CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 153 NOVEMBER 2011

The Quest for Professionalization

John Stein

The acceptance of Child and Youth Care work as a profession is a theme that continues to come up among Child and Youth Care workers.

Many complain that their work and expertise are not fully appreciated. As a result, their contributions in treatment team meetings tend to be devalued. More, they feel that they are being taken advantage of, being paid less than they are worth because of the belief that they work because of their dedication and commitment to their children rather than for money.

In thinking about all this, I thought to look at the professionalization of Social Work to see whether it had anything to offer Child and Youth Care Work. Trattner (1984), in From Poor Law to Welfare State: A history of social welfare in America, offers a chapter entitled “The Quest for Professionalization” in the latter half of the text (pp. 219-238). I thought it provided some insight into the current struggles of the Child and Youth Care profession.

The Quest for Professionalization of Social Work

Over the years, especially in the late nineteenth century, as the day of the generalist was beginning to fade groups–teachers, engineers, geologists, chemists, economists, political scientists, and so on–experienced a formative growth toward self-consciousness and efficient organization that resulted in their becoming professions. Before they could do so, they had to have exclusive possession of a systematic body of knowledge, a monopoly of skill obtained from higher education and training, and a subculture whose members shared a group identity and common values (Trattner, 1984, p.219).

During the early twentienth century, charity workers also sought professional status (Trattner, 1984, p. 219).

In 1914, Charles P. Neill, the U.S. federal Commissioner of Labor opined:

Zeal for the cause of health or devotion is not accepted as a sufficient basis to turn anyone lose as a healer. But too often, zeal in the cause is all that is expected of a charity worker. The unintelligent, untrained charity worker can, in spite of disinterested zeal, often cause... havoc (Trattner, pp. 219-220).

It seemed that the systemic problems of industrialization required trained workers, schools to train them, social research, other highly technical skills, and professional discipline.

Charity workers did not have these tools at the turn of the century nor, in the eyes of the public, could they ever develop or acquire them. It was commonly felt that social work consisted of little more than providing aid to people in need, and that no person or group could claim a monopoly on benevolence or could create a profession out of it. To the extent that every person had an obligation to help the suffering, social work was everybody’s business. Only when social workers succeeded in convincing the public that not everyone with love in his or her heart could do the job, that social work consisted of more than benevolence and well-wishing, that it had a scientific as well as an ethical component, did they achieve professional recognition (p. 220).

By the third decade of the twentieth century, social workers had founded professional schools, developed a systematic body of knowledge based on scientific theories, and demonstrated unique skills. More, they “had a self-conscious group of practitioners who belonged to a number of newly created professional organizations” (p. 221).

Trattner traces the beginnings of the movement to professionalize Social Work to the American Social Science Association founded in 1865. At their annual meeting in 1874, members of state boards of charities who were attending the meeting decided to get together to discuss common problems and solutions. Later that year, paid secretaries of those boards got together in what was probably the first meeting of people making a career of charitable work, laying the groundwork for the founding of the Conference of Charities. In 1884, the group changed its name to the National Conference of Charities and Correction, opened it’s doors to others, both religious and secular, and published Proceedings, a record of its annual meetings. They created a certain esprit de corps among charity workers, establishing charity work as a distinct occupational area in which they alone could claim expertise.

By the late nineteenth century, social work was beginning to pass beyond mere philanthropy to a vocation based upon the assumption that it required specific knowledge, skills, and techniques, as well as good intentions, and that such capabilities could be passed from teachers to students (p. 223).

Moving into the twentieth century, there were two specializations, casework and settlement house work. Both groups realized that:

Since the concepts, values, standards, and techniques of the profession are rooted in education, vitality in the field depends upon a reciprocal flow of knowledge between the teacher and the practitioner, between theory and practice, between the training school and the agencies in the community (p. 223).

In 1898, the New York Charity organization organized the Summer School of Philanthropy, an annual six-week summer program for those already working in the field. It consisted of lectures, visits to public and private agencies, and field work. Later, the school was renamed the New York School of Philanthropy, redesigning and expanding its program to a full academic year, primarily for students without experience. In 1910, it expanded to a two-year program. By 1920, it had become the New York School of Social Work (later becoming the Columbia University Graduate School of Social Work). In 1901, settlement houses in Chicago cooperated in offering an extension course through the University of Chicago, leading to the founding of the Chicago School of Civics and Philanthropy, which became the University of Chicago School of Social Work in 1920. Meanwhile, in 1904, Boston’s Associated Charities in cooperation with Simmons College and Harvard University, founded the Boston School of Social Work.

At first, most schools of social work were like the New York School of Philanthropy; that is, adjuncts of private social agencies which supplied instructors and the opportunities for field work, which for the most part subordinated theory and research to field work. They produced practitioners to staff their agencies rather than administrators, scholars, social theorists, and the like (p. 228).

There were debates about the curricula in these schools. Should they be training centers or educational institutions? Should they provide knowledge and theory or experience through field work? Should theory be on subject matter or methods? Should field work be supervised by agency personnel or educators? Should there be research?

As more schools of social work began to appear, their directors began meeting at the National Conference of Charities and Correction. In 1920, feeling the need for some accrediting agency for schools of social work, they established the Association of Training Schools of Professional Social Work, which eventually became the Council on Social Work Education in 1952. It continues to set the standards of social work education in the United States and Canada.

Another important development in the professionalization of social work was the appearance of specialized publications, beginning with the Proceedings of the National Conference of Charities and Correction in 1884, followed by the journal Lend-A-Hand in Boston in 1886, Charities Review in New York in 1891, and other numerous specialized and general practice journals, later including Social Casework in 1920, Child Welfare in 1922, Social Service Review in 1927, Social Work Today and Public Welfare in the mid 1930s, and many more.

At least one more thing was needed for social work to be considered a profession–professional associations. Professional associations are important, helping to raise standards and determine the relationship between the profession and society. More, in linking professional colleagues through a network of such associations, professional associations help to differentiate between professionals and amateurs as nonprofessional outsiders. Further, they facilitate links between schools and practitioners.

Traditionally, there have been two types of national associations in social work–groups concerned with extending and improving the quality of work of member agencies (such as the National Federation of Settlements, the Family Welfare Association, the Council on Social Work Education), and associations of individual social workers which seek to further professional development and improve working conditions (such as the American Association of Medical Social Workers and the American Association of Psychiatric Social Workers).

In 1911, the alumnae of several women’s colleges organized the Bureau of Occupations to serve as an employment agency. The demand for positions of social work was so great that a special department was created for social work applicants. It maintained a registry of all social workers affiliated with it, laying the foundation for a national organization, In 1917, it separated to become the National Social Worker’s Exchange, assuming responsibility over additional areas including salaries, ethics, standards, and communications among various branches of the field. It opened its membership to anyone engaged in social work, either paid or volunteer. In 1921, members voted to change the name to the American Association of Social Workers. In 1955, it merged with several other associations, changed its name to the National Association of Social Workers (NASW), and decided that graduation from an accredited school of social work was necessary for membership. (NASW currently offers three types of membership: Regular Full Membership for social workers with at least a BSW, Student Membership, and Associate Membership for people with a professional interest in the profession or its clients (NASW, 2011). It’s purpose throughout:

To serve as an organization whose members, acting together, shall endeavor through investigation and conference 1) to develop professional standards in social work; 2) to encourage adequate preparation and professional training; 3) to recruit new workers; and 4) to develop a better adjustment between workers and positions in social work (p. 235).

In 1960, NASW established the Academy of Certified Social Workers to provide credentialing (ACSW) of social workers who met rigorous criteria for education and practice (NASW, 2011). Trattner concludes:

All that remained for professionalization was popular acceptance of the fact that social work had a well defined body of knowledge and unique techniques capable of transmission through a formal educational process (p. 236).

Social work has most certainly achieved professional status today. Most (if not all) states in the US provide for the professional licensing of social workers and require licensure to practice social work independently. I have seen salaries improve significantly since the 1970s.

The Quest for Professionalization of Child and Youth Care Work

Child and youth care in some parts of the world seems to be well along the road followed by social workers, less further along in other places, and in yet other parts of the world, they seem yet to have begun the journey.

In Canada and other ‘commonwealth’ nations, there are professional associations, schools providing courses of study dedicated to the field, and journals produced by and dedicated to the field. In fact, in one way, the Child and Youth Care profession is a bit ahead of the curve.

Through the Internet, most notably CYC-Net, but also other resources, there is now world wide communication among practitioners and educators.

All that remains, it seems, is “popular acceptance of the fact that” Child and Youth Care has “a well defined body of knowledge and unique techniques capable of transmission through a formal educational process.”

It did not happen quickly or easily for social workers. At first, they weren’t even social workers, they were charity workers in philanthropy. Gradually, they developed a professional identity and adopted the title of social worker. Eventually, they set standards of education and practice for themselves, and provided credentials for social workers who met those standards.

In other parts of the world, most notably for me, in much of the US and especially in Louisiana, the journey has not begun. More, the beginning does not even seem to be on the horizon. Pay for many entering the field is minimum wage, $7.25/hour or $15,080 annually (Civil Service pay for psych aides, working on children’s units in state psychiatric hospitals). Some private agencies pay a bit more, perhaps as high as $10/hour or $20,800 annually, but still below federal poverty guidelines for a family of four.

As a result, qualifications are low. In many instances, a high school diploma is accepted as the minimum qualification, although a bachelor’s degree may be ‘preferred.’ Consequently, expectations are equally low, little more than providing basic supervision. Get the kids up and dressed, get the beds made, and get them off to school on time. Get their homework and chores done. See that the rules and schedules are followed. Keep them out of trouble and don’t let them bust the place up. Don’t get too imaginative and interfere with treatment done by professionals.

Most agencies are headed by social workers, psychologists, or other professionals, possibly with advanced degrees in education or pastoral counseling. They do not identify themselves as Child and Youth Care professionals, but rather identify with their own professions. Consequently, there is no leadership for the Child and Youth Care profession. The state association of child care agencies, attended by agency executives, has been more interested in advocating for agencies, but sees little connection between that and improving the pay and quality of CYCs. Few if anyone sees a need to provide formal education for CYCs. The vision is not there. Heck, anyone can supervise kids. How hard is that? Especially when there is all that treatment available from professionals. (It can be most interesting to see the reactions of ‘professionals’ if they are called upon to supervise a residential unit for a time when child care workers are unavailable for one reason or another, e.g., during staff shortages because of high turnover or mandatory training.)

While many of the Child and Youth Care workers with whom I have worked in Louisiana have been remarkably talented and skilled practitioners who would be a credit to the profession anywhere, few if any CYCs here view themselves as professionals. They have little time or opportunity for contact with other CYCs in other agencies, and consequently little opportunity or support to begin the quest for professionalization. They have little incentive or opportunity to organize, to seek certification, or to further their education (other than to get a different and better job).

And since no one sees the need, there is little chance of increased funding, especially in these times of reducing all government expenditures, no matter the cuts in services. It is “commonly felt that” Child and Youth Care work consists “of little more than” supervising children, “and that no person or group could...create a profession out of it.”

I wonder sometimes whether a name change might be beneficial, much as when ‘charity workers’ adopted the title of ‘social worker.’ Would ‘child development worker’ be a more descriptive title? Would it help to differentiate the profession from the ‘anyone can supervise kids’ mentality associated with ‘child care’ that in Louisiana serves to diminish the ‘profession?’

But there is one other obstacle I sense here in Louisiana. I wonder whether it is a problem in other localities, as well. Other professionals here seem to feel somewhat threatened by the idea that others might possibly do some of the things that they consider exclusively within their profession, based on their advanced education and licensure. More, that they might do it better.

A Word of Caution

The teaching profession also formed national and local associations and all that. But instead of acting more like professional associations, many of these bodies opted for the organized labor route, joining labor organizations such as the AFL-CIO. Rather than advocating for the profession and it’s clients, some focused on advocating for members, often at the expense of students, at times going so far as going on strike, in effect holding their students hostage, seeking better pay and other benefits, including shorter hours, reduced duties in the school, duty free lunch, and job security for themselves while advocating for little or nothing for the children. Instead of advocating for the needs of students, i.e., advocating for higher standards, more resources, and better pay to attract better trained and qualified teachers, they advocated for their own ‘needs.’ Instead of ‘we need to pay better to get better teachers,’ it seemed to be we want more money.’ Instead of establishing standards for certification of professional teachers, some organizations fought for job security for all members, regardless of ability and performance, sometimes resulting in job protection for incompetent teachers. I would hate to see Child and Youth Care follow this road to improving pay and working conditions.

Conclusions

There are many places where Child and Youth Care is well along the road to professionalization, though not yet close enough to the end for those in the struggle. There are places where the Child and Youth Care profession faces many of the same challenges faced by those in Louisiana and the journey has het to begin. There are those places where the journey is partway along the path.The steps seem to be, in whatever order:

  1. Organize.
  2. Communicate
  3. Develop a shared sense of professional identity and self-worth.
  4. Develop specific and unique knowledge and skill sets and the schools to teach them and the research to support them.
  5. Develop professional literature.
  6. Gain acceptance and recognition from other professionals, the community, and funding sources.

References

NASW. 2011. Website. http://www.socialworkers.org/credentials/c redentials/acsw.asp

Stein, J. 2009. “What’s in a Name” Goodenoughcaring Journal. http://www.goodenoughcaring.com/Journal/ Article92.htm

Trattner, W. I. 1984. From Poor Law to Welfare State: A history of social welfare in America. The Free Press: New York.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App