Over the past few years, many changes have taken place in the policy framework supporting young people leaving care. Most of these changes are quite positive and constructive. In many jurisdictions in the global North, young people leaving care have access to support until a later age than previously, even if the extent of such support varies considerably across jurisdictions. Preparations for leaving care start earlier in the care journey, sometimes with concrete steps being taken as early as 13 years of age. Transition workers are being hired to support young people as they navigate various entitlements and opportunities to benefit from the system. And a great deal of support has been mobilized to make post-secondary education much more accessible to young people leaving care, be that through new bursaries to pay for such education, tuition waivers for young people from care, or special supports, bridging programs, and other measures to support young people while making the transition to post-secondary education. In some jurisdictions, including where I live, targeted policies and programs aim to mitigate racial disparities and structurally embedded disadvantages experienced in particular by Black and Indigenous young people from care.
There is no denying that these policies and initiatives are major improvements over what for a long time seemed like state abuse and neglect of the very young people brought up in the care of that state in the name of protection. A great deal of advocacy, much of it driven by young people from care themselves and supported by practitioners and academics alike, has made a difference. It is of course true that for many young people leaving care none of this really matters. For them, the experience in care was so damaging that their interest in connecting with formal systems and opportunities is understandably minimal. Others are still getting lost in bureaucracies, excessive caseloads for workers, or because their transitions out of care are accompanied by transitions to criminal justice systems or homelessness and street-based systems. Again, others are impacted by mental health issues, addictions, neurodiversity, disability, or social rejection to such a degree that even the constructive policies and programs now available are not relevant. And still, things are better today than they were ten years ago, and that is a good thing.
On the other hand, young people leaving care are not transitioning to the same social, economic, and political context they were transitioning to ten years ago. I worry that the current efforts to improve policies and programs are responses to the world as we knew it ten years ago but are desperately out of touch with the current world and likely the ways in which that world will evolve in the coming years. Our world has changed in many ways, not the least of which is the introduction and consciousness of much greater precarity than ever before given the experience of a global pandemic, the effects of climate change, and the volatility of ideological battles dividing and destabilizing even those countries that we considered reliably democratic for decades and even centuries. All of these things have had an enormous impact on the economic organization of society in ways that I think may change the leaving care experience significantly. A few examples readily come to mind.
First, in our new and rapidly evolving economies the value of post-secondary education has shifted and certainly become less clear, both because the labour market is less responsive to generalized academic training, and because post-secondary institutions are increasingly providing a dollar store version of curriculum and student experience, largely driven by the ideological resistance to critical thinking and intellectual activity, and associated funding cuts on the part of explicitly or covertly right wing governments. Economic opportunity through the pathway of traditional post-secondary education seems much reduced; instead, we see pathways from specialized trades to entrepreneurial self-employment as much more promising than a liberal or critical education. There is still enormous value embedded in STEM-related educational pathways, notably in digital technologies, biomedical fields, and data, but young people leaving care are almost never represented in these streams.
Second, we can readily see that especially in larger urban settings, the most fundamental issue facing young people leaving care is housing. Their prospects at stable and safe housing are almost zero at this point, and there is little reason to believe that this will change in positive ways anytime soon. Housing is directly connected to labour market participation. Stable housing was a requirement for traditional labour markets because people had to go to work every day. In our new economies, the very nature of work is changing, and to the extent that such work no longer is place-based, the role of housing in labour market participation is shifting.
Third, the massive growth in human trafficking and online sexual exploitation, driven initially by the progress in digital capacity and then accelerated by the conditions of the pandemic have literally changed the way money flows, the way it is earned and the way it is spent. This industry has grown to be the second largest grey/illicit industry in the world, second only to the illicit drug trades. For young people in care and from care, this industry presents both a sustained risk for victimization and an incredibly accessible opportunity for making money as both perpetrators and victims.
Fourth, a great deal of new employment outside of minimum wage employment is unfolding within the broader context of the innovation economy, which, at least at the entry level, almost always means start-up digital companies seeking young people with digital skills and very flexible lifestyles. This presents opportunities for young people leaving care, but these are opportunities that are not at all nurtured through the care experience and the learning opportunities offered within it.
A fifth and final example is the ever-decreasing role of wage-based work in maintaining a sustainable lifestyle. In the new economies, it is rarely work that creates livable incomes; more commonly, it is investment, capital gains and passive income situations that generate livability. None of these processes are part of any of the work we do to prepare and support young people as they leave care.
There are many other examples of how changes in the global and local political economies are likely going to change the experience of leaving care. It is important to ask questions about how current policy and practice initiatives are in tune with such changes. We do have a long history of creating changes that are based on lived experiences from years long gone by. The point here is not to criticize what have been positive and useful initiatives on behalf of young people leaving care. But it is to reinforce that we cannot be complacent in our assessment of such policies. We should note, for example, that some aspects of the new economies impact very differently on particular groups of young people. Human trafficking and online sexual exploitation, for example, impact Black and Indigenous communities far more intensely and with greater consequences than other communities of young people. The digital opportunities presented through start-up companies have embedded within them significant barriers for the participation of young women. The value of post-secondary education is diminishing just as initiatives to further the participation of marginalized groups are accelerating (probably not a coincidence). For these reasons, it is good to remember that the positive and constructive policies that have emerged in recent years may not be useful for long and given the speed of change in the global political economy, pointing to such policies as proof that we are moving in the right direction may end up doing more harm than good.