The most useful ideas are ones which can be simply stated, easily visualized, and lead to more complex thinking. Child and Youth Care work is practiced in the life space of both the practitioner and the people he/she is supporting, which is a place of straightforward, simple realities. Mark Krueger calls it “lunch ideas”.
CYC practice, when it is done well, is both developmental and relational. That is, it requires an understanding of the ability and social maturity of the other person and it also requires a safe mutuality between both people usually developed slowly through a process of trust building and caring on the part of the Child and Youth Care practitioner.
It is very hard to learn how to think developmentally, because it requires you to stop assuming that others think the same way that you do. Complex descriptions such as “meaning making” are built on the basic task of thinking developmentally. An example may help: every child between 2 and 5 years old thinks like a sociopath, not able to care for anyone but himself, yet we do not label them as such, we see it as a developmental stage that will change as they mature. When we are confronted by a teenager who is stuck in the developmental processes of a three-year-old, it is not easy to think developmentally and support her to move forward into four and five-year-old thinking, we often see pathology instead.
When the two-year-old shouts “NO” to every request, we are mildly challenged, but see it as a developmental stage that is not going to be helped by fining him a dollar every time he does this, yet we often deal with profanity (an immature teen’s way of saying NO) in this way.
The basic difference between people who need life space interventions, an intense method of treatment, and people who can be helped by once a week therapeutic conversations and more rigorous expectations, is developmental. The less socially aware and mature you are, the more developmental support you need.
Simply put, people who are developmentally stuck at lower stages are more ego-centric and unsafe in the world. We have no problem thinking about young children this way, but it requires skill and training to think about teens and adults this way.
So where does relational practice fit into this?
Skilled Child and Youth Care practitioners know that there is no opportunity for change and growth without building a safe relationship first. Yet this relationship alone does not create real change, even when sometimes it creates imitative behaviour, which was described 40 years ago by Larry Brendtro as a form of role-modelling. Using relational approaches to focus on behavioural change is not really helpful, unless there is a developmental shift also occurring.
Creating a safe relationship with someone supports him/her to begin to see beyond him/herself, to become less ego-centric and more able to explore the world of other people safely. As a safe relationship develops, the Child and Youth Care practitioner is able to discuss how she thinks and feels when the youth behaves different ways, and the youth is learning to take other people into consideration, to become more socially aware. This builds a social logic into the youth’s critical thinking which is less ego-centric. This can only happen after the youth is able to be vulnerable (safely) in the relationship. As the youth begins to acquire a socially aware logic about how to behave, he/she starts to consider what impact they are having on others, which is what 5 to 8-year-olds typically are becoming more aware of.So you understand how to support youth and their parents with a developmental framework, and you create developmental growth through the use of relational learning.
Simple ideas.