CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 273 NOVEMBER 2021

Commodifying Joy

Hans Skott-Myhre

When I used to train CYC workers, I would often use an Taoist precept to talk about how to understand the flux and flow of relational work. The saying, which is attributed to the Taoist sage Lao Tzu, states that one should, “Be still like a mountain and flow like a river.” I found that it was a very useful way to talk about how there are times in working with young people and their families, when one should be quiet and not speak. At such moments, we might well refuse to even acknowledge our inner dialogue and seek to be absolutely still. To engage this way of being in our work, allows us to enter an altered state of temporality. It is a way of slowing our internal process down, so that we can pay attention to all that is happening around us. It can also situate our presence as a calm and stable center, when there is chaos or rapidly escalating tension or outright conflict.

In a way, it is counterintuitive to the traditional colonial settler mindset of action and more action to address relational impasses or conflict. As a result, it can be hard to teach, because it isn’t really a skill, so much as a state of being that requires relinquishing our conscious modes of thought and external control. It calls for us to give over to our unconscious.

But, not the western psychological unconscious with its repressed memories and dark secrets. Instead, this is the unconscious as a rich, open field of infinite possibility, unhindered by the preset templates of what is possible that are produced ad infinitum by our conscious sense of who we are and what we can do. This alternative unconscious is sheer virtual possibility and because it is the realm of all that could be, but isn’t yet, it is both full and empty at the same time. There is a calm quietness, a stillness-like a mountain.

Of course, the other aspect of this approach to the work is to flow like a river. This one is a bit tricky. A river flows with an unstoppable force. Yes, you can dam it, but is always escaping downstream, just at a slower pace. So, to move like a river relationally is to recognize the force of yourself in motion. The tricky bit is how you define the “yourself” that is in motion here.

Our training in colonial settler ways of being would have us imagine ourselves as a bounded self, contained within this bag of skin we call “our” body. As a result, we can misunderstand the admonition to flow like a river and think that is about self-assertion. Such thinking can lead to the flooding of our relational fields with our ego driven surpluses of “good ideas” and behavioral prescriptions.

But the river referred to here is specifically not that limited. To flow like a river encompasses the river as an ecosystem composed of an almost infinite array of ever shifting sets of relations. In our training as children in the colonial school system, the maps we learned to read focused our attention on naming bounded and limited spaces such as continents, seas, countries, mountain ranges, lakes, and of course rivers. We were trained to see rivers as contained lines on the map that began in one place and ended at another. This is the kind of perverse logic that allowed and still allows colonial settlers to try and control the flows of rivers without any real understanding of the cascades of effects on the animals, plants, biospheres, and climatic flows that make up the actual river.

To flow like a river, in my reading of Lao Tzu, is to open oneself to the infinitely rich diversity of all of the flows in which we are entangled; chemical flows, electrical flows, linguistic flows, hormonal flows, affective flows, molecular flows, interspecies flows, intersectional flows - the list goes on. In opening oneself to all of these entangled flows of living force, we are like a great river that is made up of all the tributaries that flow into it; all the rain that falls into it, all the animals that drink from it, all the fish—you get the idea.

When we open ourselves to being fed by the tremendous diversity of life that composes every moment of every relational encounter, we are filled with immense capacity. Of course, we are only able to comprehend a small portion of that capacity consciously, and so it is important once again, to learn to immerse ourselves in a certain kind of collective unconscious. Not the Jungian one with all its attendant symbology, but the one we have referenced above. An unconscious that is always indeterminate and chaotic like the movements of a river across a varied geography, full of eddies, whirlpools, rapids and expanses of still water. If we can move like a river in this way, burn out becomes an impossibility, because we are fed from an inexhaustible fountain of living force.

Both of these admonitions from Lao Tzu run counter to our training as settler subjects and so there is a tendency to reframe them in less radical terms. In some ways, the challenges they pose to our traditional ways of thinking about who we are, can be so alien and unsettling (pun intended) that they shake us to our very core. The kind of cognitive, affective, existential, and ontological challenges they infer, often seem just too far away to be really taken seriously. And so, we dilute them. We create them as more palatable, by either reading them as safely abstract or turning them into instrumental applied skill sets or techniques. In doing either of these things, we reduce the level of living intensity possible in such practices and assure our encounter with such precepts will leave our current sense of self intact.

I was thinking about this the other day in terms of two other profoundly spiritual practices derived from non-European traditions. We often hear about the utility of yoga and mindfulness in assisting both CYC workers and young people. Interestingly, the applications of both are dissimilar, when applied to CYC working adults and children in care or in school. For the adults, both these practices are pitched as forms of self-care. They are proposed as ways to prevent burn out and to enhance our capacities for relaxation and self-reflection. For young people they are generally used as covert modes of disciplinary control. Often, they are taught in situations where the adults are concerned about levels of chaos or even overt violence.

In this regard, mindfulness has gained significantly in popularity as a way of calming and subduing rambunctious groups of young people.

Emaline Friedman, in her excellent analysis of mindfulness training in schools, makes the point that the ways that mindfulness training is deployed has possibly detrimental implications for the ways in which young people come to understand themselves as creative and agentic. She is also concerned, that the manner in which mindfulness is taught and practiced obscures the contextual problems of 21st century educational and social impacts on young people. In other words, mindfulness can hide the ways in which schools and capitalist society engender the very problems that give rise the symptoms mindfulness is designed to suppress. Friedman states, 

The suspicion cast here on mindfulness practices for school-age youth derives from two sources. The first is somewhat of a speculative concern; if mindfulness practice carries benefits, then what are the chances that its implementation in schools would be able to transmit these benefits? This opens onto the perpetuation of particular values through the delimiting of a skill set of self-management that we now observe to be expected earlier and earlier in life … The second concern attends to an assumption in the first. What are the purported benefits of mindfulness, and what, precisely, is being intervened upon when MBI’s are utilized? … This hinges directly on youth’s establishment of autonomous rather than pre-figured modes of responding to, and to some degree managing their experience of elements in the world. … I would like to suggest that in many deployments, mindfulness may be akin to resisting the many sources of environmental stimulation, and thus inimical to the self-development of creative tools for respecting and managing the many directions that attention entertains.

Friedman is making the point that mindfulness trains students in a certain kind of conforming passivity, in the face of a complex and sometimes hostile world. The way in which the practice of meditation is taken up here, also has the possibility of limiting the varied ways in which young people might learn to pay attention to the world when it is exceptionally stimulating (positively and negatively). It encourages retreat, rather than engagement. For those of us in CYC, this would seem to run quite contrary to the fundamentals of encounter and engagement that have been so central to our practice.

For the adults, we also have trainings in mindfulness that I would worry about in much the same way and so I won’t belabor that here. Instead, I would like to turn my attention to a particular appropriation of the yogic tradition. This ancient set of practices has been taken up as practice of ‘self-care.” In that regard, it is deployed as a set of exercises that enhance our overall physical health and also provides a relaxing respite from the madness of the world. However, in doing so, it also shapes our relational perspective into what could be seen as a kind of passivity. The very idea that one has to retreat from our engagement to the world in order to rather reluctantly reengage, frames our relations with the world as beyond our capacities. Like the mindfulness training above, this can frame our work as a problematic encounter that drains us. There is the suggestion that working with young people (or others) is damaging to our bodies and spirit and that we must seek refuge in order to return to the struggle. I would suggest that this is a powerfully perverse reading of the relational work that we do. Indeed, I would suggest that our work with others is inherently nurturing, if we know how to open ourselves to it, like the river I described above.

What is really frustrating to me about the two appropriations of Eastern spiritual practice, is the way in which they have been stripped of their actual living force. Each of these traditions was developed, not as a retreat from life, but a profound and powerful way of engaging life from the inside out. Both meditation and yoga were developed as ways of concentrating and channeling mental and physical energy in ways that could potentially undo the barriers that hold us in the prison of our “self” and open us onto the living force of the divine. In this encounter, we stand the possibility of having our “ego” eradicated and to come into states of enlightenment or satori in which there is no longer the limited individual we imagine ourselves to be, but a stilled body/mind like a mountain through which living force flows like a river. This is an extremely radical proposition that is trivialized and insulted in the appropriations of these traditions by neo-capitalist school systems and systems of care.

Many years ago, when yoga was just arriving in the United States, a friend of mine took a class in Kundalini Yoga. She took it very seriously as a spiritual discipline, but reported many of the students saw as a simple way to relax and increase the flexibility of their bodies. She also worried about the depth of understanding that the instructor had about the possible power of the practice. One day, I met her for coffee and she told me she had left the class and wasn’t going back. In fact, she said she was never going to practice yoga again. Curious, I asked what had gone wrong. She said that for many years she had been reading about how the energy of Kundalini lay coiled at the base of the spine and that through the practice of Kundalini yoga, this energy could be released in such a way that it would burst up the spine through all the chakras and blow your ego straight out of your mind. She found this a fascinating idea, but never really gave it full credence. Instead, her spiritual practice of yoga was to become more centered in her “self “so she could be more peaceful and yet powerful in her life. But the other night at yoga class, she actually felt the stirring of the Kundalini Yoga and the energy she felt was so powerful it was frightening. And as it began to stir, she looked at the instructor in the front of the room and asked herself that if the Kundalini energy worked the way it should, could he handle the spiritual emergency into which she would be thrown. What would he do, faced with a blissfully, egoless student unmoored in a world that requires a mooring. She decided that he would have no idea what to do and so she stopped her practice right then and there. For years she looked for a teacher that could handle the promised end point of meditation and yoga. Last I saw her, she was still searching.

The promise of these practices, that our society has trivialized and instrumentalized, is truly revolutionary in the most profound sense. Like so many beautiful and powerful entanglements, our proprietary impulse is to steal them and use them for our own very superficial and narcissistic investments. In doing this, however, we ultimately cheat ourselves of the sheer intensity of experiencing our lives as fully as possible. In a sense, we substitute the pablum of “happiness” over the true richness of joy. In doing so, we face a life of constant loss and suffering from which we must flee, instead of a life of immersion in the stream of living force that brings at a minimum, moments of ecstasy and joyful revolt. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App