CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 267 MAY 2021

Wither the Program

Kiaras Gharabaghi

For many years I have been wondering whether the idea of ‘programs’ is a useful idea in the context of child and youth care practice. It’s an odd thing to wonder about; much of my professional career has unfolded in programs, including residential programs, day treatment programs, in-patient hospital-based programs or programs associated with youth homelessness and youth criminal justice. Even in the community, child and youth care practice still largely unfolds in the context of programs – learning programs, outdoor and adventure education and therapeutic programs, social skills programs, anger management programs, therapeutic group programs and many more. Most child and youth care post-secondary training programs in fact offer at least one course that is called something like ‘program development’, in which students are explicitly taught how to develop a program, implement it and evaluate it or measure its outcomes. In all of this, we rarely ask the question “what is a program”?

Some years ago, I wrote a column called De-Programming Kids (https://cyc-net.org/cyc-online/cyconline-mar2009-gharabaghi.html). In it, I made the case that there is something rather destructive and de-humanizing about thinking of young people as elements of a program. I still maintain this thought to this very day. A program is a set of boundaries, imposed by its designers, and constructed in relation to a wide set of factors that include employment factors, cultural factors, organizational factors and others. These boundaries, much more so than any of the practices that unfold within them, determine the assessment and therapeutic intervention content experienced by young people. But they do much more than that; these boundaries determine the limits of possibility, and ultimately the designation of truth. No sooner does a young person join a program, the program itself begins to place judgment on the appropriateness of the young person’s presence within it. This has given us such memorable phrases as “this young person doesn’t fit the program” or “they make the program unsafe” or even phrases such as “the program schedule”, “the program rules or policies and procedures”, and “the program structure”. My personal favourite is the phrase “program expectations”, which is applied both in service settings and in post-secondary education settings.

Programs are primarily instrumental in nature. They facilitate doing something such that we can identify what we are doing in relation to a particular structure. We fear, I think, that without a program, we might not know whether we are actually doing something. For example, imagine sitting in a park and observing a number of young people playing basketball. Without a program, we are sitting in a park just watching young people play a game. In the context of a program, we are supervising the youth on a program outing to the park. We are not actually doing anything different, but we construct our activity differently in relation to how we are connected to the young people playing basketball. In the first case, we are not connected at all; in the second case, we are a staff member of a program to which the young people belong. This is already problematic. Why do we see ourselves as not connected to the young people at all if we are not there as part of a program outing to the park? Are we not connected through our presence in the park? Or our membership in the community? Or a mutual interest in basketball? Or perhaps we are even connected through the environment and its care for all of us. As a person sitting in the park and as youth playing basketball, we are sustained by the same air, the same soil, the same winds and spirits that may be present. We are also connected through our unfamiliarity with other people in the park, known to neither us nor the youth. It seems to me that overwhelmingly our connections, that is the connection between I, sitting in the park and the youth playing basketball in the park, is exactly as it would be if both I and the youth were part of the program.

Our need for programs is far more consequential than simply the need for structure, rules, policies and procedures. We need the program to feel connected to young people. The very concept of relational practices relies on the presence of a program, since it would be hard to engage in relational practices when we don’t feel connected to young people we encounter and we see ourselves as doing nothing in particular. Within the context of the program, we are doing something: we are supervising youth playing basketball, which is very much part of relational practices in program language.

I have been thinking about this because of multiple experiences during the current pandemic with child and youth care practitioners questioning the point of their programs. This has been particularly the case in residential and day treatment settings, which are perhaps amongst the more structured and pre-programmed settings among programs. The problem is that practitioners are questioning the point of their programs not because they are thinking about the relevance of programs in the lives of the young people these programs are meant to serve. Instead, their questions are driven by the very low enrolment numbers in their programs during this pandemic, sometimes as low as one or two young people. They are furthermore questioning the value of their programs because they are unable to implement the pre-pandemic program routines due to the need for social distancing and other measures taken to mitigate the spread of COVID-19. In other words, the programs were designed to serve groups of young people. With only one or two young people in those programs, what is really compromised is not the well-being of the young people, but the familiarity of connection with young people in relation to the program. Child and youth care practitioners have been programmed to think of connection in relation to the program, and when that program no longer functions as a program, the capacity to meaningfully connect with young people is diminished. Also diminished is the capacity of the program to render judgment upon the young people because the program itself faces an existential crisis. If it questions the legitimacy of the young person’s presence in the program, it may end up with no young people at all, which would render it superfluous. Suddenly, the terms of hierarchy have shifted. The program needs the young person, regardless of whether the young person needs the program. At the same time, the program can no longer function as a program per se, leaving practitioners confused about whether or not they are actually doing something.

All of this makes me wonder about the impact of programs in the development of child and youth care practice as a field primarily concerned about relationships, care and presence. It seems to me that there are at least two things that we might consider in greater depth during this pandemic and afterwards. First, how much of our practice can exist outside of programs and how much of our practice is really just an instrument of ‘program’ as a euphemism for our professional ethos? And second, what possibilities are we removing from child and youth care practice in our reliance on programs for providing the boundaries within which we work?

I think the first question is important because it speaks to the extent to which our practice actually is an autonomous practice. By that I mean the extent to which our practice is more than the implementation of program expectations, routines, structures and policies and procedures. But I think it is in the second question where we need to explore the limits of what is possible so long as we construct our practice within the confines of programs. Given that programs themselves are constructed in the context of much larger social, political and economic structures, all of which are deeply embedded in the march of neoliberal divestment of not-for-profit relationships (such as most human connections), are conversations about anti-racism, decolonizing practices, inclusion, equity and care pipe dreams that can’t ever happen?

The big question: Can we live without programs? Can we live in community and feel connected because we live in community? Can living in community be doing something? Can child and youth care still be a human endeavor, or are we lost to the already emerging programmatic elimination of relational anything? 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App