It has been an especially brutal winter with the usual sub-zero temperatures but twice the usual snowfall. February was a continuous string of blizzards with blowing snow adding to the existing by a few inches or so each time out. There literally was no place to put the snow. The city gave up plowing the walks. And then finally the break came and above zero temperatures brought a respite. I had to go downtown for an appointment passing the boarded-up flagship store of the Hudson’s Bay department store just short of its centennial. Founded in 1670 and established across the land in every capital; the Bay fell victim to changing times, online and outlet shopping and the pandemic. Back in student days it was the back yard to our downtown campus, a place to shop, to eat and to pass through. As I walked along, I noticed most of what were once vibrant businesses were now shuttered and empty. I learned theft was a huge contributor as a frame store which had been a fixture of the core forever had to leave as the theft was so aggressive and constant. A major big box office supply store suffered the same fate. Meanwhile in the back lanes car after car was becoming stuck due to the melting snowpack. This went on for block after block appearing most desperate and alarming. The next day was the first day of spring and quite suddenly this dust up blew up on the social media page of the small village I and many others summer in. The page acts like a party line with local news, lost dog reports and sales of vintage items. Suddenly there was a series of posts, some 61 in all by roughly a dozen contributors that came up, were finally caught by the administrator who closed further posts and edited the balance. Those used here in italics demonstrate that the not in my backyard movement is alive and well even in resort villages. The column looks at the NIMBY syndrome as it can apply to child and youth residential care.
Early in my career I and our group home were the victims of such discrimination and the power of some to force moving to a new location. The unit was sited quite well on a unique lane leading to back lane to a street with an avenue out front and a graveyard out back. Tucked into the blind corner was the home of a local town counsel woman. The property had a garage that blocked her property totally while fronting on the lane. We never used it as there was ample parking for the team. Now the girls did use the space behind the garage to smoke, chat and gather with friends and siblings from the neighbourhood usually until they were called in. They were cautioned to keep things quiet and did so for the most part and our first winter came and went. Suddenly, the counsellor roared up in protest having placed a motion to remove the group home from its location due to the constant noise and cigarette butts in the lane. In the mid 70’s therapeutic group care was new, novel and unknown. My supervisor and agency attempted to use the newspapers to educate the public with interviews with all involved. The youth did not get it as they were not aware of harming anyone. Unlike the adults many were aware of moving a lot and often due to discrimination. It just was unfair and legal after the town council voted to deny the group home permission to reside there. We moved across town to a large lot on a quiet street after consulting with neighbours and their town council for a genuine welcome.
Some 50 years on and after 15 wonderful summers in the village the following post popped up:
I got woke up this morning at 2am because my dog was going crazy at the front door. I got up to look out the door window and stared right into the face of an ugly woman with black hair. None of my neighbors match that description so I assume she's from the group home that promised there would be no problems in town. Everyone make sure your doors are always locked and get good security cameras.
Group home remains a hot word for me to this day and like many I was unaware of a group home in the village and this complainant was outing its street address online. It took seconds to use maps to find the home, a three-story country home that had been a family’s passion for many years. It was surrounded by humble traditional three season cottages. I was aware the village council wanted to expand its tax base by attracting more business. Several members of my last group care team had cottages in the area, one having operated a therapeutic foster care home. They had situations of property damage and theft over the years but always within the family. Child and youth care folks appreciate the outdoor life, the quiet life and a respect of boundaries – all things the village provided in spades.
The third post was most welcome and came within moments:
I am a staff in the group home. A couple things. Firstly, you’ve assumed wrong that it was one of our youths as all of them were home last night. Secondly, you should be extremely ashamed of yourself for making that assumption solely based on your ignorant views about group homes, and the individuals that live in them. Stop being ignorant. Stop being discriminatory. If you don’t know, don’t assume.
All individuals in group homes are just like you and I. Their Brain just functions a bit differently. I’m a huge advocate for individuals like this. Sometimes they don’t understand what Societal norms are and that’s why we are there supporting them. Thank you for all that you do for these individuals.
Another group home supervisor soon jumped in:
I’ve run group homes for years. I understand what’s involved and what they are required to complete if this was the case. Should that individual have been from the group home, it needs to be reported immediately. I don’t care if the person is upset that there is a group home in the community, they need to have respect because ANYONE could easily end up in this situation.
Another post totally illustrated the ignorance, fear, discrimination and resulting anger that often drives the NIMBY movement:
Just a heads up, @ 1:30am Saturday Morning, March 19/2022. We had a woman walk right up to our front door peering in. (She was described as native wearing dark clothing. We are unsure if there were more people involved…. Our dog went ballistic, and the woman took off running down the Ave. (Police were called. ) Next time I’m letting the dog out after her. Let’s see how she does against an 80-pound guard dog chasing her. I have already had 3 of my car door handles broken because of these WASTE OF SPACE LOSERS and am completely fed up … KARMA WILL BITE YOU IN THE A** if you come around here again and I mean that literally!!!!
Over my time I’ve only had one similar interruption when my neighbour’s girlfriend chose 1:00 am to knock on my door to ask if she could take the lawnmower I was throwing out. Jarring yet a genuine and very polite question. The way the group home spoke up to report it could not be their youth so quickly and with an attempt at education was commendable. That it was echoed by another was a welcome surprise. If only we had similar support back in the day. The original complainant could not resist a retort on the fuss he or she set off:
Well, my post did exactly what I intended it to do. An awareness of what is happening here, and that people need to have their guard up. The comments were awesome, I think even the girl that peeked at me through the window said I shouldn't have called her ugly! I love this community and if I see anything negative that will affect me or my neighbors living a peaceful life here, I will let my voice be heard!
Again, this person spoke for everyone without intending to. We all want a peaceful life and a safe one. In the city it is often just understood you mind your own business and welcome involvement when it is necessary or polite. For safety you build a stockade around your property. In the country being open to landscape is prized yet the exposure can cause anxiety. People are seeking peace and quiet and most agree on this so there is a hypersensitivity to the unknown or unfamiliar.
Of course, the ultimate NIMBY conflict is taking place in the Ukraine as Russia has decided to inflict genocide on their literal kin. Deliberate executions, carpet bombing of civilian residential areas and the displacement of over 4 million citizens are now in our digital backyard as modern media allow for that. Similar behaviour with labelling of the other, discrimination but with a level of anger and terrorism no one should have to live with. The photo at the top is of our backyard at the village. Much of it was cleared, each stone and rock removed from the land which has been tilled and enriched by immigrants from the Ukraine who honed such skills over the centuries. Note the colors, the blue and yellow, the colours of joy. May this terror end with a mutual reproachment, an agreement to let the Ukraine be a Sovern and free nation. Live and let live. As a post war baby boomer who practiced peace and reconciliation much of his life, witnessing this fall back to Medieval times the personal shock is similar to that of the Ukrainians who endure horrors I can only imagine. Why the world dithers is beyond me.