions or sundry accusations, but the key is to stay in touch with your-Self and remain open to whatever is coming from the other side – without judgments or interventions. Your quest is for connection and your search is driven by unconditional curiosity. The more protected the younger Self, the longer it will take but sooner or later, usually when you least expect it, the defences will momentarily drop and you will sense an unfamiliar presence peeking out from the battlements. This is a moment of truth and if you’re there to acknowledge and welcome the stranger into the fold, the inside-out shift begins and a new relationship is born. From this point on, it’s not so much what you do, but who you are that counts.

As with a young child, this delicate relationship must now be nurtured with the adult establishing the conditions and showing the way. To this end, it’s essential that, within the range of daily activities and events, time is still set aside for direct Self-to-Self communication. What the emerging Self needs is not a judge or a teacher but an accurate mirror – an affirmation of its existence, rightness and validity. While mirroring is a natural ability, it is also a skill that should be honed by any professional who works relationally with either children or adults. The problem is that it’s not possible to reflect what you don’t have. In other words, you cannot accurately mirror another unless you have been accurately mirrored. Since it’s highly unlikely that you grew up with mirrors that fully reflected what you thought and felt, there’s always some remedial work to be done. In reviewing the following descriptions of mirroring styles, it might be useful for you to consider which style best describes your own experience growing up since this is likely to be the style you will adopt in reflecting the experience of others.

Mirrors that Lie

Do you want kids to succeed in life? To feel good about themselves? To have a positive attitude? Of course you do, and the obvious strategy is to focus on the good stuff and ignore the crappyola. “Well done,” “Brilliant” “Fantastic” “You’re so talented” we cry as the kid struggles to match the billing. And the more serious the perceived deficit, the more we amplify the positive message. It’s called over-mirroring and it’s still the most popular motivational technique employed by parents, professionals and athletic coaches who push kids to perform to some predetermined agenda. Behaviourally it can appear to work like a charm but, faced with such exaggerated reflections, a fragile Self can easily be overwhelmed, withdrawing from the action and leaving the performer to carry on alone. Over time, the successful ones remain empty on the inside while the failures build up layers of protection from a barrage of negative judgments and labels. The use of over-mirroring to promote self-esteem remains universally popular, even though it pushes the authentic Self has into hiding, leaving the kid with nothing on the inside to feel good about. The Self the world sees is a fake – an image of success that wraps itself around the ego to become whatever is required to earn the most valued rewards.

Perhaps you believe kids should get on with their own lives with minimal adult intervention? “That’s nice dear… now go and wash-up before dinner.” At the extreme end, this occurs when the significant adult is not energetically present or tends to respond well below the child’s level of excitement. The result is that he or she is left feeling unseen, unheard and even abandoned. This is under-mirroring – hazy reflections from the outside that lack definition and form, leaving the recipient feeling, incomplete, invisible and, in many cases, abandoned. In the extreme case, the fledgling Self comes to doubt its very existence. Lacking in substance and validation, it has no voice and nothing to say to the outside world.

Professionals who are more concerned with behavioural outcomes than Self-development frequently combine these two styles into a technique known as selective mirroring. Typically, they will over-mirror the desired responses and under-mirror the behaviours to be extinguished. This is a classical outside-in approach that pays little or no attention to what the youngster is actually experiencing on the inside.

This mirror reflects only what the adults want to see and encourages the creation and presentation of a “false-self” that expresses the good bits while stuffing the rest into the psychic closet Carl Jung referred to as “The Shadow.”

Perhaps you believe that kids should be given straightforward, no-nonsense feedback – particularly those who behave badly. Of course there may be times when this might be in the kid’s best interests but as a general stance, critical mirroring can be developmentally disastrous. In this case, the authentic experiences of the child are constantly interrupted by the negative introjects of the adult. On the inside, feelings are not only discounted, they are “wronged” and an unacceptable Self withdraws into its own protective shell.

Do you think kids benefit by knowing that adults have experiences similar to their own? “Hey, I understand exactly how you feel buddy. When I was your age, I was sent away to summer camp and …” Again, there may be an appropriate time for such stories but as a basic stance, it amounts to the adult projecting his or her own stuff onto the experiences of the child. Referred to as narcissistic mirroring, glimpses of the child’s interior world are used as opportunities to express the needy Self of the adult. This often passes as teaching, or sharing, or affirming but, in effect, boundaries have been violated and a fragile Self has been dismissed.

At the extreme end, very few of us were presented with a mirror that was so fragmented that it bore no relation to the structures of consensual reality. This type of psychotic-mirroring is not common but it can be found within the Child and Youth Care arena and may explain how psychotic behaviour can be passed down from one generation to the next without having to resort to genetics – just a thought.

I offer these as discreet examples of faulty mirroring but, in actuality, they are usually blended and most of us have been exposed to all of them at one time or another. Understanding that our earliest experiences of being mirrored (i.e. before the age of three) sets the ball rolling, we can usually identify one predominant form that will be reflected in the mirror we now offer to others.

Mirrors that Respond

Mirroring is not an exact science. At its core, it’s an energetic process – the thoughts and words are simply extensions of an intuitive sense that is created between one person and another. In its most primary form, babies are our best teachers. Go and play with an infant, without any agenda, and you will probably find yourself mirroring within a matter of minutes. You will discover that it’s not simply imitating the other – it’s about being open and responsive to your own experience while responding to the experience of another. Some people like to call this “resonance” and babies are usually very good at it. As we get older the process becomes increasingly cognitive and complex but the energetic and intuitive foundations remain constant. For an adult to offer an accurate mirror to a child, the following conditions are essential:

If your interested in learning about the neurological foundations of mirroring, you might want to take a look at Marco Iacoboni’s book “Mirroring People” published in 2008. If you want more information on breathing and learning how to enhance your mirroring potential, I unabashedly recommend my own book, Don’t Let Your Kids Be Normal published by Influence in 2010 and available on Amazon. Of course, you could also contact the author directly for more information.

A Final Reflection

Given the scope of this article, it wasn’t possible to delve into the conceptual foundations of the inside-out perspective. Briefly stated, the underlying theoretical assumption is that there is a natural developmental process that can be disrupted or distorted by significant others during early childhood and eased back on track though subsequent relationships. The focus is upon the emergence of the Self as it seeks increasing levels of connectedness and autonomy through relationships with Others. Outcomes are not identified and measured in terms of behaviour, but according to each person’s sense of making his or her own choices, from the inside-out. In psychology, this is often referred to as “intrinsic motivation” or “internal locus of control”. I’m ending on this note because I’m tired of people telling me that this stuff is ‘hairy-fairy’ and non-scientific. My hope is that Child and Youth Care can begin to develop its own empirical foundations and research designs without sacrificing its unique character and traditions.

The author would like to thank ERNIE HILTON for his insightful comments on the first draft of this article. Such interactive collaboration lies at the heart of professional Child and Youth Care practice.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App