CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 279 MAY 2022

How CYC Supervision Can Support Changing Practitioner Thinking

Jack Phelan

Practitioners who have mastered the skills of being a Competent Care Giver (Phelan, 2015) are now requiring a change in supervisory focus. The thinking style of this Level 1 practitioner has been developed without much theoretical influence, since most of the demands of becoming a competent care giver require common sense logic, built through on the job experience and a gradual development of competence in maintaining a pre-existing program of behavioral expectations. The focus of CYC practice for the initial 12-18 months of experience is behavior management and safety. The reliance on external motivation and controls to manage the events of the daily program have limited the scope of practice to assessing behavior change and adherence to goals that can be physically observed. The additional emphasis on becoming a caring, connected adult is usually seen as a less intrusive way to create compliance to program expectations. This type of practitioner is valued for his/her ability to keep good order and maintain a cooperative, relaxed environment when interacting with young people and families.

When external control and motivation based on adult approval is the focus of a practitioner’s efforts, his/her thinking is constrained by the limited scope of the treatment approach being utilized. Programs which measure success by the immediate behavioral changes in the young people and families ignore the fact that when the external environment is removed, the successful behaviors quickly disappear. Practitioners who have become highly successful at creating change through external motivation eventually become disillusioned as they see young people and families revert to familiar life strategies after discharge.

When a program is built on measuring the behavior change in the young people and families, expecting the behavior management tools employed will result in internal motivation to support future successful behavior, there is a critical flaw in the program design. When internal motivation to change is less important than merely creating behavioral shifts that may be very temporary, usually caused by the external environment, the carry over value of the positive program effects is minimal.

CYC practitioners at Level 1 expertise try to keep in touch with young people and families after discharge to continue to motivate them but get discouraged by their inability to be sufficiently influential, based on the need to focus on new people. When young people and families miss them after they are gone, it is seen as a successful connection, when it actually is a problem, because the presence of external motivation is still required.

CYC supervisors can support these competent care givers to change the way they think about CYC practice to enable them to develop more complex mental frameworks as they develop into Level 2 practitioners, treatment planners and change agents (Phelan, 2015).

The writing of Laura Steckly (2020) about Threshold Concepts and the thinking development model proposed by Heather Modlin (2014) will help explain the shift that is required for Level 1 practitioners to grow into more professionally complex change agents.

During Level 1 practitioner development, the “self” of the helper is a very important force in creating change. The Level 1 practitioner is very aware of how he/she is seen by the other person, trying to be personally appealing and creating a shared connection that is based on liking each other and being agreeable. The goal is to keep the connection strong by not having conflicts or differences of opinion. Level 1 practitioners try to insert themselves into the life space of others as role models to build successful life strategies and attitudes. This attempt to support change by creating an attractive role model is a flawed method, because most of our young people and families do not see us as realistic models to emulate in their actual non-program lives. The behaviors and attitudes we practice in front of them only work inside of our structured, mandated programs but will not be useful in their actual lives.

Modlin (2014) describes an adult thinking stage of “socialized thinking” which is characterized by looking outside oneself for approval and standards of correct behavior. This person is basing his personal value on how others respond to him and is uncomfortable with disagreements and differences. The Level 1 practitioner can function very competently while maintaining this thinking style. The goal of connecting is to get the young person or family to like me. However, to create longer lasting change, the goal of connecting should be to get the young person or family to like themselves, a more complex task which is the focus of a Level 2 practitioner.

CYC supervisors are an important support for this developmental journey because thinking about CYC practice now requires the introduction of Threshold Concepts (Steckley, 2020) and new ways of thinking about self. Supervisors can build more complex thinking processes through discussions based on how the practitioner thinks about what is happening, rather than focusing on measuring the behavior changes occurring in young people and families. CYC supervisors can assess the timing of efforts to support practitioners who are ready to learn new methods when they begin to question the usefulness of external motivation and behavioral change.

CYC supervision based on adult thinking styles will create the small steps of awareness to support Level 1 practitioners to move from socialized thinking toward self-authoring thinking (Modlin, 2014). The self-authoring thinker will more easily shift from thinking about “self” in practice as being personally attractive and now see the importance of supporting the young person or family to strengthen their own sense of self. Steckley (2020) describes the shift in thinking as troublesome, which means this new approach will be resisted initially, but that it is also irreversible and not easily abandoned once understood.  Supervision is helpful in the transition because it can make the troublesome journey more successfully negotiated.

More specific details about threshold concepts at Level 2 practice will be explored next month.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App