For some time now, we have been hearing about a looming mental health crisis amongst young people and the pandemic has certainly rendered these predictions much more ubiquitous. Many people have argued that this crisis is not just looming but has in fact been well established for some years. Studies have shown that nearly 50% of high school students across many North American jurisdictions are impacted by a diagnosed or diagnosable mental health challenge, often within the spectrum of anxiety-related challenges, but also including mood disorders and other challenges. Our responses to these observations have been at best weak, and some might say have totally missed the mark. Nevertheless, schools, postsecondary institutions and other sectors have been investing in mental health services, counselling facilities, peer support models, and other measures to try and mitigate the impact of this crisis. It is hard to say whether any of these efforts will be successful, but it seems clear that whatever investments have been made, these are almost certainly inadequate. In postsecondary institutions, waitlists for counselling services are very long and getting longer, crisis responses are hit and miss and sometimes non-existent, and there continues to be a significant reliance on referring students to private sector services, with relatively low uptake.
Of note in all of this is that we appear to be uncritically accepting that what we are witnessing is a mental health crisis in need of intervention. Within this frame of reference, the young people experiencing anxiety and mood disorders are the problem, and our responsibility is to provide institutional services to address this problem. It is not hard to see how we have bought into medical models of service in this context. These kinds of approaches could, in my view, learn something from child and youth care practice.
I wonder sometimes whether the increased prevalence of anxiety we are seeing in young people actually is a mental health challenge, or at the very least, I wonder whose mental health challenge we are witnessing. A different way of understanding these challenges is to see them as entirely realistic and well-founded concerns about the threats posed by existing systems, institutions, processes and ways of being together. Anxiety may be one of the last remaining indicators of excellent mental health and rational thought, and our young people may indeed by the holders of knowledge and intuition we need to take much more seriously.
The issue of masses of young people (students in secondary and postsecondary institutions) experiencing significant challenges functioning according to and conforming to the norms of the institution reminds me of a similar issue in group homes and often foster care settings. We know that there are moments in those settings where many young people simply run away (go AWOL), sometimes taking much of the group with them. Many group homes respond much like schools, colleges and universities respond. They label the running away as a problem that sits with the young people themselves and develop ever tighter surveillance and intervention systems to ‘fix’ the problem. Sometimes, young people are made to see the psychiatrist after running away repeatedly from their foster home or group home.
In other group homes, the response is quite different. Once a pattern emerges in which young people run away often and en masse, staff start asking questions about their own program and its disconnection from the needs and desires of the young people residing there. They wonder about what they (the staff) are doing wrong such that young people don’t want to be there. And often, they even ask the young people why they run away, why they don’t want to be there, and what needs to happen to make staying at the group home a more attractive (and safer) proposition than running away. Then they take action to make their group home a better place, one that young people might find sufficiently attractive to stick around.
In a way, this process mirrors the dynamics of ever-increasing anxiety amongst young people. We have long taken the position to empathize with anxiety, and to offer accommodations and counselling services in an effort to make the existing setting one that feels fine for the young people. I am not sure this is the right approach, nor am I convinced that our settings as they are will, or even should, ever feel fine for young people. Anxiety may be an expression of realistic and quite accurate assessments of the threats posed to young people by our settings. For example, anxiety about grading in schools and postsecondary institutions is well founded. The process is largely arbitrary, in that it assesses learning based on depersonalized standards that render the learner unimportant. It is easy to be made to feel stupid in that context, or less than others, or simply not competent. The degree of social control imposed by institutions of all sorts, ranging from schools, to hospitals, to recreational clubs and even private settings such as shopping malls largely negates opportunities to be oneself. Security forces are never far away and being labeled a security threat has become rather frequent and easy. Climate change and the lack of meaningful response to this existential threat really is catastrophic from a young person’s perspective and renders questionable whether adult decision-makers and persons of influence can be trusted. Ongoing violence in the forms of war, rebellions, occupations, and policing rightfully raise young people’s anxieties about their personal and their collective safety.
I could go on listing the virtually infinite ways in which the social contexts young people find themselves in are inadequate, unsafe, harmful and often dismissive of them and who they strive to be. Examples of dehumanizing activities, not only directed against young people but in society more generally, abound. Young people watch and see what we do to the elderly – they can readily see the abuse and neglect that we knowingly impose on especially poor elders stuffed into care homes where they are largely abandoned. Young people can see that it is easy to be forgotten in this world, to be dismissed as lacking value, and to be violated in terms of rights and entitlements. And they can readily see how easy it is to end up getting blamed for the challenges that this gives rise to.
This is a good time to be anxious. Young people are quite right in expressing their misgivings about the world we have created through anxiety and mood disorders. They are not the problem. It is time, I think, for us to ask about our own mental health. In what world is it considered healthy to destroy one’s life setting? To kill others in the name of a maniac’s narcissistic self-image? To protect structures of racism, misogyny, transphobia, ableism, and other forms of exclusion and violence? If these things don’t make us anxious, then whose mental health should we be questioning?