CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 153 NOVEMBER 2011

Outrageous, isn’t it?

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Recently much of Ontario became incensed when news broke about a rather macabre story at a hospital in the southwestern end of the province. Apparently an elderly woman (82 years of age, we now know) was entering the hospital in order to visit her imminently dying husband. As she entered through the visitors’ entrance she fell, and ended up lying half inside of the hospital and half outside. The fall was sudden and awkward, and as a result of it the woman was bleeding on her elbows as well as her face. In addition, she damaged her hips and therefore was unable to get herself off the ground. She yelled for help, and indeed, nurses came immediately. Instead of providing help, however, the nurses instructed the woman (who, I may remind you, was lying face down, bleeding on the floor) to call an ambulance so that she could be taken to the Emergency Ward, which was located approximately 30 meters to the left of the Visitors’ Entrance. In spite of pleading with the nurses, these and additional hospital staff that came to scene insisted that an ambulance be called. An ambulance was eventually called, however, none was available in the city where this hospital is located, and therefore one had to be ordered from a nearby town; the hospital was informed that this would take approximately 40 minutes. Not in any way dissuaded from their position, the hospital staff continued to insist that the woman wait for the ambulance and provided no medical assistance whatsoever, nor did they make any attempt to pick the woman up from off the ground. Minutes before the ambulance finally did arrive, a doctor inadvertently came to the scene, picked the woman up off the ground and carried her over to the Emergency Ward, where she then received treatment. Sadly, her husband passed away while she was still receiving treatment and therefore she had to let him go without saying goodbye.

This story is outrageous, isn’t it? I mean really, who in their right mind would do such a thing? How can a hospital, of all places, behave in such inhumane, reckless and insensitive manner? It is difficult to come up with the appropriate language to describe the idiocy of this particular incident. It is clear, however, that once the incident has been forgotten (right about now), the woman will still have to live the rest of her life knowing that this did indeed happen, that she was unable to say good-bye to her husband, and that should she ever require assistance from a hospital, she will have no reason to have confidence that all will be well.

It is ever so easy to be outraged by the incompetence, insanity, inhumanity or darkness of other systems and other professionals. Such crazy things would never happen in our institutions, programs or services, would they? We care, are empathetic , have respect for people in general and certainly for those who come to us for assistance. I do wonder, sometimes, what sort of response we would get from the general population if some of our routine practices made the news. Here are some examples that have actually happened and that I suspect continue to happen with astonishing frequency:

  1. After pulling off the eyes of several stuffed animals, a five year old boy is removed from his foster home and placed in a group home by a child protection agency where there are ten adolescents with significant behavior issues. During his six months stay in the group home, he witnesses daily violence, daily police involvement, is yelled at himself by the older teens and on several occasions has his life threatened. While the staff try their best to be attentive, the reality is that there are two staff present for ten kids and therefore the attention the boy receives is limited. The child protection agency feels that the incident with the stuffed animals points to a high risk of sexual offending behavior and therefore the boy is well placed in this setting. Several of the teenagers living in the home are themselves victims of sexual abuse and/or sexual offenders, and no assurances can be given by the program that the five-year-old boy will be within staff eyesight at all times.
  2. Two workers from the same child protection agency each place a young person in the same group home, also operated by the same child protection agency. Turns out that one of the youth had previously sexually assaulted the other. When the issue was brought to the table for discussion, each of the workers encouraged the staff in the group home to provide support to their respective youngster. No other action was proposed or taken, and for a period of six weeks, the young person who had been abused refused to leave his room unless the other young person was away from the house. He was placed elsewhere after this six week period.
  3. A teenager with significant behavior issues was placed in a group home for teenagers with significant behavior problems. In a conflict with a staff member, the teenager picked up an orange from the table and threw it in the direction of the staff member (but not hitting the staff member). The police were called and the staff insisted that the teenager be charged with assault. The police carted him off to the station, charges were laid, and the youngster was released on conditions of following the rules where he lived. The teenager with behavior problems living in the group home for teenagers with behavior problems promptly had a behavior problem, resulting in the police being called so that he could be charged with violating the conditions of his release from the previous charge. This time he was kept in custody for a few days before being released with clear orders to follow the group home rules as well as with a tight curfew. Upon missing his curfew one night, he was charged again and sent to custody for three weeks. And upon return, he got into a major fight at the group home with a peer, was discharged from that group home, and over the period of the next few months experienced over ten different placements. Reportedly he went missing altogether when he was 16 years of age, and no one seems to know where he is today.

Of course, everyone who has worked in Child and Youth Care systems for any length of time could add many, many other stories like this. And of course, all of us could also add some very wonderful stories about young people finding their path, doing great, becoming whatever it is that makes them proud. Similarly the hospital surely must get the odd surgery right, mend the occasional broken bone and provide timely diagnoses for major illnesses. Getting things right is not the point. Getting them wrong is OK as well. But becoming outraged at the insanity, stupidity and outright inhumanity of institutions and systems ought to remind us that we have become perhaps a little too dependent on following procedures, abiding by policies, and indulging our paranoia about making mistakes. In the spirit of the ‘occupation’ movements in New York and around the world, and also in the spirit of those who resist just to be difficult, I want to remind everyone that being compliant and conforming to the rules results in 82 year-old women lying face down on the floor of the hospital, bleeding, while their husbands die.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App