Despite strong evidence in its favour, emerging adulthood has never truly been established in public consciousness in the same way other stages, such as infancy and childhood, have. Instead, there has been a tug-of-war between ideological stances on the subject. Some researchers have begun to question why opportunities to assist emerging adults, and especially for those who are aging out of care, are not more numerous. In this author’s opinion, emerging adulthood should be fully recognized as a stage of development and considered in further policy changes for youth aging out of care. Agencies serving those emerging from care can play a key role in in promoting interdependence and a sense of community belonging. This can be made possible by providing family like environments for emerging adults where they can try, fail, succeed, reflect, reference, and regroup all while allowing for positive thinking about the future.
Keywords
emerging adulthood, aging out of care, interdependence, child and youth care, youth development
A recent article I read in Popular Mechanics featured a young man in his early twenties who is paralyzed who competes nationally in events that include tasks such as walking, stepping over stones, and climbing stairs (Brant, 2020). He does this all with the use of a prototype biomechanical suit attached to him called an exoskeleton (Brant, 2020). From a youth development standpoint, this story fascinated me for two reasons. First, I could not help but see this impressive metal exoskeleton as a physical metaphor for what Vygotsky calls scaffolding, the structured nature of cognitive supports, social supports, and gradual instruction that adults can provide to younger people as they develop (as cited in Kranzler et al., 2019; Steinberg 2020). The second was the story’s insistence that the reason the young man, Mark Daniel, both survived the trauma of his accident and became the perfect candidate for the experimental exoskeleton program was because he was in peak physical condition, somewhat naïve, hopeful about the future, self-focused, and a little fearless. In other words: he was the perfect candidate because he was an emerging adult (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007; Berzin, Singer, & Hokanson, 2014).
Psychologist Jeffrey Arnett first proposed the term emerging adulthood in 2000 and has been developing theory to support it ever since (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007; Berzin, Singer, & Hokanson, 2014; Steinberg, 2020). Arnett argues that, especially in industrialized societies, emerging adulthood is a distinct developmental stage between adolescence and adulthood, roughly the ages 18-25 (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007; Berzin, Singer, & Hokanson, 2014; Steinberg, 2020). It can be defined by key features including identity exploration, risk-taking, instability, self-focus, feelings of being in-between, and a strong sense of possibility and optimism (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007).
When we consider Mark’s story as a case study and within the context of emerging adulthood, it is a good example of the concept at work in everyday life. Mark is lucky. After surviving a car accident at age 18 he went through a brief period of self-pity (Brant, 2020). However, he says his parents consistently inspired him to stay hopeful and to keep working. Mark has now become a key component of a research and development project that is hopeful for the future and needed someone just like him (Brant, 2020).
As an emerging adult, Mark is fiercely forward-thinking, and self-focused. For example, wearing the experimental exoskeleton requires a high level of conditioning and requires the pilot to be focused on maintaining physique. When we consider the intersections of the social and biological domains of development, emerging adulthood comes at a time of peak image control and increased physical fitness (Steinberg, 2020). Mark, who is now in his early twenties, was already used to doing the kind of self-focused physical conditioning required for the work of controlling the exoskeleton. As a risk taker, he also never hesitated to undergo the surgery to implant the necessary biomechanical devices (that allow him to command the exoskeleton) under his skin.
Mark is employed and supported by a team who are older and who, as scientists, have ample experience in setbacks and resilience. They act as a support system for him not just in his work, but life in general. In a way, the community of researchers on the exoskeleton team also act as his scaffolding (Kranzler et al., 2019; Steinberg, 2020). However, even though Mark is intensely self-focused he sees his work as not just important for him, but for the future of the entire disabled community (Brant, 2020). This kind of developing conscientiousness can be seen as sign that he is indeed emerging as an adult.
I have found the theory of emerging adulthood fascinating, essentially ever since I stopped being one. Mark comes from a supportive family and has found belonging in a new group that, without even knowing it, is helping him develop into an adult. His emerging adulthood mirrors my own in some ways, and I am grateful I had similar kinds of community based, manageable opportunities and support. It shaped who I am today. Now, as a child and youth care practitioner, I have begun to question why more opportunities to assist emerging adults, (like the one in this example) do not exist, and especially for those who are aging out of care.
It was just a coincidence that I was reading this story at the same time as I was researching emerging adulthood. While gaining in popularity and reputation, the concept is still somewhat neglected (Côté, 2014; Hendry & Kloep, 2010). It was a combination of this and a consideration of emerging adulthood in child and youth care (specifically for young people aging out of care) that made me hypothesize that emerging adulthood should be fully recognized as a stage of development and that this should be considered in further policy changes for youth aging out of care.
Emerging adulthood was a term Arnett proposed in 2000 and it became so popular so quickly that even Arnett himself questioned why this was (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007). Arnett hypothesizes that part of the reason is, at the time, developmental science was already in need of a way to clearly define a stage which almost everyone had already been observing in industrialized societies. The term emerging adulthood contrasted with both what Erikson called young adulthood (late teens to 40 years old), and biosocial theories which state that teens in industrialized nations are aging faster (Arnett, 2007).
Arnett’s theory began with asking the question: what defines adulthood? Arnett states that adulthood can be characterized by evidence of accepting responsibility for oneself, making financial decisions, and financial independence. Previously, society used a much more direct determinant if a person was an adult: if they owned property or not (Arnett, 2007). Socially, from a western colonial and industrialized perspective, this just does not fit anymore. For these reasons, Arnett began developing the theory of emerging adulthood (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007). Some question Arnett’s reluctance to define emerging adulthood as simply a transition between, and overlapping with, adolescence and adulthood (Côté, 2014; Hendry & Kloep, 2010). However, Arnett asserts that emerging adulthood should be recognized as a distinct stage because it lasts at least as long as some developmental stages, and even longer than others such as infancy (Arnett, 2007).
Arnett also makes a point that depressive symptoms appear to decline after adolescence and into emerging adulthood (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007). Part of the reason could be the newfound optimism and hopefulness that comes with possibilities and growing opportunities for experiences that can present during this stage. I do not believe this point can be understated. There are myths that emerging adults are suffering and slackers. However, Arnett believes emerging adulthood can be good for society because of the increased hopefulness that comes with it. For example, to the earlier point that depressive symptoms in adolescence appear to decline in emerging adulthood, this can be a time of increased optimism. Many emerging adults not only want to have a job, but an occupation that is a reflection of their developing skills and their personal sense of themselves. This can create a drive to focus and better oneself, which in turn can benefit society (Arnett, 2006; Arnett 2007).
Despite its popularity in mainstream media, emerging adulthood is still treated as either a new undeveloped concept or simply as a general way to describe a transitional stage between adolescence and adulthood. In my own experience as a child and youth care practitioner it is interesting to note that up until very recently, even within my professional network of teachers, social workers, community workers, nurses, and counsellors, emerging adulthood is still treated in this way. In child and youth care, we know that practice can often take time to catch up to theory. I noticed that it was only after I began integrating the term emerging adulthood in the field that my colleagues have begun using it too. It is also only very recently that have I seen consideration of emerging adulthood appear in policies and decisions concerning aging out of care.
Côté takes umbrage with Arnett’s theory on two fronts. The first is as a critique of emerging adulthood as good theory, especially Arnett’s assertion that the stage affects young people across the social classes (Côté, 2014). The second is in the potentially damaging applications of the theory in society. Côté asserts that for Arnett’s theory (he instead refers to it as more of a hypothesis) to be accepted as universal, it will need rigorous empirical testing. He feels that Arnett is really only observing that youth are taking longer to transition to the responsibilities of adulthood. For example, when Côté pointed out that a certain young mother Arnett had interviewed would not have the luxury of experiencing an emerging adulthood, Arnett noted that despite the challenges of raising a young child, the mother still looked forward to becoming a teacher and had optimism about future possibilities (Côté, 2014). These types of indicators are especially important to remember when we consider emerging adulthood in the context of our work as child and youth care practitioners, and with vulnerable young people both in and emerging from care, and across economic class.
Côté acknowledges that young adults can often experience a period of what Erikson and Marcia label identity moratorium (as cited in Côté, 2014) but points out that neither researcher ever asserted that all young adults face this crisis. Côté warns that employers and economic policy makers may also misconstrue the growing prominence and narrative of emerging adulthood to avoid taking risks hiring young workers, deny them opportunities, and devalue their contributions (Côté, 2014). He is also concerned that the establishment of emerging adulthood as a normative stage of development, and not just a general term, will further erode the motivation of young people and lead them to delay, or even deny, adulthood. However, research has shown that the ambivalence emerging adults feel towards the responsibilities of adulthood are normative and not a sign of laziness or selfishness, citing that that almost all emerging adults show evidence of taking on full adult responsibilities by age 30 (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007). I often see this in my own relational child and youth care work.
Côté does state that he is willing to accept Arnett’s term, emerging adulthood, as a loose concept and a way of defining the somewhat discontinuous transition into adulthood (Côté, 2014). However, he is concerned that firmly establishing emerging adulthood as a stage of development in the same way we do other stages such as infancy, childhood, and adulthood might cause young people, and especially vulnerable young people, to expect to experience self-blame for failures, and to prolong, or put off chances to develop into adults. Côté also argues that an over-emphasis on emerging adulthood as a distinct developmental stage could delay the formation of vocational identity (Côté, 2014). Yet, emerging adults have shown to spend a considerable amount of time focused on vocational identity, often tying it to their personal identity (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007). I do, however, agree with both Côté and Arnett that before recognizing emerging adulthood as truly universal we will need further study of cultures around the globe to see if a stage comparable to emerging adulthood exists (Arnett 2007; Côté, 2014; Steinberg, 2020).
Hendry & Kloep also provide a critical antithesis to Arnett (2010). One of the key points of their argument against the universal adoption of emerging adulthood as a formal stage of development is that they caution strongly against creating another stratification stage with limits and boundaries (Hendry & Kloep, 2010). According to Hendry and Kloep, young people do not need another label placed upon them by the establishment. They make a case for taking much more of a lifespan view and seeing the period of between adolescence and adulthood recognized as more fluid and with careful consideration applied to supporting individual development. This was an interesting perspective for me to consider and makes me question my biases. In my own training and experience this is usually the child and youth care (CYC) approach. Normally, I would agree that young people do not need yet another label and further stratification forced upon them. However, I have simply found the case for emerging adulthood as a distinct developmental stage too strong to ignore (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007; Berzin et al., 2014; Gomez et al., 2015; Hokanson et al., 2019). More formal recognition of emerging adulthood could lead to practical application of techniques, techniques that could shape a brighter future for young people aging out of care.
Critics also argue that emerging adulthood does not stand up as good theory (Côté, 2014; Hendry & Kloep, 2010). However, Arnett argues that criticisms such as these are themselves indicators that it is standing up as good theory and invites further dialogue (Arnett, 2007). Another critique is that contemporary popular media has fueled a culture of emerging adulthood (Côté, 2014).
Anthropologists such as Margaret Mead have shown that traditional societies nurture child and youth development in a way that can be defined as continuous (as cited in Steinberg, 2020). Conversely, Arnett makes a convincing argument that, according to his research, our contemporary western and industrialized societies have in many ways helped to make development into adulthood particularly discontinuous (Arnett, 2007; Steinberg, 2020). For example, in industrialized societies, popular culture and the collective consciousness appear to continue to focus on the clear and brief transition into adulthood that many baby boomers faced during the 1950s and expect that it is normative (Steinberg, 2020). However, it is important to keep in mind that a form of emerging adulthood existed long before the common reference point of the 1950s (Steinberg, 2020).
In another article, the authors collected the stories of emerging adults who were aging out of care and their perceptions of learned helplessness (Gomez et al. 2015). They use a mixed-methods approach, and the centrepiece of the research is the interviews with emerging adults themselves who have aged out of care. This kind of participatory action research also advocates for the cause to these youth. The interviews reveal a theme: not only do many youths aging out of care not feel prepared for adulthood, they often do not feel their experience has even prepared them for a positive emerging adulthood (Gomez et al. 2015). Despite this, most of the interviews reveal that these young people are still optimistic, they often just feel in-between something they cannot quite articulate. Rather than focusing on making specific recommendations for systemic changes (though it does make some good suggestions) the research shines a light on the voices of emerging adults who have aged out of care. The authors argue for increased support in helping them to achieve autonomy, to practice perseverance, and to integrate into their communities (Gomez et al. 2015). I believe it is integration that might be the key.
Gomez et al. find that the foster care experience for adolescents often falls short of providing the kinds of opportunities to be prepared for emerging adulthood (Gomez et al., 2015). These missed opportunities can include activities that provide scaffolding such as college campus visits. I have seen this in my own experience. Often, I have seen workers simply provide emerging adults with addresses, phone numbers, brochures, and websites and think this is enough assistance. I don’t believe this goes far enough in facilitating the future independence of emerging adults. Especially for those who have aged out of care, this can be akin to helping push them off a cliff. We should be walking alongside and facilitating emerging adults in gaining self-efficacy, not expecting it to just appear once they have aged out (Gomez et al., 2015).
As a child and youth care practitioner, I cannot avoid (nor would I want to avoid) attempting to argue a concept from an unashamed CYC point of view. Perhaps we can conceptualize, apply, put into practice, and evaluate supports and policies that include the voices of youth, especially vulnerable youth (Gomez et al., 2015). Emerging adulthood should be fully recognized as a normative stage of development, and with particular consideration to those youth aging out of care. Many emerging adults in contemporary culture are afforded the space to learn and practice the responsibility and accountability that will define their future adulthood. Emerging adults can often experience this through trial, error, and scaffolding (Kranzler et al, 2019). Through supports and resources they can begin to understand the importance of nuanced civic engagement and accountability to the community. They can also be afforded the chance to experience identity moratorium, self-focus, feeling in-between, and optimism: all through the process of trial and error and the scaffolding provided by their parent(s) or other older family members, from a secure home base (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007; Berzin et al., 2014; Gomez et al., 2015; Kranzler et al., 2019).
A good example is living through a failure with the support of adults, who can help give these failures scale and place them in the greater context. This experience is a given for most emerging adults. Emerging adults who are aging out of foster care and group homes should have the same, if not more of the same, latitude to experience the safe base of an adult-led, home-like setting they can return to when needed. They can use this setting to contemplate, regroup, and have opportunities to experience informed, caring conversations, and helpful information and attention from adults that are invested in not just their development into adults, but who also recognize them as beautiful humans (Brokenleg, 2012).
Hokanson et al. (2019) explain that emerging adults aging out of care strive to gain independence, but they often do not feel independent enough (Hokanson et al. 2019). This can often be a result of repeatedly being let down by family and/or others in their lives (Berzin et al., 2014; Hokanson et al. 2019). As a result, many of these youth yearn to be emancipated from care and never look back (Berzin et al., 2014; Gomez et al., 2015; Hokanson et al. 2019). Often these instances lead to some form of young adult agreement including independent living (Berzin et al., 2014; Gomez et al., 2015; Hokanson et al. 2019). This can create a sense of independence but also one of isolation (Berzin et al., 2014; Hokanson et al. 2019). Perhaps independence is not the goal we should be looking for. Instead, we should be working to create interdependence (Hokanson et al., 2019).
We should be open to learning from Indigenous perspectives like the circle of courage model (Brokenleg, 2012). For example, the circle of courage does include an emphasis on independence, but independence is only one of the four components, or quadrants, of the model along with equal measures of belonging, generosity, and mastery (Brokenleg, 2012). It takes the courage of a whole community as well as the developing individual to create interdependence. It is important to demonstrate this community connectedness, especially for adolescents and emerging adults who, often because of past experiences, understandably feel that their independence includes not having to trust anyone (Berzin et al., 2014; Hokanson et al. 2019). In a healthy community, by contrast, dependence and independence converge at points of interdependence; this is vital for young people to learn as they become adults (Berzin et al., 2014; Brokenleg, 2012; Hokanson et al. 2019).
There has been some positive progress in this direction as of late. We are beginning to see some additional supports for emerging adults aging out of care such as college tuition waivers and circles of supportive adults and elders (Gomez et al. 2015). These are good steps. Instead of creating learned helplessness, the system should help prepare emerging adults by recognizing, acknowledging, and normalizing the developmental stage of emerging adulthood, and continue to assist youth aging out of care to navigate through it (Arnett, 2006; Arnett, 2007; Gomez et al. 2015). Some developing strategies to support emerging adults include developing initiatives that help them become accountable to community.
Examples include programs that allow emerging adults to directly see the outcomes of their actions, such as regularly helping others (Gomez et al. 2015). These kinds of interventions can occur while recognizing that, at the same time, most young people will remain self- focused for much of their emerging adulthood (Gomez et al. 2015).
Through this writing process my thoughts keep coming back to generating a child and youth care response to this issue. As is often the case, the truth lies somewhere in the middle between the arguments; it is my hope that I have begun to synthesize them into a new direction. Such reforms could also help youth development in industrialized societies, such as ours, to become more continuous, and not such a jarring experience for emerging adults who have aged out of care. Instead of thrusting independence on them before they are developmentally ready, we can create more interdependence. We could be relying on and learning from emerging adults at the same time they are relying on and learning from us.
References
Arnett, J.J., (2006). Suffering, selfish, slackers: Myths and reality about emerging adults. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 36(1), 23-29. https://doi.org/ 10.1007/s10964-006-9157-z
Arnett, J.J. (2007). Emerging adulthood: What is it, and what is it good for? Child Development Perspectives, 1(2), 68-73. https://doi.org/ 10.1111/j.1750-8606.2007.00016.x
Berzin, S., Singer, E., Hokanson, K. (2014). Emerging versus emancipating: The transition to adulthood for youth in foster care. Journal of Adolescent Research, 29(5), 616-638. https://doi.org/ 10.1177/0743558414528977
Brant, J. (2020). At the bionic Olympics, athletes and engineers make miracles: The futuristic tech and human ingenuity that’s redefining what it means to be paralyzed. Popular Mechanics, 2, 30-36, 82-84.
Brokenleg, M., (2012). Humanized youth work. Retrieved from ERIC database. (EJ977659)
Côté, J.E. (2014). The dangerous myth of emerging adulthood: an evidence-based critique of a flawed developmental theory. Applied Developmental Science, 18(4), 177-188. https://doi.org/ 10.1080/10888691.2014.954451
Gomez, R., Ryan, T., Norton, C., Jones, C., Galan-Cisneros, P. (2015). Perceptions of learned helplessness among emerging adults aging out of foster care. Journal of Child and Adolescent Social Work, 32(1), 507-516. https://doi.org/ 10.1007/s10560-015-0389-1
Hendry, L., & Kloep, M. (2010). How universal is emerging adulthood? An empirical example. Journal of Youth Studies, 13(2), 169-179. https://doi.org/2010.1080/13676260903295067
Hokanson, K., Golden, K.E., Berzin, S., Singer, E., Berzin, S., Cosner, S. (2019). Not independent enough: Exploring the tension between independence and interdependence among former youth in foster care who are emerging adults. Child Welfare, 97(5), 141-157. https://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=10&sid=9f50bbf5-24fd-406e- 8901-94de0e8376f1%40sdc-v-sessmgr01
Kranzler, Amy; Pimentel, Sandra S.; Zayde, Amanda. Scaffolding and support beams: Clinical and administrative tools for emerging adult programs (2019). Evidence-Based Practice in Child & Adolescent Mental Health, 4(2), 122-140. https://doi.org/10.1080/23794925.2018.1551092
Steinberg, L. (2020). Adolescence (12th ed.) New York, NY: McGraw Hill.
From: Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, Vol. 34, No.4, pp47-57