Back in my early days of child and youth care I worked in a long-term group home in Alberta, Canada. We had six beds available to children’s services located in what was considered an average neighbourhood. At the time, a long-term group home would often have young people living there for a number of years, often until they transitioned into adulthood and moved to a supported independent living situation. It was not unheard of for residents to stay three or four years in a setting such as this. Long-term group homes were designed for youth who were not able to live at home; those who did not fit well in foster care, and many were permanent wards of Children’s Services.
Family involvement was limited. If there was family involvement it was the occasional visit home on a weekend, or the family might come home to the annual holiday celebration held in December. Family visits would often break down and we would pick up the young person up after only one day with their family. Sometimes it would not even last that long.
Phone calls with family members were only allowed during certain scheduled times, usually after dinner and when chores were completed. This rule was sometimes broken because families would call outside of the scheduled time claiming that was the only chance they had to call.
We had such rigidity around family that we had rules about when young people were allowed to talk to their family; and that we allowed home visits with family, as if the child belonged to us and we would allow them to only visit their family (T. Garfat, personal communication, April 29, 2021).
Young people did not have cell phones or access to the internet, neither had become mainstream yet, so they were very dependent on access to family through landlines monitored by the group home staff. At the time, we had strict rules about how and when the phone line was used by youth in the program. We didn’t want them to have free access to phones, as we believed it was sure to cause behavioural problems if they became upset during the phone call. We went through a number of phones because the phone would be slammed, thrown across the room, and even used as a weapon on occasion. Phones were risky in the hands of an upset and dysregulating young person. Thinking back on it now, I do not know what we were thinking. We would put young people in the position of having emotionally charged conversations with their family members in front of their peers and then wonder why they could not keep control of their emotional reactions.
At the time, I was fresh out of school and ready to change the lives of the “at risk youth” that I was charged with caring for. I wasn’t sure that I was fully prepared to help young people fix their lives, become independent, and break away from their “dysfunctional” families, but I knew there were people that I was working alongside who had been doing this work for a long time, so why question anything? I just went along with what I was told to do and did not ask questions (at least in the early years of my career). There were rules and processes in place for a reason, and families were not in the lives of youth in the program for a reason. It was not my place as the Youth Worker to question or inquire about different options. What the Case Worker or Social Worker (Children’s Services delegated guardian) said they wanted to happen is what was done, end of discussion.
I eventually became a key worker, the Youth Worker in charge of one young person in the group home. In my case (which I recognize might not have been the same for all key workers in other programs), I was responsible for all the reporting, assessments, and attending case conference meetings involving this particular youth. This meant that I was able to help guide the treatment plan of my key kid, or so I thought. I soon found out that Youth Workers did not have much respect at the conference table when it came to decision making and case planning.
Family members were not often present at the regular case conferences regarding their child. Case conferences usually consisted of the group home manager, supervisor, or director; the key worker; the Case Manager from Children’s Services; the youth (sometimes); and on few occasions the family. Apparently, it was deemed unimportant to invite the family. Sadly, at the time, I was just fine with that; because clearly, they must be the problem – right? We (the professionals) are the best people to support youth in care, right? We will always be there for them, won’t we?
Fast forward a decade or two and I am managing multiple programs at a large agency and we (Children’s Services and Children’s Services Agencies) are learning about the importance of including family in the treatment plans of young people. We are exploring wrap around type services that include having the young person’s family of choice at case conferences, supporting the youth who is always in attendance at a case conference. We are learning about family finding (n.d.), a concept created by Kevin Campbell that involves the professionals in the lives of young people actively looking for people from the young person’s past who can be supportive in the life of the young person. We are looking for people outside of ourselves to be the support that will carry on as we (the professionals) pull out of the young person’s life. We are involving people who, in the past, we would have declared unfit or problematic to the table at decision making time. We (the children’s service sector) have decided that young people most often go back to where they came from, back to their family, or back to the where and what they know – including the streets. Therefore, in light of that, we certainly should include the people that are important to a young person in their treatment planning … shouldn’t we? The answer is yes. Yes, we should, but are we?
An old African proverb, believed to embody the spirit of several African cultures, says “It takes a village to raise a child” meaning that the entire community should engage with children so that they can grow in a safe and healthy environment. Yet, despite knowing this is likely true, society in general (western society especially) seems to fail at following through. We isolate within nuclear families, and when the nuclear family encounters difficulty within the family system and trouble arises, children’s services will often get involved, for good or bad depending on the situation.
Regardless, if children’s services involvement is good or bad it is traumatic for children, youth, and families. Imagine being a child who is taken from your home and family and sent to a place where you do not know anyone, you don’t know the rules, you don’t know if you will see your family again, and you don’t know if you will be safe. If you are a parent or have a young person in your family that you can call to mind, think about the fear that child would have if it were them who was taken away.
We tend to forget about the fear when we believe we are helping children, youth, and families by intervening to keep children and youth safe. Who is there to help bridge the transition for the child, who can they rely on to be there? I know that many practitioners in child and youth care think they will be that person. We want to be that person for young people, but we are not. We are paid professionals in their lives, we will not be there long term, we cannot love and care for them in the same way that someone who will be part of their life forever can. I am not saying that we will not love and care for the children and youth we serve, but not in the same way that family can. Therefore, it is our responsibility to find the people who will be there for children and youth to support, love, care, and help to keep them safe throughout their life.
So, what is it that is getting in the way of this happening for every young person, each time? I believe it boils down to lack of resources and overloading of case management. I do not think that anyone who works with children, youth, and families would be against finding family, or individuals who can be natural supports to a young person; it is just finding the time and the resources to do it.
What if we had a dedicated person to do family finding at each program? A person who could work with the children’s services case manager, and the young person – if they are able – to seek out natural supports? I wonder what kind of difference that could make in the life of a young person who has been taken into care, or a young person who is struggling and at risk of needing children services intervention. The Family Finding Model, developed by Kevin A. Campbell (n.d.), is an evidence-based model used to identify relatives and other important adult connections for children in care. The model responds to those involved in the child welfare system with the same urgency as the Red Cross during crisis, using the philosophy of Article 26 of the Geneva Convention – “The Right to Know”. Family Finding projects have demonstrated that Family Finding works to significantly increase the number of relatives and other important adult connections for children in care and leads to an average of five to eight offers of help from these adults (Campbell., n.d.).
I remember many years ago working with a young person in the long-term group home where I worked. This youth had been taken into care under a temporary guardianship order, meaning she could be in care for up to two years (or more if extensions were granted), while the system decided what would happen for her. Her Mom was living in a very unclean home, where hoarding was occurring, and Dad did not have custody. So, the youth and her brother were taken into care and placed in different group homes. At that time, the immediate family may have been consulted about taking in the children but there was no support offered to make it manageable. There was a grandmother involved but she was unable to care for two teenagers without assistance. The system failed the children in that they failed to dive deep into the past of the family and look for people who could be involved with the children. Instead, the children remained in long term group homes with multiple extensions on their temporary guardianship order, while their Mom was given orders repeatedly to get the house in livable condition to get her children back.
What we know now, is so much more support was needed for this family.
Years later, an aunt and uncle who lived in Ontario, found out about the children being in care. They did not know they had been taken into care because nobody had looked for other relatives. Once they found out, they wanted to know if they could move to Alberta and take the children into their care? They were fully prepared to do whatever they needed to do to help the children. Unfortunately, by that point, the children had become enmeshed in the child welfare system and did not want to go live with people they now viewed as strangers. I wonder if this would have worked out differently had the aunt and uncle been connected to the children earlier on, perhaps in what we now know as a kinship placement.
Resources will probably always be a barrier to child and family services being done well, but we can continue to advocate for better options.
People need more time and space in their caseloads and programs to be able to do their jobs well and provide the best possible outcomes for children, youth, and families. By asking local children’s service authorities and organizations about models such as Family Finding (nd) we encourage the system to continue to keep looking for natural supports for children and youth in care. Everyone needs someone in their lives who will be there for them as a supportive resource and young people in care need this even more as their lives are quickly turned upside down. I hope we can commit to doing more than just talking about it.
Reference
Campbell, K. (n.d.). www.familyfinding.org
Originally published in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 34, No.1 pp44-49