CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 291 MAY 2023

Doing Life

Hans Skott-Myhre

There are two ways to read the title of this column. The meanings couldn’t be more disparate and yet at the same time, they are deeply entangled with one another. In fact, we could say they imply one another in the ways they articulate something important in how we see ourselves and the breadth of our capacity to act and become. On the one hand we have the common usage of the term “doing life” as it relates to being incarcerated under the terms of a life sentence. This is also related to the phrase “doing time” which refers to the experience of time spent while imprisoned. On the other hand, we could read the phrase “doing life” as an affirmation of living capacity. To do life is to engage with living force in as full a way as possible and to do time is to open time as a living space of creative possibility. As I said, these meanings may seem to be diametrically opposed to one another, but are they?

The beginnings of an inquiry into the question of doing life and time might well begin with an exploration of the what life and time mean for those of us working in Child and Youth Care (CYC). Indeed, for me, the central defining characteristic of Child and Youth Care is the lived experience of young people, their , families and communities, and CYC workers as they do life and time together.  That said, the lived experience of life and time is actually not included in the characteristics of CYC brilliantly explicated by Garfat, Freeman, Gharabaghi, and Fulcher. However, I would  argue that it is deeply inferred in the characteristics that are listed. Doing life and time is certainly a key element in the central driving concept of “the purposeful use of daily life events” with the associated key notions of “being,” “interpreting,” and “doing.” The idea that we do lifespace work also hold a resonance with doing life. But, life and time are implicit rather than explicit as the central defining characteristic in this description of what constitutes the field of practice. So, I would like to take a moment here to center life (and to a degree time as well) as the heartbeat of the work we do and the life that springs from that work.

But, does our life spring from the work and is our work the heartbeat that sustains us as CYC workers? For many of us we have been taught that the world of work is a separate space from our “real” life. We are taught that it is important to keep the work we do separate from the “life” we live. In a sense, we are given the impression that our work is at least mildly toxic and is a space that we enter cautiously and exit with care so as to not inadvertently contaminate our real lives. In this way of describing our work, our lived experience is intentionally bifurcated into two spheres. We can only fully integrate who we are, when we leave the world of work through some form of retirement. We are only whole, when work no longer takes a portion of time and lived experience away from our real life. This is why, even in a field of relational care, we are told we cannot form friendships with our “clients,” much less come to think of them as family, or as a community to which we belong. Similarly, our fellow workers should not hold a central role in our lives. We should be cautious about seeing them as family or community.

I am reminded of a program that worked in profoundly deep ways with street engaged youth. The workers in that program saw their engagement with youth more as a community than a social service program. They built complex and powerful webs of connectivity between themselves and the young people they engaged in their work. This commitment to living relational care extended into their relation with each other. They spent much of their free time with each other, weaving other family, partners, and friends into a extended family that was founded in the work they did in common. They held potlucks at each other’s houses, partied together, shared entertainment, and talked, talked, talked about life, love, work, and who they were becoming.

From a certain perspective, this was a very dangerous, incestuous, and enmeshed system that could lead to serious institutional dysfunction.

However, the program thrived and the young people and the staff worked collaboratively to build a very exciting and welcoming space for everyone who came there. This was a reasonably good example of doing life as an affirmation of creative force. The workers were taking life as the heartbeat of the work they did and their life sprang from the power of that work.

Unfortunately, one of my insights from working and teaching for over forty years now, is that open creative spaces within the dominant atmospheric of capitalism have a shelf life. They are like open windows that let in fresh air that can blow away the stale dead air of the traditional workplace. But, at some point they are likely to slammed shut.

And so it was, that the supervisor who had managed to hold the space open for this dynamic and exciting program left, and a new supervisor with much more traditional ideas took over. This supervisor was trained in family systems theory and believed that they were looking at an enmeshed and dysfunctional work environment. The solution was to re-establish boundaries between workers and young people, but also between the workers themselves.

To do this, the new supervisor brought in a consultant with expertise in enmeshed systems. They met the staff and notice right away that the workers referred themselves a collective “we,” when talking about the program and the work they did. The consultant began to intervene by insisting that every worker begin using “I” statements and to begin a process of differentiation from each other. This was heartbreaking for this closely knit community and gradually workers began to quit. This dissolution was accelerated when the new supervisor declared that all street engaged youth were traumatized and needed diagnosis and psychiatric intervention. Eventually, the community began to drift apart and the program hired a different staff and began to serve a different kind of young person.

I raise this example because it illustrates, the difference between doing life and doing life. In the first instance the program was doing life in the way that living organisms actually function. No living system is comprised of a series of differentiated entities who are not in some way deeply entangled with one another. Life is comprised of entanglements of living force constantly modifying and being modified by everything all at once. Indigenous theory such as that articulated by Lee Ann Simpson is clear that all things, living and inanimate are in kinships and sets of relations. It is colonial logic and the practices of capitalism that make every effort to separate us from our life and alienate us from the products of our creativity. In very important ways, this includes attempting to capture and appropriate our capacity to engage in complex social entanglements that go beyond the social norms of bourgeoisie socialization between mature individuals.

When we are subjected, as the workers were in this program, to an abstract set of social conventions, we begin to move from doing life to doing life. In other words, when we are pressured to match the social norms and conventions of definitions such as trauma or enmeshment, we begin to lose a central aspect of connection to life itself. Instead of celebrating the community of being of which we are a part, we drop into anxiety about whether we are individually getting it right. We begin to live life as a carceral activity, in which we are imprisoned in a system of solitary confinement, locked within ourselves. We are told that this is good for us and that it is a kind of freedom to be able to express our self. What we are not told is that the price for this kind of freedom is life.

It is not surprising that this prison of the free self has resulted in epidemic rates of loneliness. We are locked into a life of solitude and we can’t even see the walls of our cell. We even come to imagine that our inability to overcome our sense of alienation and loneliness is because there is something wrong with us. If we could just fix our self, then we could be freed.

But freedom seldom comes through the perfection of the self. Those models of perfection are always driven by abstract systems of power, who both set the terms and assure failure. If there is a kind of freedom that is found in solitude, it is generally through the loss of the self though an immersion in the flow of life. Such is the goal of solitary meditation or a life of hermitage. But the kind of solitude we experience under colonial capitalist systems of dominations and control is a separation from all our kin.

The options for resolution within the logic of colonial relations are fraught and complicated with the kind of dilemmas found in a prison. Under capitalism, relationships tend to be transactional and limited, designed to end as we all become increasingly independent. Our levels of violence to ourselves and others are on the increase. Our eruptions of violence are ever more frequent. We become despairing and despondent—ever more hopeless. In short, at some level we know we are doing life and we experience life as doing time. In short, we act very much like we are in an open air prison.

It is tremendously important however to realize that the prison of the self is a magic trick, a trance induction, an illusion. The prison is constructed out of nightmares from which we have the capacity to awake from and to waken others. Perhaps, this why the term woke has such resonance and why it elicits such resistance from those enmeshed in colonial logic. The antidote to nightmares is to wake up into the actuality of life. Of course, we might say that life these days can be pretty rough and perhaps we would prefer to sleep. But our lived experience in the world today is unduly painful today because too many of us remain imprisoned in the nightmare of alienation and loneliness. To awaken is never to awaken alone. It is to be brought to the awareness of the full power of all our relations. It is to enter a scared circle of life and to join in the struggle to preserve, enhance and celebrate life.

When I think of this in terms of CYC work and the programs where we often work, I begin to wonder if we are doing life or doing life? In other words, does our workplace thrive on separation and division? Is it a place of corporate hierarchy, with chains of command and institutional imperatives for professional behavior? Are there evidence-based prescriptions, treatment regimes, or techniques that rob us of our own creativity and replace it with day after day of the same old, same old? Do we go to work with a certain degree of trepidation that sooner or later someone will figure out that we don’t fit in and that we don’t really believe in the treatment anymore? That bossing young people around and getting them to behave isn’t enough? If that’s the case, then perhaps you are doing time. Just waiting until you can get free by finding another job, another degree, maybe some private practice. But, if you find that when you leave work, the same issues of repetition and constant striving persist, then perhaps you are doing life,

Of course, we could open the window and let some fresh air into the room. We could organize ourselves by aligning with life and creativity. We could become a community, instead of a program. We could join together with young people rather than treat them? We could free ourselves. But to have the force to do that we need the power of connectivity and collective action. We need all our relations and a commitment to the land and all things on it as a sacred commitment that we share. Because CYC has relationality as a central principle, it is as good a place as any to begin a jail break, to find others who share a vision of opening the doors and windows and letting life in. To do life, to do time as an affirmation of new worlds to come. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App