CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 273 NOVEMBER 2021

Identity Conversations in Child and Youth Care Practice

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Questions of identity are often raised in the context of identity politics, which immediately renders the resultant discussions divisive and tense. That doesn’t mean these questions should be

avoided; it simply means that engaging these questions requires a great deal of capacity to deal with the tensions that will flow from them. In this article, I want to focus not on general questions of identity but instead the much more specific context of how explorations of identity can contribute to child and youth care practice in an interpersonal relational context. I think it is important to begin to develop intentional frameworks for becoming engaged with young people pursuant to their evolving ways of seeing who and how they are in this world. We should explore with them who they see themselves as being, how their vision of who they are is or is not influenced by the current circumstances of their lives, and how an ongoing reflective process of thinking about who they aspire to be can be helpful in managing the adversities and challenges they face now and in the future. It is not possible, of course, to have such conversations with young people outside of historical, political, and systemic patterns of social and cultural life. We are all rooted in our social context, whether that is a context of privilege or adversity, opportunity or oppression. And yet, regardless of how we are socially positioned based on race, ability and disability, gender and other factors, we will spend every day of our lives navigating our relationship with the world around us. Many identity conversations with young people get stuck on static factors and their relationship to systemic and structural injustices. I want to suggest that while this is perhaps not surprising and entirely legitimate, it is also worthwhile to de-center such static factors and focus instead on identity in a relational way. In other words, we can focus specifically on young people’s relationship to the world they experience all around them, understanding that the world around them is not an objective thing but an ever-shifting network of relationships that offer both goodness and care as well as challenge and injustice.

I am not advocating that we begin to ask young people questions such as “Who are you?” and “Who do you want to be?” In fact, I would discourage such questions, in part because they center identity not in relational ways but in descriptive, object-centered ways. For a young person, who they might see themselves as being very likely differs depending on a range of circumstances. It turns out that we can be more than one thing, more than one way, in relation to different others and different constellations of circumstances. And asking “who do you want to be” is a loaded question, placing the responsibility for being someone in particular squarely on the young person disconnected from their social context. Who I want to be depends entirely on who you choose to be, and how your choice of being a particular way becomes performed in my life. The spirit of ubuntu, often captured in the phrase I am because you are, is indeed at the centre of our relational identities.

Still, I think we have endless opportunity in our interactions with young people to explore how they see themselves being and evolving in relation to the world around them. Engaging how we are in relation to what we encounter is a critical component of building strength and resilience in the face of adversity. It is also an essential feature in decision-making when we are faced with both everyday situations and with much more impactful and significant choices that may influence our future. One example where relational identity conversations might feature more centrally than they currently do is managing conflict with others. Our focus in doing so is usually based on solutions; we ask questions such as ‘how can you get along with this person’ or ‘how can whatever you two disagree on get resolved’. In other words, our focus is interventive – we aim to solve a problem by helping young people explore strategies to move forward.

There is nothing wrong with doing so, but I am not sure this really speaks to the opportunity presenting itself. For most young people we encounter, specific interpersonal conflict situations are not really defining moments in their lives. Conflict happens, peer relationships come and go, and whether or not a conflict is resolved ultimately is almost always circumstantial anyways. Instead, we might use the opportunity not to solve the presenting problem (the conflict), but to focus on how a young person thinks about the conflict, which provides an opportunity for that young person to build identity infrastructure. By that I mean that it allows a young person to think about their own way of being in the face of conflict and how this way of being is reflective of the ways in which they ascribe value to solutions and to their own mastery of humility, respect for others even when we don’t like what they do, and their general positioning or response to a world in which conflict and care always co-exist.

Everyday encounters and experiences also lend themselves to relational identity conversations. Walking with a young person past a homeless person allows for conversations to emerge that focus not on whether walking past the homeless person (without engaging or assisting) is right or wrong, but instead about how the young person thinks about their own way of being in the world in relation to the encounter with homelessness. Who or what are you in that context? Are you a bystander? A person complicit in the other person’s fate? A person with responsibilities to respond to this moment, or perhaps to respond to the phenomenon of homelessness or a person disconnected from that phenomenon and living life independently from that phenomenon? In these explorations, it doesn’t matter what action is taken in the moment; we are not aiming to solve anything in particular, and we are not looking for interventions. In effect, the relational identity conversation is an investment – specifically an investment in the young person’s identity infrastructure that they can draw on in relation to endless moments yet to encounter.

Some concepts, such as humility, respect, the Self, relationship, and care, are often discussed in our literature and our training sessions, and I agree with those who have really focused on these concepts and developed them in relation to child and youth care practice. However, I furthermore believe that each of these kinds of concepts has far more meaning and opportunity embedded in them if we approach them as dynamic and evolving elements of young people’s identities. I call it relational identity specifically because the focus is not on the individual, but the relationships of individuals with the world – physical, social, and spiritual – around them. When we are able to see ourselves in those relationships through a lens of care or humility, we may well be able to approach challenges within those relationships differently. When we avoid or simply abstain from exploring how and who we are in our relationships with the world around us, in contrast, we construct all adversity and all challenges as a contest between Self and Other, and this, I think, is not particularly useful.

The world we live in is complicated. From climate change to pandemics, and from military conflicts to the erosion of democracy, there is a great deal of challenge and adversity in our young people’s futures that will require a strong sense of Self and a clear understanding on our relationships with that world around us. Child and youth care has a mission beyond helping young people to become healthy or healthier individuals. It also has a mission to ensure that young people are able to carry forth visions of a just and equitable world. This is not going to happen if we are not engaged with young people at a relational identity level. Beyond the identity politics embedded in social struggles against racism and oppression, I think our interpersonal practice can become more embedded in systemic and structural analyses when we focus less on intervening in the operational, logistical and behavioural problems youth encounter and instead take a more forward-looking approach that explores with them how and who they are in their relationships with the larger world. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App