CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 277 MARCH 2022

Tribal Times

Garth Goodwin

These are indeed interesting days to be living through. The Omicron variant roared into existence in November and by January dominated literally ballooning the numbers for the infected and hospitalized. Provincial and State governments crumbled under the onslaught admitting there was little they could do to prevent the spread. As if to underscore the point daily tallies of workers, flights and rail schedules falling to Omicron by the hundreds to thousands expose the growing realization that things no longer work the way they did. No longer is life a blur of untold options for transit, dining and entertainment with thousands on the move in a constant flow of humanity. Rather, interruptions, brownouts and burnouts are becoming the new norm. Curiously, in the face of the many cancelations a kind of blowback is emerging. In the world of child and youth care the Child and Youth Care Association of Alberta has announced a national conference for Canmore, Alberta in October 2022. To hedge their bets, the announcement outlines a hard reality event alongside a virtual component for those who cannot attend. The announcement and call for papers to come tug at deep tribal heartstrings on one hand and a pronounced yearning to break out of the shallow living of the last few years to experience a different place and to interact with old and new faces. Thom Garfat, in one of his many keynotes I believe in Winnipeg in 2010; introduced the concept of the child and youth care tribe to identify those who regularly attend the biannual conferences. Thom along with Leon Fulcher would go on to host gatherings for a global audience and with Heather Modlin would introduce the global child and youth care conference movement. Each reinforced the tribal concept, and it all came to an end with the pandemic. Social interaction has been reduced to the personal home level shattering tribal bonds with a profound and alarming polarization that threatens democracy itself developing. This column will explore aspects of tribalization.

It is the case that you do not know what you had until it is gone. Tribal connections are a blend of identity and belonging. The process of tribal connecting begins early, perhaps as early as playdates for toddlers. Certainly, by childhood. In my case bible studies at a neighbour’s house. We lived so far north missionaries went to the trouble to come there to ensure we had religion which we did for several years until we approached adolescence and more worldly concerns ended such studies. Along the way, both in the community and especially in school the various sports, intellectual and game activities were offered and brought new levels of identity and belonging.

Youth at risk tend to build their identities privately often being alone in situations they would rather not want to be in. They often come into care with a built-in resistance to social and team pursuits. One of my key kids wanted to play ringette and this became a mission outfitting her in what was becoming expensive gear to have her play protected. The first game came along. Her skating skills were basic, even tentative so the coach put her in the crease as the goalie. As she skated out that first game, achingly slow with halting steps, the parents in the stands began with the comments, the dissing and the taunting. She persisted and did not badly in goal so attended for the season giving it up in the end severing ties with that tribe.

The child and youth care association movement became my tribe. The notion of developing the field of child and youth care was exciting and involved staging conferences at provincial and national levels. Over time delegates and board members became more familiar and friendly. Setbacks on the career path with the closing of group homes and the loss of significant teams only intensified those connections. The gatherings and world conference movement extended it even more until it had to end rather suddenly with the pandemic. Social media has allowed the sharing of news, insights, and support with members of the tribe making this remarkable isolation of the pandemic tolerable.  

Quite suddenly in late January a so-called Freedom Convoy emerged in Canada involving semi truckers protesting the mandating of vaccination. They drove across the nation to the capital in Ottawa to stage their protest becoming a significant example of tribal creation in the process. With each provincial capital the convoy grew becoming quite large, around 15,000. It retained its identity and goal until it came to rest clogging all but one lane of the main road in front of the Parliament buildings. Then things became dynamic and dramatic as the Confederate flags emerged, the swastika’s, someone thought it totally cool to hop up on the grave or our unknown soldier and do a little jig. The convoy prepared to nest building a canteen, setting up bouncy castles, bringing in saunas and setting up supply sources for the protestors. Initially, there were large rallies on the weekends with a long-term group settling in for the long term complete with bellowing truck air horns and fireworks in the evenings. One man’s tribal ways are another man’s terror and trauma. This went on for ten days or so before a judge’s order noting horns and noise cannot be part of protest. The trucks fell silent in response. It was the first hint of Canadian good manners returning.

No one wants to budge on their positions on mandates yet. For me, it was a no brainer to get on board and go to the trouble of getting the jab. They used our convention center in my city as they wanted to emphasize the 6 metres of separation though out. The medical community took shifts doing the actual vaccinations and they were so slick about it you had no idea it was done. Now, vaccinations are available at clinics and pharmacies, even those in supermarkets. The country has almost caught up to its truckers, 90% of whom responded to the call here and in the United States that to do so due to their cross-border travel. Each level continues to inch up with the booster shot going over 50%. As a former child and youth care professional who put good health first for both youth in care and those working with them it was natural to be vaccinated. My province just specified youth in group homes, spelling it out for booster shots for adolescents. The numbers isolate the protesters to a small minority and the behaviour of several thousand who just hopped on have reduced that even further. In group care, unworkable, a term for those youth who could not respond to care due to intense anger, acting out, causing harm to others, breaking laws and running away constantly was part of the experience. The thought has crossed my mind that they have aged into a minority of perhaps a million or so who view freedom as their right to do and say exactly what they want. Various tribes including the far right and white supremist groups pepper the protest population. It reminds one of Hillary Clinton’s ‘basket of deplorables’ from the 2016 Presidential campaign. This writer wandered into this kind of territory using the word pantywaist in the January column. In my childhood the word was a trigger calling on the receiver to try harder, toughen up, learn the skill or play the game. Unfortunately, the word went on in subsequent decades to gather less complimentary meanings and references: emotional and sexual risking muddling my point. Perhaps another take is called for. A.S. Neill, the founder of a school/residential movement for youth at risk summed up his approach as Freedom, not licence underlining that our freedoms are linked to our responsibilities. It is so ingrained in me I had forgotten but it works in almost every human experience involving another. This suggests a rather obvious label for the anti-mandate cohort, the irresponsible’s. Dan Bilefsky writing in the New York Times noted:

“During the pandemic, repeated polls have shown that a majority of Canadians support public health measures to contain the pandemic, but the number of Canadians who would like to see restrictions end has risen in recent weeks, and the demonstrations have tapped into pandemic fatigue across the country after months of lockdowns. 

More than two-thirds of Canadians said they had “very little in common” with how the Ottawa protesters see things, while 32 percent said they had “a lot in common,” according to a survey conducted last week by Abacus Data, a research firm.”  [1]

It has been a long slog indeed and the pent-up craving to be mask free, with open travel, gathering, office space, recreation and dining is significant. It is interesting that the numbers are similar to the irresponsible’s in the United States built up in the Trump era. Recently, the Governor of Florida jumped in regarding the fund raising for the convoy being cancelled and the totally irresponsible Fox television network is jumping all over it trying to spin to a global status.

The Freedom Convoy goes on with echo blockades in Windsor, Winnipeg, and Coutts. Several counties and just announced, three Canadian provinces are lifting all their mandates with a few more seeing Spring as the target date. I remain uncomfortable and had to decline an international invitation due to this. The system remains uncertain and tentative as mentioned. It is like the entire world has become a reality show with Covid-19 applied the rule of the Big Brother series: expect the unexpected. The virus has connived its way across the world and is now focusing upon the youth and children. While they have more resilience death continues in significant numbers, we have grown numb to it.  The Olympics are taking place in a closed loop as they call it, no one enters without showing clear in constant testing. The Olympians and their teams and the media delegations are the only audience. There is constant spraying, testing and immediate removal to quarantine if you test positive. Still, people come down with Covid and here we do not see it. Ironically, this began for me with those first refrigerated semi units being used as morgues in New York. This approach was soon overwhelmed, and mass graves were dug in those first months. Covid will be with us forever, like the flu they say. It will take a hypersensitivity by the medical systems to read the wind and call the tribe back for a booster vaccination.

 

[1] Ending Protest Requires More Police, Ottawa Chief Says - The New York Times (nytimes.com)

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App