There’s nothing inherently wrong with power struggles. In fact, they’re part of the natural order and essential to the sustainability of life on this planet. At the most basic level the outcomes may seem to be about ‘winners’ and ‘losers’, but seen through the eyes of Charlie Darwin, they are simply part of the action that make evolution possible. In the more advanced life forms, power struggles are the means whereby each new generation takes over from the one before, ensuring the survival of the species and providing the necessary conditions for the creation of power-hierarchies – including the one we refer to as “the family.” These ‘social’ systems inevitably control individual members and, whether we are talking about wolves or baboons, the core tension is always between the authoritarian elders and their overly ambitious offspring.
But does this all apply to us humans? While some psychologists and philosophers continue to argue that we are as biologically driven as any other species, most agree that our ability to reflect upon our subjective experience makes it possible for us to move beyond our basic urges and make alternative creative choices on our own behalf. According to the stance I’ve taken in this series of articles, this decision-making ability is nothing less than our internal sense of Self – how else could we become self aware, self motivated and self responsible?
From this perspective, power struggles are highly significant and necessary relational events along the rocky road toward separation, individuation and personal autonomy. Psychological theory suggests they are most likely to occur in early childhood, to wit, the ‘terrible twos’ and during adolescence but, as we all know, they are by no means limited to these periods of development. In the handbook of ideal developmental psychology, these uncomfortable episodes cause only transitory tensions and are passively resolved through the process known as rapprochement.
In the untamed world of Child and Youth Care practice, however, such ideals are sadly lacking and the recalcitrant behavior is often seen as a challenge to the efficacy of the program and a threat to the authority of the practitioner. The kids are duly labeled and every effort is made to control the offender through restrictive behavior management methods. In the parenting game, young children who seem to have no commitment to the concept of rapprochement may be diagnosed with “Oppositional Defiance Disorder” while adolescents become "Adjustment Reactions” or just plain "Punks". Once identified as a threat to adult authority, the developmental roots of the problem are tossed out of the window to focus on dealing with kids who need to respect their elders and obey the rules in other words, kids who need to be taught a lesson. For the most part, the one with the most power will win the day. But who will win the war? Well, nobody, of course.
But what if we return to the hypothesis that the underlying problem is developmental and its resolution requires some form of relational intervention. Should this be so, the enlightened practitioner would come to welcome the much maligned power struggle as an opportunity to do some remedial work, rather than see it as an uprising that needs to be quashed. From the outset, this would require an understanding of the developmental, functional and relational aspects of the conflict.
The Terrible Twos
Individual differences aside, most professionals and parents agree that somewhere between the ages of one and four, children seem to take on the characteristics of psychopaths-in-training. Even the most peaceful happy babies can be transformed into raging monsters, demanding immediate gratification, claiming everything as their own and refusing to share their coveted possessions with anybody. When confronted or denied, they fly into a tantrum and when given an order they scream in defiance. If you want to see this in action, spend and hour or so in your local shopping centre. If you’re able to resist the urge to take one of the little monsters by the scruff of the neck, then you are truly a professional. Even parents who understand this as a natural developmental phase can find themselves being drawn into a public confrontation with a Tasmanian devil and it’s hardly surprising that the less enlightened ones are bent on stamping out the wickedness before it’s too late.
Developmentally, we are dealing here with the child’s quest for separation and individuation. Though still very much attached to the parents, the thinking, and increasingly verbal, child is coming to understand he/she is a separate person who has the innate capacity to act on his or her own behalf. On the inside, the energetically emerging Self needs to know it has the resources and the power to operate in a vast and unknown world. This is no junior psychopath, only a self-indulgent narcissist carrying the “Here I Am” banner and expecting the world to pay due homage.
For the child, there are two important aspects of this transitory phase. The first is an opportunity to experience the raw indomitable Spirit that lies at the heart of the Self. The second is to hear the world speak back with a firm, gentle and caring voice. Both are equally important. If the fledgling Self is not able to spread its wings, it will never learn how to fly with confidence, let alone soar to its potential. If the world remains silent, the unfettered Self will have no way of understanding and learning the rules of order. And if the world reacts with hostility and repression, a power-struggle may flare up but, eventually, the battered Self will succumb to the superior power and withdraw from its essential task. The key is for parents to understand what’s taking place and respond in ways that are in the child’s best interests, rather than simply reacting to their own frustration. When it’s time to say “no” or impose appropriate consequences such actions can be taken without withholding the love and caring the fragile Self requires on its journey into fullness. This is all part of the process that gradually makes it possible for the child to learn about personal boundaries and move toward higher levels of empathy and individuation.
I’m not suggesting that parents should never take decisive action to prevent a ‘scene,’ or sacrifice their own sanity to protect the ‘child's best interests.’ There may be many episodes of pouting, yelling and carnage to contend with, but when the battle-cries run silent, the question is whether the child feels safe, seen and heard; and whether the quizzical Self remains assured that it can still carve out its own destiny in a complex and demanding world. Children who have this opportunity move back into relationships with their parents as transformed beings – rapprochement. Those who don’t, will continue to harbor resentment that may lie dormant for long periods of time, although the chances of an explosion or implosion will always be there. Unless there’s a major shift in relationships, you can almost guarantee that the bottled-up anger will rear up again as the sun sets on a stifled childhood.
The Adolescent Warrior
The developmental period we refer to as “adolescence” represents the second significant step along the pathway toward separation and individuation. This is the time when the Self needs to create it’s own separate identity or persona in order to step out into the world under its own steam. Even children who appear to move effortlessly from rapprochement to increasing levels of personal responsibility are challenged by this transition into adulthood. Those who remained detached and resentful, have neither the inner resources nor the necessary skills to take this step.
In their fear and confusion, some will choose to openly rebel, some will turn to a strategy of passive aggression and others will sink deeper into dependency. All continue to harbor a deeply rooted anger that seeps into every facet of their being. In psychiatric terms, these styles are classified as ‘adolescent adjustment reactions’ and are familiar patterns to most seasoned Child and Youth Care practitioners. Although it might seem that rebellion and passive aggression are more likely to fuel power-struggles, the subversive power that is drawn from a place of dependency and victim-hood is well-known in literature, politics and Child and Youth Care. In other words, they are all part of the same developmental/relational package.
The Peaceful (Child and Youth Care) Warrior
In one form or another, power-struggles are an ongoing aspect of Child and Youth Care practice and I’m not suggesting that this term should be applied whenever a kid acts out or refuses to comply with your expectations. Much as I hate the term, I’m proposing that practitioners become more ‘diagnostic’ in focusing upon recurring behavioral patterns that persistently undermine personal growth and relationship development. Since it takes two people to create a power-struggle, this particular ‘diagnosis’ should involve at least one other professional. If it is to become the focal point of the work, then the following protocols and practices might be considered.
You don’t need me to tell you that kids who turn relationships into power struggles can be frustrating to work with. By the same token, you also know that adults who have the same tendency should avoid this particular battlefield at all costs. Even those who have paused along the developmental highway to enjoy the gentle rest-stops of rapprochement may find it difficult to maintain their warm, caring and supportive stance in the face of anger and aggression. If you want to see this in its finest and most dramatic form, watch the New Zealand All Blacks perform the Haka. But that warm and supportive presence, provided by a firm and secure Self is the only lure that will draw a fearful Self from its hiding place and into the world of co-creative relationships.