CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 285 NOVEMBER 2022

We Had It … And Then We Lost It

Kiaras Gharabaghi

At some point in the development of child and youth care practice, the field was fundamentally about care, which is why we called the field child and youth care practice. The early writers in the field, by which I mean writers in the 1970s, 1980s and to some extent, the 1990s, focused on how to operationalize the practice of care, usually in the context of young people whose lives were such that the feeling of being cared for and about was scarce, or at least contested. The practice of care, it turned out, was quite complicated, and people like Fewster, VanderVen, Fox, Garfat, Krueger, Phelan and many others provided enormously useful ideas and tips on how to make care a real thing. Their focus very often was care in the context of residential care, because in those days, at least across much of North America, residential settings were where young people ended up whose experiences of being cared for and about were somehow inadequate. In many respects, the focus on how to operationalize care was what made child and youth care so special. It set the field apart from other, related fields, that had much more instrumental and (I use the word with some hesitancy) professional ambitions, including fields like social work, nursing, psychology, and others. Child and youth care responded to a fundamental need of young people that most of these other professions either were unwilling or simply were ill-equipped to respond to. Most of our field’s most enduring concepts, such as relationships, engagement, play, and safety are derived from these early discussions of the operationalization of care.

In the 1990s, a shift started to occur, very slowly, but such that by the early 2000s, child and youth care in North America had largely abandoned its focus on care and replaced it with several new priorities. These included a greater focus on clinical practices (through the fascination first with attachment, then with resilience, and eventually with trauma); a focus on systemic issues in child and youth serving systems; a focus on the professionalization of child and youth care practice; and a focus on a form of child and youth care education that is rooted anywhere but in child and youth care. It is not difficult to understand why these changes occurred, and in many respects, they were even necessary. But we are left with something quite different from what we had at some point, imperfect as that might have been.

For me, one of the moments that made me realize a change is coming for the field of child and youth care occurred in 1996. That year, I was operating a summer child and family camp on behalf of a child and youth mental health centre, specifically for young people living in residential care and treatment programs. We had about 30 young people divided into five or six groups, each with one or two child and youth care practitioners facilitating their camp experience. From time to time, the kids’ families came up for a few days, but most of the time, it was these smaller groups of kids experiencing summer camp under the auspices of a child and youth care practitioner.  Most of the camp was quite a disaster, with kids not having a particularly good time, lots of behavioural challenges, and child and youth care practitioners enforcing rules and consequences and begging for more staff support. About three weeks into the camp (we were there for six weeks), the Director of the agency came up to take over one of the smaller groups for five days. He had agreed to do so early into the planning for the camp, and sure enough, he arrived, set up his tent, and took over the experience for one of the groups of kids. For that week, while all the other groups were struggling to get by, with quite a lot of conflict and misery, the group taken over by the Director was having the time of their lives – literally no issues of any kind, smiles all day long, and tonnes of laughter and joy. The Director was a guy who had learned about child and youth care during the 1970s and 1980s; he was steeped in the language and practice of care. I observed him operationalize care for the entire week, using strategies of play, rituals, fantasy, spontaneity, humour, deep conversation over hot chocolate, and lots of physical activity and closeness. He imposed rules and structure, but he did so with the kids and for the purpose of facilitating not only his care for and about the kids, but also care between the kids. While he was doing these things, all the other (and generally younger) child and youth workers were in various stages of the new approach to the practice; they were labelling kids’ problems, setting boundaries, enforcing rules in the name of safety (rather than care) and imposing consequences in the name of accountability (again, rather than care). It’s not that they didn’t want to care for and about the kids; they just didn’t know how to operationalize care, because what they were learning about child and youth care practice wasn’t steeped in the art and practice of care. What they knew about was therapeutic change, except that a makeshift summer camp setting revealed just how much therapeutic change activity is actually rooted in the coercive context of physical settings such as group homes, schools, and other institutions. Without the walls, the policies and procedures, and the routines of set programs, these child and youth care practitioners were a little lost.

For the past twenty years, we have been distancing ourselves from care as the core of child and youth care practice, following instead in the footsteps of other fields of practice, including those we are often very critical of. We did this because we never really addressed the inadequacies of what we had and instead proceeded to change our field entirely. Ironically, we still haven’t really addressed the inadequacies of what we had. I think it is important that we at least know what those inadequacies were (and are), so that we can have a more meaningful discussion on how to address them. Throwing out the operationalization of care was probably not the right way to address anything other than to lose our way in the increasingly harsh and judgmental context of child and youth service provision.

To begin, let me say at the outset that I have valued the thinking and contributions of those who shaped this field during the 1970s and 1980s a lot. I think their work was valuable then but holds that value today, albeit it with some modification. There were three core inadequacies of the care-focused work on the 1970s and 1980s, that may have been less apparent then than now (but that’s no excuse for these inadequacies). The first of these is that virtually all that work was generated through white lived experiences, white world views, and white value and meaning constructions, and just about everyone who was then associated with writing about child and youth care was in fact white. In Canada, this impacted especially Indigenous young people (the Sixties Scoop was still very much going on during the 1970s and into the early 1980s), whose identities, cultures, languages, and ways of being in the world were largely ignored. In the US, it impacted both Native American young people and Black young people, both groups that by then were already hugely overrepresented in coercive settings across the child and youth services systems. More than that, however, the whiteness of the whole enterprise gave rise to a complacency that can’t be talked away. Child and youth care was then, and is today (in North America) racist, at least in the sense that it is constructed in ways that negate, silence, or otherwise undermine the value, power, and rights of non-white peoples.

The second inadequacy of the earlier work in our field is that the operationalization of care was articulated in a strictly ableist context. Virtually everything that was written then presented the young people we work with as able-bodied, neuro-normative, and developmentally at least average. The prototype of young person who featured in most case studies, stories, and examples was a young person with some emotional difficulties and accompanying externalized behaviours. Eventually we expanded the articulation of that prototype to include some features of family dynamics, but fundamentally, child and youth care was developed, explained, and practiced in the context of interpersonal exchanges between the worker and the young person. To be sure, there was some reference to group work as well, but the group was understood as an undifferentiated entity, such that even group work was explained as an interpersonal exchange between the worker and the group as undifferentiated entity. At the root of all of it was an assumption that child and youth care practice unfolds in the presence of young people who could be relatively normal and reflective of young people generally, if only they were given an opportunity to work through their emotional distress in non-threatening and supportive ways. The relationship, which came to dominate all child and youth care narratives, was firmly framed as reflective of a world where everyone could be situated similarly.

The third inadequacy of these earlier approaches was the reliance on the residential setting as the basis for child and youth care practice. Understandably, much of the early writing considered care practices in the context of residential settings because that is where such practices were desperately needed and because child and youth serving systems relied very heavily on residential settings as the response to identified troubles in the lives of young people. Perhaps symptomatic of a judgment culture against parents and caregivers facing other forms of discrimination, exclusion, and oppression based on race, ability/disability, socio-economic status, education, stable housing, and more, much of our field evolved at a time when the core of our response to the adversities faced by young people was based on separating young people from their families. At least since the mid-1990s and certainly into the 2000s, the demand for care practices has gone far beyond the residential setting. In fact, at least in North America, the demand for care practices has become much more acute in other institutions, notably schools, hospitals, and recreation facilities, as well as in communities (on the playground, in malls, at busy intersections, in drop in shelters). Perhaps most fundamentally, the demand for care practices has appeared in family-based settings such as foster families, kinship families, and extended family networks sharing the upbringing of young people.

Our response to these inadequacies of the earlier writing in the field of child and youth care has taken us away from the need for our field. Our response has rendered thinking about the operationalization of care practices secondary to a wide range of things, phenomena and processes that are all valid and important but that provide virtually no clue at all with respect to how one provides care in the face of the highly differentiated and generally very complex circumstances facing young people in the 21st century. I understand and support the appearance of much more systemically focused writing and analysis in our field. The issues of racism and ableism alone warrant this level of analysis. I also understand and support the importance of engaging with issues of trauma, brain science, clinical practices, and related initiatives, all of which are very relevant to the circumstances faced by young people. And of course, I understand the desire of child and youth care practitioners to engage issues of professionalization, although I worry that we are working far too hard to professionalize the aspects of child and youth care practice that have already been professionalized across other fields of practice rather than focusing on raising the status of care practices across professional landscapes in child and youth services generally.

In the end, however, I can’t help but think that young people who encounter child and youth care practitioners are no longer encountering opportunities for experiencing care. They are instead encountering professionals who want to change things, advance the performance of young people in the normative structures where they encounter them, and who use the challenges faced by those young people as fodder for the legitimation of their social justice agenda. This is not the only way of advancing child and youth care practice. I believe that we can maintain our focus on operationalizing care across the full spectrum of settings and social contexts such that we account for the inadequacies of earlier approaches. We can expand notions of care to include (and perhaps even be driven by) Afrocentric care, Indigenous care, and Trans care. We can develop care practices that account for the diversity of ability/disability, that transcend neuro normative assumptions, and that resist the imposition of ableist structures and norms in the lives of young people with disabilities. And we can focus on care practices that go beyond the residential setting (but that include those settings too, because residential settings are now the least caring settings in child and youth service systems) and equip child and youth care practitioners to operationalize care across institutional and community settings.

When we came together decades ago to respond to the fundamental need for (and right to) care in settings that did not provide for care, we had a good idea and did spectacular work that had enormous impact on many young people. When we abandoned care practice as the core of our field and focused instead on theories that features rather uncomfortable and often not very rigorous attempts to find convergence across psychology, neurosciences, critical race theory, feminism, sociology and more, we advanced our understanding of why and how things are as they are, but we left many young people, including Indigenous and Black Youth, trans youth, youth with disabilities, and others, without care.

Globally, the developments in our field have been quite different. It is not the case that care practice has been abandoned everywhere. In South African approaches to child and youth care, care continues to form the core of the field, is responsive to issues of racial inequities, mitigates ableism in imperfect but hopeful ways, and has transcended residential care settings so successfully that the field itself is associated much more with community settings than with institutional settings. I have observed these kinds of dynamics across many jurisdictions around the world, but in North America, we had something very special, and then we lost it. I wonder if we can find it again. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App