I’ve written about the Scottish Residential Child Care Workers’ Association (SRCCWA) in a previous column, as has Mark Smith. I’d like to revisit it this month, as it has been a year now since we first came together (and because I’m doing a bit of spring recycling). During that first meeting when 50 of us came together to explore the possibility of forming an association, I felt a strong sense of community. The connection was immediate – it always is when I’m with fellow ‘ressies’ and this is because the passion for and dedication to the work of residential child care makes us kindred spirits.
So while this shared passion and dedication already made us something of a community, the conception of the SRCCWA brings with it the powerful potential for us to create a vibrant community of practice. A community of practice, put simply, is a collection of people who are united not only by membership in a group but by a shared activity. Within the group, knowledge and meaning are collectively created.
Most of us are involved, in varying degrees, in communities of practice already, whether or not we label them as such. Depending on the culture of your workplace, it also may be legitimately called a community of practice – colleagues, united by the activity of caring for children and young people, who talk with each other and the kids to make meaning in a way that shapes and defines the work.The way we (staff, kids, managers, external managers) come together and make sense of, make meaning about, define and evolve our understanding of what it is we’re doing (or attempting to do), together, with the kids in our care – the way we do all this is influenced by many factors: our own histories, the histories of our workplaces, the current cultures of our units, the dynamics between us, and the spaces we create, maintain and protect in order to reflect and be in open, candid dialogue with one another.
There is also a wider context that influences the way we make meaning of the work (and hence, the way we do the work). The quality of the meanings we make and the work we do, then, is not only affected by what we bring but what gets fed into those reflective (or unreflective) spaces. Some of what gets fed in can enhance our understandings, helping us to evolve our practice. Some of it is misguided and uninformed, holding us back – or worse. Yet, we are the ones who make the meaning, even if we do so unconsciously and without reflection.
So what does this all have to do with the SRCCWA? Well, the more we come together to share our wisdom, experience and acquired knowledge, the more quality gets fed into our small communities of practice in our own places of work. The SRCCWA has the capacity to become a large, vibrant community of practice that is stronger due to the breadth and diversity of its members. We can more powerfully make meanings that promote healing, transformative practice; we can also better scrutinise and reject those practices (and the meanings behind them) that are misinformed and counterproductive. In addition to, or more likely through the process of making meaning about the work, communities of practice can nurture, fortify, energise and inspire, making us more resilient in our collective efforts to develop and enhance the development of others.
When we encounter such supportive environments that enable truly meaningful practice, we experience a love of the work that Primo Levi refers to above. Sometimes, however, the job is not loveable and far too often this is due to the wider context within which we struggle to do the work (rather than the difficulties we encounter in direct practice). Policies, procedures and attitudes, misinformed by meanings carried by those who do not have adequate experience and wisdom, have created conditions that make the work less meaningful and less loveable. At worst, we have had reasons to hate the job and feel helpless to do anything about it (other than leave). The time is ripe to begin to effect bigger changes.
So not only can the SRCCWA become force of enhancement, it can begin to effect meanings on a larger scale, developing and evolving the way practice in residential child care is made sense of in Scotland (and internationally) while scrutinising and rejecting those uninformed, counterproductive meanings that continue to influence what we do and how we do it.
And this is exactly what Drath and Palus1 argue for in a book they wrote about communities of practice back in the 90’s. While the authors aren’t writing about residential child care, it felt like they were directly addressing this opportunity we have before us, so pregnant with potential. Essentially they argue that, rather than seeing leadership as something held by people in positions of authority, it is better understood as meaning making in communities of practice. That is their definition of leadership – meaning making in communities of practice. And I like to think of the SRCCWA evolving into a powerful leader in our sector.
Notes
1. Making Common Sense: Leadership as Meaning-making in a Community of Practice by Wilfred H. Drath and Charles J. Palus. (1994)