As I begin to write I went online to see how many have passed from Covid-19. 4,839,110. Closing in on 5 million. Think about that. We have lived with the six million figure typically used in reference to the Holocaust since 1945. Enough time has passed that many have no idea it took place until formally taught. We have lived with this meter running since mid-March 2020, when it was declared officially here in North America and nationals were ordered to sort things and get home asap. For whatever reason we immediately sought comfort in toilet tissue and rolls flew off the shelves. It may be fair to say most people are aware of the pandemic but a few refuses to believe in its lethality, some 40 to 10%, those refusing to vaccinate. Only Israel sits at 100% because everyone there gets the vaccine, now 3 shots. Nations at war ignored the Holocaust as well. Fatigue sneaks up on one becoming a way of living without the awareness of it. It helps to be in lockdown, a legislated state of living which attempts to reduce social life to one’s residence ideally, force constant disinfecting, maintaining a six-foot distance from others and the wearing of a mask to both prevent and deflect spread. Yesterday and today, there was an event, the 23rd biannual conference of the NACCW, National Association of Child Care Workers of South Africa held virtually online. There were the usual glitches, delays and so forth yet the organizers prevailed, and it was possible to catch on YouTube a few familiar and beloved faces, voices and above all, wisdom. The depth of the fatigue was hinted at but more so the extent to which the simple act of caring has taken a severe hit with this pandemic. It may be the child and youth care corps that helps revive in the end. This column explores the struggle with caring.
That is rather extreme of me to pronounce the end of care. Certainly, in the first months of this when the morgues of New York were overrunning with the dead; calling for refrigerated semi-trailers to be brought in to handle the overflow. Mass graves came next and then nothing but data.
Joining the debt clock and population clock was the death clock displaying the global and American death statistics. It was tucked up on the right-hand side while the heads talked on about what has emerged as one of the most diabolical viruses ever, a shape shifter that changes on the fly adapting to its environment and always attacking from a position of strength. Its earliest version roared through long term care facilities carried by part time workers spreading it among a population of sorry but sitting ducks ramping up those death stats to the point of numbness. The only defense has been to take the sequence of two vaccinations outlined. Even then, you still can become positive, the real defense being not sick enough to be hospitalized. I’ve known several now who have caught it and suffered nary a symptom. Now a third shot is being considered, a booster perhaps the first of an unending annual jab, a cocktail of vaccines.
As we collectively retreated into pandemic lockdown, we did so in increments that essentially brought social and, in many cases, significant social life to an end. The schedule of events, activities, sport and cultural meetings were ended due to the limits on participants. Thanksgiving and Christmas gatherings were cancelled. The creation of vaccines and the establishment of inoculation centers became the focus of activity. One round of shots leads to another and finally a glimmer of a return to a kind of normality. In our zeal we overlooked those from the care professions who had been doing the heavy lifting throughout: doctors, nurses, first responders, teachers and police; some becoming victims of the virus itself, many more lapsing into burnout literally worked beyond any reasonable level of compassion or competency. I went there upon becoming a unit supervisor. Same people, same home, and same youth in care but with a shift in focus away from providing care to being expected to have immediate answers, do the shopping, attend meetings and be all things to all people. It was a bit much and I found the connection to them/it all literally fading to null and void. Resigning to the fact was the only answer. The caliber and professionalism of the carers being lost will not be made up overnight. Indeed, as we emerge from this pandemic the world of work is deeply fractured. Truck drivers and restaurant staff have huge shortfalls in staffing relative to the work required. Resolution to working at home or returning to the canyons of steel and glass at the core of every major city is looming.
Child and youth care is diminished incredibly. The NACCW virtual conference achieved its purpose to communicate but little was done to express the robust relational experience South Africans can generate generally and individually. Two seasons of conferencing have been cancelled taking down the potency of immediate relating between individuals from across the country and in some instances the globe. Much has worked against the establishment of the child and youth care field certainly in Manitoba. A recent scandal in that jurisdiction exposes many of them.
The child and youth care system is a provincial government responsibility. The Federal Government is also a consumer, something recently brought to the surface again over a lawsuit over short buying pay out less for services for indigenous youth than to the wider standard. A judge has ordered compensation to those youth and service providers impacted. This system is a curious beast as it is a closed entity, the province controlling all aspects: education, standards, service compensation, licensing, consumption and service operations. Every now and then something exposes it all as a total shame show. In February an agency in Brandon for youth with complex needs, a diverse staff compliment of youth care practitioners, educators, nurses, counselors and administrators, some 200 in all and youth in care was closed for financial irregularities. A social service is lost, hundreds unemployed, and youth moved again in a system for which the province has absolute responsibility. The question that must be asked is does it?
Compensation stood out. CBC reporters Vera-Lynn Kubinec and Caroline Barghout wrote: “When it comes to executive salaries — such as $175,000 for the chief executive officer of Brightscape and $160,000 for the chief operating officer — the report recommended a review of executive salaries by an HR consulting firm.” 1 Now these numbers stun me, and I knew competent, credentialed and youth care experienced executives, some of whom take a cut in salary to work in the sector. There is a historic precedent here. In the ‘70’s Manitoba had tens of private group home operators, some 60 clustered in the central core of the city. Each was independent following common standards of compensation yet operating with a wide latitude. The department providing oversight counted the peas on the plate and hangers in the closet yet just accepted the operator as presented. Most, I believe all are now gone, some being train wrecks like Brightscape.
You get what you pay for they say. In this instance it seemed to be a complex mix of bribes to youth and staff. The reporters continued:
“The Deloitte report documented staff bonuses including $7,265.79 for Winnipeg Jets tickets, $500 for a fitness class/spin class gift card, and $934.40 spent on cycling shoes for "two directors who went above and beyond their portfolio scope," the report says.
It also noted the company's advertising and promotion budget, which management described as being used mostly for things like recruiting fees and staff hiring, included payments of $296.57 for Dom Pérignon Champagne as a gift to a lawyer, as well as $974.12 for Winnipeg Jets tickets.” 2
This writer would like to think it will be annual forensic audits all around after this, but effective oversight remains allusive.
Turnover is constant in child and youth care. Is it any wonder with the diversity on offer out there? The system seems to be in constant flux.
Educators, the people who have the task of dealing with such flux can build and craft all the field they want but if it is only cherry picked to look good what good is it? The website for Brightscape certainly strung together the latest thinking in a wonderful presentation. You have your structural hard heads, loosie goose’s, bleeding hearts, and devil may care types. There is a viewpoint on the practice as there is staff and a philosophy of treatment as there is programs. It is a wonder anything gets done at all. It is curious to me that a profession (read anything Jack Phelan writes) that demands years of commitment to digest, interpret, apply and apply again is measured in months if you are lucky. Jack Phelan remarked in his address to the NACCW: “Good child and youth care work is talking to their heart not to their head.” 3 You cannot mentor anyone in a month let alone several years. The emergence of Human Resource professionals has not helped. Not only do they absolve supervisors from mentoring anyone, but they also have the power to tinker with the system of the treatment community itself. A lot of folks with even more notions than a television network. Compensation has always been a mystery at the staff level as well. Ideally, one should progress up the levels on the salary scale in a fair and balanced way. You want experience, or do you? Regime changes with new administrators or supervisors often set off a clearing to the decks busting up teams of hard-won excellence. Do those agencies loose staffing compensation commensurate with the individual position or do they bag a bonus trading down? Just curious.
There has been an evolution towards size of agency. I experienced a transition from a religious based charity to a complex array of programs that operates on a scale never foreseen by the founders. When you have worked to have child and youth care work credentialed and you see professions in accounting, human resources, communications, computers, data and administration brought in at top dollar and given a seat once occupied by a youth supervisor at the board table, you begin to become a little concerned about giantism. Treatment is now complimented with constant fund raising, profile is essential to attract clients, staff and dollars. For me this trend clearly meets a demand and provides a service as they thrive as the need is that great.
And yet, for those whose heart is in it, the trend is toward the family unit in either a group or foster setting. Thom Garfat speaks of the moment of connectedness between persons.4 While this column queries the lack of such connectedness between the key elements of the care system the folks, I have known have worked themselves toward sharing their profession with their spouse as a foster parent or finding a boutique group unit that excels with certain client needs. One colleague works as a foster carer only for a family. Many have not only survived this pandemic but thrive doing so. The passing of the pandemic and it is passing with an ETA of sometime in 2022 there will be an explosion of connectedness, perhaps one that will allow the child and youth care system pull itself together to realize there is a need for sharing between provinces, for Federal participation and for a renewed appreciation for the development of the child and youth care practitioner as a mature professional with applicable skills. One can only hope. Heather Modlin calls child and youth care professionals as “champions of hope” reminding her audience of Randi G. Fine’s statement: “Hope is the promise that anything is possible.” Should they ever get a handle on this virus the prognosis is anything will happen, there will be no return to normalcy, at least not in the short term.
1 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/brightscape-grou-home-financial-audit-spending-1.6200318? vfz=medium%3Dsharebar&fbclid=IwAR3cn7muEjLFivxsw_59taXz8guMby3im6u EygLV6n23k1HLr-QFG-4_x08
2 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/brightscape-grou-home-financial-audit-spending-1.6200318? vfz=medium%3Dsharebar&fbclid=IwAR3cn7muEjLFivxsw_59taXz8guMby3im6u EygLV6n23k1HLr-QFG-4_x08