The most straightforward description of the goal of effective CYC practice would include creating change, both supporting people to change the way they think about themselves and changing the strategies and behaviors they employ to be successful in their lives.
CYC theories, program structures and treatment planning all focus on encouraging people to be different and measuring how much change occurs during and after the process of treatment. CYC educational goals and supervision approaches aim to teach practitioners the techniques and practical methods which lead to shifts in how young people and families live. We have also begun to emphasize sensitivity to power imbalances, gender and cultural diversity and ethical dilemmas. All of these training efforts focus on changing the person being helped and then evaluating how much change has happened.
CYC supervision emphasizes program delivery dynamics and how the behavior of the young people or families can be influenced using the tools and environmental incentives available in the program design. Supervision agendas are based on what the practitioners need to do and what they need know to act correctly. The goal of creating change is focussed specifically on how to change the person being helped.
I would like to consider a different target for change, where the CYC practitioner is the focus of supervisory efforts to create change. My belief is that when practitioners think differently about what they are doing, the results can be greatly enhanced. To put it simply, supervisors can focus on how practitioners think, not what they think. Program strategies and methods can look quite similar when you only look at the behavior of practitioners who think differently about what is happening, but the results of their efforts are not the same. The intention behind each intervention strategy has an enormous influence on the person being supported. We have often neglected examining the helper’s intentions, his mental image of why he is creating results or reactions and have jumped into measuring the young person or family’s response. When the intervention is not successful, we look to the young person or family and ignore the intentionality of the helper.
I would like to suggest that as a practitioner matures and becomes more professionally adept, he/she has also mentally shifted and developed more complex intentions as they intervene in the lives of people. The growth in more complex intentionality corresponds to the developmental dynamics described in the three levels of professional change known as the competent care giver (Level 1), the treatment planner and change agent (Level 2), and the creative, free-thinking professional (Level 3).
The agenda of supervisory efforts to support this growth in complex thinking about intentions can be focussed on how the practitioner constructs his/her picture of Self. Simply put, the newer practitioner builds self image based on safety dynamics, particularly concerned with personal safety. The more experienced (2-4 year) practitioner sees self in a teacher, influencer role, with a need to be personally attractive and the creative professional permeates every interaction with a self that is completely present, yet free of self-interest. CYC supervision can support the self journey of practitioners in a process that will build an awareness of intentionality that will enhance the overall effectiveness of our change efforts.
I will describe the specifics of each level of self construction and its effects on intentionality and program results in future columns.