Rage is the only language
I have left
Charles Blow
In both CYC and in the broader dominant society, I find that we don’t seem very comfortable with anger. With some degree of legitimacy, we find anger frightening. Justifiably, we perceive anger as having the capacity to destroy or significantly harm the objects of its wrath, which may include ourselves, our relationships, our equilibrium, our property, and so on. As a result, to the degree possible, we tend to marginalize anger. When we do legitimize it, we often do so on the way to another set of emotions. Often, we treat an anger as an illegitimate by product of other more palatable expressions of our pain. We prefer trauma, hurt, and fear over anger and we look for them under the surface. We turn the attention of the angry person towards these “underlying” emotions as quickly as possible.
There is a scene at the very end of the series the Watchmen in which the Black grandfather, Will Reeves, who is the 100 year old survivor of innumerable racially inflected traumas beginning with surviving the Tulsa massacre of 1921, talks to his granddaughter Angela about their joint history as masked vigilantes. For both of them, the wearing of a mask was a necessity to hide their Blackness, because White society would never accept a Black vigilante crime fighter.
Pamela Willenborg in her analysis of the series unpacks this relationship between masks, trauma, violence, and anger and concludes about the final scene,
trauma cannot be exorcised by brutality, and wounds that are hidden can never heal. While the battle with Trieu rages, Will returns to the Dreamland theater, where his nightmare began—but he stays out of the fighting and only seeks to protect children who have also survived the murder of their parents. He explains to Angela what he has come to realize: He didn’t use the mask out of anger, but out of “fear…and hurt.” This is what finally gets Angela to break down and cry, and what he says next is the poignant logical conclusion to what began in the graphic novel: “You can’t heal under a mask, Angela. Wounds need air.” Every ugly thing must be brought into the light, mourned, and soothed, whether it is personal, historical, or cultural.
For many, if not most of us, the logic of this analysis rings true. Trauma cannot be resolved through vengeful acts of brutality and destruction. It can only be healed through bringing the traumatic events into our conscious awareness where they can approached rationally and their effects diffused through the application of even handed justice, or failing that, the healing that can be found in forgiveness and letting go of the past. Trauma should not be hidden or denied. Our fear and hurt are real and need to be acknowledged as legitimate so that we can move forward. Anger has no legitimate place here. It is only a transitional emotion that can open passageways to the more authentic pain and fear that anger masks.
This description of the path to healing is comforting at some level. It speaks to the necessity we feel to bring resolution to traumatic events. In another way, it is reassuring to think that the trauma and anger that have resulted from social actions, for which we may well hold some accountability, will come to a close. At some point, we hope that we won’t have to keep looking over our shoulder to see if those who have suffered, so that we can live well, are bringing their anger to us.
This is, of course, the anxiety of those who have benefited from the social and political practices of white supremacy, misogyny, xenophobia, heterosexism, and class warfare against working people. Living in a world economy premised in exploitation and myriad forms of enslavement, means living in an environment saturated with trauma, rage, and grief. There are people suffering death and indignity on a daily basis, so that others can live a lifestyle of privilege.
For such a social configuration, immeasurable anger is always just outside the door. It saturates our collective sense of who we are and what we fear. Of course, anger has degrees of intensity, from an ongoing sense of irritation at the infinitude of small acts of degradation, to rage when those acts culminate in acts of violence that cannot be denied. Of course, rage is all around us in the lived experience of individuals, but these can be denied by pathologizing or even empathizing with those who are angry. They need to resolve their issues we say. Anger is unhealthy and inappropriate. We feel bad for their trauma and grief, but the anger needs find resolution. And so, when rage boils over into civil unrest, rioting, looting, and mayhem, it is somehow both surprising to us as a society and unacceptable. But, in promoting this way of thinking about anger, are we refusing a certain of accountability? By focusing on trauma, fear, and grief and not legitimizing rage, are we profoundly misunderstanding our situation?
When I think of the young people I have worked with over the years who were deeply angry, I wonder if I ever really understood what I was witness to. Like most in CYC, I wanted them to be less angry. I wanted them to access their trauma and grief; to burst into tears and release the pent up anger so that its toxicity would not poison their lives with violence. I have to wonder though, whether that was for them, or for me. How much of a role did my anxiety play in my need for young people to be less angry? How much of our talk of safe spaces derives from our own fear of anger (perhaps even our own?)
Of course, I am not suggesting that we stand back while angry young people attack each other, the staff, and destroy our facilities. I am suggesting that less of that might be a threat if we found ways to acknowledge the depth and legitimacy of rage in ourselves and the young people we encounter in our work. I think sometimes, that when young people enter our programs, we draw a line in their lives that says “your new life begins here.” We imply that what happened before is just your history and that needs to be brought to resolution and left behind. You are in a safe place now and time begins anew.
But this is a lie and a travesty. What brought them to our attention doesn’t stop. Just because we don’t engage in the kinds of violence, degradation, and violence they have experienced, doesn’t mean that it stopped happening. They know that and they know that when they leave our care, their world will resume and that while they may have changed at some level, their world has not. I will leave aside the fact that our programs are full of acts of aggression and microaggression on the part of workers and other adults they encounter while with us. The point is that the assaults on them and those they love continues, and as long as that happens, any attempt to resolve the trauma is battlefield triage at best. And if the battle still rages and it is only a matter of time before it engulfs those who have taken brief respite. We need to ask ourselves, what about the ongoing trauma and pain; what about the anger?
Agnes Callard notes that just because harm has been reduced or eliminated, the anger resulting from that harm has no obvious end point. At what point is it reasonable to move on and let it go. Is it when one is safe from the harm, pain, and fear? And for those of us living in a political and cultural environment where there is no obvious end in sight, how and when do we let it go? After all anger can be protective in a world hostile to one’s very existence. Elizabeth Bruening writing about the recent Chauvin conviction in a piece entitled “Chauvin was Convicted but Something is Still Very Wrong” states,
But when do we let go, when do we know it’s time to move on, and what does that mean when emotions — which should not be dismissed as irrelevant to politics — are in play? Or can these feelings issuing from echoing loss be transmuted — and if so, into what, by whom? How do we ever know when it’s time to stop seeking restoration for harm, and do we stop because it’s the right thing to do, or because after a point it’s no use searching for, longing for things that aren’t going to come?
The question of who gets to decide when anger is no longer appropriate is a key one for those of us in the business of ostensibly being helpful to others. Do we as CYC workers get to say anger needs to find resolution? Do we get to decide when the desire for vengeance is inappropriate? Are we in the anger management business or the practice of relational care? I would suggest that they are very different. How are we to assess the depth of damage done and to tell someone else, that is enough? These are challenging questions and strike at the heart of our work as relational. Relational work doesn’t function without accountability and accountability to harm done includes entering angry spaces without judgement.
Of course, this is all tangled up with power relations. Anger as the result of trauma premised in a loss of privilege and dominance is a very different set of coordinates from anger premised in being the object of dominant aggression. Abusive relationships premised in patriarchal assertions of masculinist privilege must be radically distinguished from the anger that can arise on the behalf of women and children subject to such abuse. The anger experienced by those in positions of dominance and control, when confronted with defiance, is inherently fascistic and reactionary, while the anger and rage asserted by those fighting for greater degrees of freedom and autonomy, is an assertions of a desire to live more fully. This is why the violence engaged in by reactionary right-wing militias is not the same as the violence engaged in by Antifa or people of color. When we conflate the two and insist on peace at all costs, we are bypassing an opportunity to be politically accountable to the social trauma in which we are all complicit. To equate the rage and violence of the abuser/oppressor with the violence of the abused/oppressed is an act of re-traumatization. It is to perpetuate the trauma that led to the rage and violence in the first place. It is to confirm the worst fear of those expressing their rage on the street, and that is that their struggle has no legitimacy and that they are in some very real sense invisible.
And there are so many invisible bodies. By invisible, I don’t mean that they don’t appear across all forms of media. Indeed, they do; the bodies being traumatized at the U.S./Mexico border, the parade of black bodies shot to death, the bodies of mass shooting after mass shooting, the bodies struggling to breath in India, the indigenous bodies being slaughtered in Brazil, the women’s bodies being sexually assaulted and murdered all over the world, the trans bodies being savagely murdered, the bodies killed through suicide and drug overdoses, the bodies dying in deserts, oceans, and rivers while trying to migrate, and the bodies dying of preventable diseases all over the planet. This is not an exhaustive list. There are many more bodies on display on our daily newsfeed. So why would I say they are invisible?
They are invisible because the display of this slaughter day after day, has failed to halt it in any meaningful way. It is as if we didn’t see them. As if they didn’t register as information that we need to pay attention to. Gregory Bateson used to say that communication is information that makes a difference. If that is the case, then the display of these bodies is failing to communicate. It is as though they aren’t really there. They might as well be invisible because they don’t appear to making a difference.
We in CYC are resoundingly familiar with this dynamic. The young people in our work are invisible in the same kinds of ways. We keep care of an apparently never-ending stream of young people arriving from traumas without surcease. And their pain and fear seems endless and also doesn’t seem to communicate in any meaningful way to a world that seems largely indifferent to their suffering. Of course, the bodies that I am referring to on the global scale and those we encounter in our work are not really different. They are the same and the anger we encounter in our work with them is the anger derived from unresolved, bottomless, global, endless, and ongoing trauma.
In a recent New York Times opinion piece, Charles M. Blow, writes about his reaction to the ongoing shooting of unarmed Black people in the U.S. He enumerates his profound frustration and anger as he witnesses death after death after death. And he says,
This has produced in me and many others an inextinguishable rage, a calcification of contempt. As for me, I no longer even attempt to manage or direct my rage. I simply sit with it, face it like an adversary staring across a campfire, waiting to see how I am moved to act, but not proscribing that action and definitely not allowing society’s idea of decorum to proscribe it. A society that treats this much Black death at the hands of the state as collateral damage in a just war on crime has no decorum to project. That society is savage.
It is this savage society that we encounter daily in our work. Franz Fanon is reputed to have said that western psychotherapy was designed to assist the oppressed to live more comfortably with oppression. I can only hope that CYC is not designed to do the same. Because if we using our good work to attempt to smooth over the trauma of living in a savage society that is hostile to the very people we serve, then we will reap the whirlwind of the trauma we continue to perpetuate.