Child and Youth Care practice, when it is done well, involves connecting in increasingly personal ways with another person to build influence so that new perspectives and beliefs can be considered and hopefully accepted by the person being helped. The skilled CYC practitioner carefully considers every interaction with the other person to increase the power of the connection and minimize experiences and interactions that will diminish the strength of the connection between them.
It takes several years of experience to become skillful in connecting with people who are naturally fearful of closeness and vulnerable interactions. I would like to describe the increasingly complex dynamics that CYC practitioners are able to manage as they become more sophisticated and skilled in relationship building.
During the first year it is too chaotic and unsafe for most practitioners to be deliberately connected with young people in their care. Personal boundaries need to be fairly thick, interactions more factual and focussed on managing behavior, while safety and program demands require new workers’ full attention. Most attempts to be friendly and personal with youths in the program are viewed by the youth as obvious ways to develop compliance with behavioral expectations, not genuine interest in them. The anxiety embedded in new staff members who struggle with competence and fear of confrontations blocks them from creating useful connections for the initial period of life space practice.
Therefore, the first stage of building skill in connecting is to be non-relational for an extended period, typically lasting nine months to a year. Only after becoming confident and competent in managing a safe environment can safe connections be created with young people. At this second stage the CYC practitioner works toward building his/her attractiveness to the young person through becoming interested in the music, athletics, hobbies or other interests of the youth and gradually increasing the youth’s desire to be interacting with him/her. As the youth becomes more attracted to the presence of the worker, there is an increase in “other-awareness’ in the young person, he/she is beginning to think about how the other person is affected by how they behave. This is an Important step in building connection, which is a strategy familiar to many CYC staff, and the use of “I” messages by the staff, to indicate how the youth impacts others, especially the newly attractive worker. The goal is to build awareness in the young person of considering other people’s needs, becoming less ego-centric, thus more socially competent.
The focus for the worker during this process is on himself, becoming more attractive as a role model and comfortable support for the youth. Many staff reach this stage of connection ability after sufficient experience and remain here. The usual struggle for CYC staff who remain focussed here is that it is painful to break the connection when youth leave the program or they move, because the power of the relationship is lost because it demands the constant presence of the CYC worker.
The next level of connecting is also built on the ongoing presence of the CYC practitioner, as the worker expands the young person’s awareness of others and the social dynamics of relationships. Through gradually building experiential moments of learning, the worker skillfully increases the youth’s judgement of social impacts. The youth starts to think about how the worker would evaluate the impending decision to do or not do something, e.g. “what would he/she think about what I am about to do” and allows himself to be influenced by this judgement of the worker. The next step is to expand this evaluation of potential behavior to consider how several others (teacher, friends, etc.) would be impacted.
This is a more personal and vulnerable connection between the worker and the young person which develops as boundaries become closer but is still based on the presence and attractiveness of the worker. There is an important limitation on this type of relational influence because it is grounded in whether the worker would be a useful point of reference for the youth. Most of the young people we support live very different lives in communities and social groups that are not reflected in our typical program situations. Even though a worker might be a role model for a youth inside the environment of the program, most youth do not believe that the worker’s strategies would succeed in the “real world” of their lived experience. So the value of the connection is limited to the time spent inside the program.
After several years of practice skillful practitioners realize the limited impact of creating connections based on their own presence and life logic. The next stage of connection building involves a new focus and goal, so that more permanent change will occur. Gradually the mature CYC practitioner shifts the focus off him/herself and begins to support strengthening the attractiveness of the young person’s self image. Simply put, the goal is no longer to become personally attractive to the youth but to get the youth to like himself. This shift in focus is difficult for most practitioners because they have been invested in building their own presence and attractiveness for most of their career, evaluating their success by how much the young people like them.
When the connection between the practitioner and the young person is focussed on supporting the youth to value their own strengths, which are typically quite different than the strengths listed in program treatment plans, the practitioner is minimizing their own opinions and life logic. The young person begins to see their own intrinsic worth and value, which allows nurturing to be accepted without suspicion or fear. As personal competence increases, based on realistic strengths and tempered by socialized logic, the youth becomes less reliant on the presence of the helper. This type of connection leads more naturally to separation and independence without regression to old problematic patterns.
To summarize, the steps of connection building begin with no relationship focus, through personal attraction efforts, to generalizing social messages and lead to a minimal focus on the worker and a concentrated focus on the “real” other person.