Human rights including the rights of children exist for the purposes of supporting human dignity and advancing respect of human beings. But how can the language of rights be used to justify problematic actions?
Rights are compromised by widespread misunderstandings of what some individuals and groups understand as their “rights” as the following two anecdotes briefly illustrate.
There was a boy who was defacing the exterior wall of the store and when an adult questioned what he was doing, he said: “I can do what I want. I have rights, you know?”
Thousands of protesters immobilized Ottawa, Canada in late January through February, claiming that their rights and freedoms were compromised by COVID-19 public health measures (Tasker, 2022). Some city residents were attacked physically and verbally for wearing face masks and many, many others were subjected to non-stop harmful truck diesel fumes and incessant horn-honking day and night (Hogan, 2022). After three weeks, police warned that the protest had to end or individuals would be arrested. Many protesters then placed their children (including very young children in strollers/pushchairs) between themselves and hundreds of police, raising concerns about their safety and the use of children as “human shields” (Carbert, 2022). One 11-year-old who was involved said that it was both fun and scary when the police were using force and pushing to dispel protested; she enunciated that was fighting for her “rights and freedoms” (wlctv.ca, 2022).
These two examples illustrate particular understanding of rights and freedoms that are inconsistent with their goals and intentions to advance human dignity and “the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world” as outlined in the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child’s (1989) preamble. These anecdotes are problematic for at least two reasons. First, they reflect incorrect understandings of what rights are. Second, they create and propagate additional misconceptions of what rights are as well as foster resistance to the rights framework. To be clear, the freedom of expression or the right to protest is not unlimited and these specific rights do not exist in isolation from other rights or people. These aforementioned claims attempt to justify one’s actions with willful disregard for their impacts upon others, reflecting a self-centred, self-serving approach, which is the antithesis of rights.
We must also resist the common tendency to focus on one right to the exclusion of others. For example, child protection is a key priority around the world but protection practices tend to ignore children’s right to participate including in crisis contexts as Stoffel and Kreyscher (2022) explore. Reporting from the Polish border to support Ukrainian refugees for instance, Cuevas-Parra (2022) outlines how participation informs other rights including protection and provision. This does not mean that child and youth participation should be the only priority. It is possible that some children chose to participate and may think that it is fun to be placed in front of their caregivers before a large group of police. However, placing (or forcing?) children to serve as barriers against police is extremely problematic when considering the other human rights of these young people. Education about children’s rights is a human right in itself and the spectrum of other rights including to respect must also be upheld.
Rights may be a convenient tool for some at particular times or circumstances, but rights do not exist for such expedience. This means that a young person should not do whatever he wants to do no matter the damage that it causes to others merely because it is his “right”. Moreover, truckers cannot demand “freedom” from mask and vaccine mandates, and at the same time subject thousands of residents to harm and trauma. The rights framework and language should not be instrumentalized and manipulated in this way to suit and serve one’s individual agenda or preferences. Further, we must recognize and respect how our rights and freedoms are interconnected with others. This is evident in the existence of public health measures that exist to support community health and people who live in it with particular concern for those who are most vulnerable including those who are immunocompromised.
It may be nice to interact with others without a mask, but Buck (2022) describes that her 12- and 13-year-old sons understand that the face “mask is a negligible price to pay for – yes, truckers – freedom: freedom from illness and freedom to live a relatively normal life under abnormal circumstances.” They appreciate that: “Masks don’t really have a downside and COVID has several.”
Human rights are important even if they are disregarded and inconsistently understood. The rights framework is the global response to support understanding of human priorities and the legitimacy of our arguments against violence and other infringements upon human life. They provide a framework to support respect of human beings and our efforts to make things better. The human rights framework can support the work of Child and Youth Care practitioners and other professionals and caregivers who focus on children, youth, and their families.
Even if you have a priority or favourite right, remember that it must be understood and implemented in relation to other rights and other people – young and older. As relational practice is essential to CYC, it is also critical to understanding and respecting children’s rights.
References
Carbert, M. (2022, Feb 19). Safety of children a top concern as police move to end demonstrations. The Globe and Mail, A13.
Cuevas-Parra, P. (2022). A plea from the Polish border: protect Ukraine's children. World Vision International, retrieved from https://www.wvi.org/opinion/view/plea-polish-border-protect-ukraines-children (Accessed April 29, 2022).
Hogan, S. (2022, Feb. 19). The Ottawa convoy has 'shattered norms' for protest in Canada. Will we see more of it? CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/trucker-freedom-convoy-new-normal-1.6355574 (Accessed March 27, 2022).
Stoffel, S., Kreyscher, K. (2022). Children as agents in crises: re-assessing adult-child power dynamics in humanitarian action. Humanitarian Alternatives. https://alternatives-humanitaires.org/en/2022/03/25/children-as-agents-in-crises-re-assessing-adult-child-power-dynamics-in-humanitarian-action/ (Accessed April 27, 2022).
Tasker, J.P. (2022, Jan. 29). Thousands opposed to COVID-19 rules converge on Parliament Hill. CBC News. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/truck-convoy-protest-some-key-players-1.6332312 (Accessed March 27, 2022).
United Nations (UN). (1989). ‘Convention on the Rights of the Child’, 20 November, UN Doc. A/RES/44/25.
wlctv.ca (2022, Feb. 18). 11yr old shares her #FreedomConvoy2022 experience, https://twitter.com/wlctv_ca/status/1494835469195960321