Throughout my career I have been concerned about staff retention on the front line of residential treat-ment Child and Youth Care. From the get go this concern has been there with two early realizations. The first involved turnover. It does take a team to do this kind of work and yet when those first of an endless stream of team mates moved on because it was time I was left to mull the truth of the matter that this kind of work was going to take time to master. I have written in the past about the bargaining with team mates that was necessary to remain committed to the work. Ultimately, that commitment becomes intensely personal and a deliberate decision in the face of constant change. Recently, my sense of things has been of a more aggravated turnover, enough to raise concern for the future of the frontline of residential treatment. This column will explore aspects of retention for residential or group treatment care.
There was a time when residential treatment was the only game in town. The idea of bringing youth at risk together in a group and placing them under the care of a team of treatment workers was a novel notion that took root in a wide way in the early seventies. Group homes sprung up like mushrooms, all intensely working away at healing youth at risk in the community. Quietly operating alongside was the germ of a notion of supported foster care which has emerged through the nineties as a cost effective alternative as treatment foster care.
Innovation has continued into the millennium with an array of specializations emerging including educational assistants, addictions workers, life and independence transition workers, crisis specialization workers, outreach workers and it can be anticipated even more specializations to come. It was not accidental that Child and Youth Care education at the diploma and degree levels also developed apace along with these innovations. Residential youth care work continues often to be the introduction to the youth helping professions with people giving it a few years involvement, yet increasingly, this is being reduced to a practicum placement of a few months time before moving on to the emerging specializations. For some agencies at the forefront of this innovation, the residential care front line has become a kind of ready talent pool to draw staff from often before what would pass as an apprenticeship in residential Child and Youth Care has passed.
Residential treatment often was the core service of the more established agencies. There is a risk that the turmoil of innovation will result in an acceptance of lesser standards for such care with the focus moving away from treatment to behavioural management with placement in the group situation as the first stage of a continuum of care that will see a youth progress through a series of placement settings appropriate to his or her health and capacity to live in less staffed settings. I believe in this model but with the team’s shared determination to support the young person realistically choosing to transition when it is truly the time to do so. The time it takes for the severely harmed to heal and those who work with them to master the healing profession has always impressed me. To be truly successful, placement cannot be measured in months but rather years for some who need a deep sense of belonging and a substantial period to work through their issues and internalize the competency and confidence at living to move on to independence. Effective and excellent programs usually have significant staff commitment to the program and the youth in their care that can be measured in years.
One of the factors of the emergence of new Child and Youth Care specializations has been in the area of compensation. Programs that have their origins in health or justice have tended to offer dramatically higher salaries relative to those of social services. These distinctions are regretful as they carry a certain sense of diminution for Child and Youth Care work. The approach taken in Ireland that placed youth care, social work and clinical work all on the same scales would be my preference. Knowing your work both demands a professional constitution and professional rewards would do much for those in residential care work to stick with it. A trend that links experience and compensation arriving at salary scales that are decent and roughly equivalent right across the array of Child and Youth Care specializations would be welcome.
Still many who commit to residential care work do not do so for the money. They do so often for the bedrock reason of wanting to make a difference, to care and help young people in need. They appreciate the complexity of the work, its holistic approach and often the profound sense of belonging to a team and an enterprise much larger than themselves. Much of the time networking has brought them to a team lead by a charismatic and passionate supervisor who gets the work and inspires. In one of my less fortunate transitions between employers I learned this the hard way. Our mature and developed team was to be part of the sale of the group home to a new owner. At the last minute, we learned by letter we were not qualified to meet their expectations and were terminated. This set off a period of indignities that were unexpected exposing a Child and Youth Care system that was very unclear about expectations and often less generous than anticipated. I should note the group home only lasted six months under its new management which continued under a controlling regime that only resulted in crisis.
Anyone who has worked with youth at risk understands there will always be a place for residential treatment. Group care is not for everyone and often it is for no one in the beginning. There are youth who fit group care, even secure group care. The last Child and Youth Care Chronicle, Volume 20, #2, the newsletter of the OACYC reviewed Jim Anglin’s book Pain, Normality, and the Struggle for Congruence: Reinterpreting Residential Care for Children and Youth which argues just this including the following quote from a youth in care: “I knew the staff got changed every four days, and that would be enough time for them to have a break and come back to work and deal with me.” In many ways, the residential frontline is the foundation service for Child and Youth Care offering assessment, short and long term therapy to youth and important core experience and training to practitioners. However, it is not the only game in town any longer and truth be told, no one of these specializations has a cake walk when it comes to the work. Over time, each specialization will become better at what they do. For Child and Youth Care work in general, there may be a need to recognize this expanded marketplace of specializations and philosophies and advertise this more clearly up front to both potential employees and placing agencies. More and more, going forward, it is going to be about fit for both, matching skills and inclination on one hand and presenting problems on the other to the necessary service. An agencyin Newfoundland, Waypoints, uses its web site to both inform and educate going into extensive detail about Child and Youth Care work, their facilities, training and expectations. This is a long way from the word of mouth that revealed very little so many years ago.
The vibrancy of the emerging make-up of Child and Youth Care is on display in a number of places. As noted in the last column, the programs for the larger conferences are reflecting the number of specializations through diverse workshops and presentations. Members of the online community at CYC-Net is now routinely exposed to letters from workers in any number of these specializations. The Ontario Association of Child and Youth Care Professionals struck executive committees that reflect many of these. This reflects the common need of Child and Youth Care professionals going forward to step up at the association level to represent the field and advocate for young people and practitioners. My only wish would be that of the many coming forward, a select few who have the capacity and passion for the group care model will stay on and hold the frontline of the core enterprise of Child and Youth Care.
This feature. Goodwin, G. (2009). Holding on to the Line. Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 22/2, pp. 36-38