Much is made of the relationships between child care workers and children. It is indeed important. In fact, it is critical. But we cannot neglect other relationships and what they can contribute to the development of our children. Their relationships among each other, peer relationships, can be most powerful. Perhaps not so powerful, but still important, are the relationships children may have with other staff in residential settings.
This article is inspired by Lucille, a remarkable woman who worked as a secretary, actually more of an office manager, for over five years in a group home for twelve boys that was within walking distance of her home. Lucille was one of those rare people whom everyone liked. A lot. That was because Lucille seemed to like everyone. A lot. When you walked into Lucille’s office, you were the center of her attention, as if nothing else was important to her – no matter who you were: visitor, co-worker, Executive Director, or resident. She had a hug for anyone who needed it. Staff made it a point to pass through her office – day staff at their convenience, evening staff when they came on duty, night staff before they left for the day. Somehow, she knew everything that was going on. Because she never engaged in office gossip, with one exception, people confided in her. The exception, if someone were having a problem, personal or job-related, Lucille would tip off the appropriate supervisor so that they might lighten the duties a bit. As supervisors, we knew that if Lucille trusted us with some information, we had better handle it effectively and with discretion. She was a key to the effectiveness of our team.
Even more important was the role Lucille played with the boys. The boys, just as the staff, somehow managed to pass through her office on a regular basis. She knew them by name. They would share their accomplishments with her – she was often the first person to see their report cards. Lucille never, however, became involved in any of their problems.
Misbehaviour never occurred in her office. It was unthinkable. Consequently, Lucille’s office remained a positive place for the boys, and for everyone else. It was the place a boy could go when he was feeling down, when he had somehow managed to get on the last nerve of the staff and the other boys. When he knew he had done something wrong. In Lucille’s office, he was just another boy, to be accepted as a worthwhile person, with genuine, unconditional affection and, if needed, a hug. It was a respite – a place for boys to feel some acceptance and self-worth, no matter what. It brings to mind a phrase I have seen in one or two places in one form or another: “Give me a hug (or love me) when I least deserve it, for that’s when I need it most.”
Lucille was not involved in therapy. Her relationship with the boys was not intended to be therapeutic. (I think sometimes we go overboard, referring to anything that is beneficial as ‘therapeutic.) Nevertheless, I think Lucille’s relationship with the boys contributed a lot to their success in the program, keeping some of the more challenging boys from becoming totally discouraged. We had an excellent staff with a superb team leader, all of whom enjoyed excellent therapeutic relationships with the boys. Lucille’s relationship was not therapeutic. Rather, it was normal. Children need normal relationships in their lives just as much as they may need a therapeutic relationship at times.
Secretaries
As I considered writing this article which was inspired by Lucille, I began to realize that many of the programs in which I had worked had secretaries who played a similar role with the children – Donna and Cheryl. (Cheryl after a year chose to accept the challenge of becoming a child care worker, despite the fact that the longer hours were at the same pay. She eventually rose to the position of assistant director). I also worked in a program where the secretaries, Stacey and Janice, were actively prohibited from having any involvement with the children. Once, I allowed Janice to accompany the children on a special activity. There were no problems, but it was never again allowed. And Stacey’s request to become involved in the therapeutic riding program (horse) was denied. A shame. The kids, boys and girls, all struggled in that program. Nothing in their lives but therapy–mostly ‘state of the art behavioural therapy.’ Janice and Stacey could have contributed a lot and met some unmet needs.
Cooks
In the same program in which Lucille worked, we had a cook everyone called Mama Marie. She was close to retirement age. Loved her ‘babies’ and loved to cook for them. Wednesday was brownie night – homemade double chocolate brownies with chocolate chips. Decadent. Sunday night was spaghetti night – great to encourage kids to return promptly from weekend passes (or on occasion to return from a runaway). Mondays was the New Orleans tradition of red beans and rice.
Doesn’t sound like much, but it is a stick-to-yourribs delicacy the way they make it here. Slow cooked kidney beans with lots of seasoning and smoked sausage. (It is a tradition from the days when Mondays were laundry days. Housewives would put the beans on in the morning to simmer all day before starting the laundry. Then, dinner was ready when all was finished.) These traditional meals, well, they helped to create some stability in the volatile lives of troubled children – something on which they could always depend.
One Wednesday morning, Mama Marie came to me. It seems the kids and staff had failed to clean up Mama Marie’s kitchen after snacks the night before, leaving it in a terrible mess. She wanted something done about it. I suggested that she not make the brownies that day and that we explain to the boys that because she had such a mess to clean up, she did not have the time or energy to make the brownies. Out of the question. She could not deprive her ‘babies.’ She was another lady who gave hugs freely with unconditional acceptance and affection.
And when the boys had time to hang out in her kitchen, they learned some of the skills that go into the art of cooking. More importantly, they learned about the love that goes into the art of cooking. As with secretaries, as I thought about Mama Marie, I was reminded of other cooks in my career who contributed like Mama Marie, most notably Joyce and her staff, including Cherry Ann.
Maintenance Men
Secretaries and cooks. Jobs for women? In one program, I had two cooks who were men. Retired master chefs, they both cooked great, but they were not nurturing. One once chased a boy from his kitchen throwing a pan of boiling water at him. No harm done. He hit me instead. My trousers protected me from any burns and dried pretty quickly.
Maintenance, on the other hand, is most traditionally a job for men. Were they nurturing? No, I think not. At least, not in the same way secretaries and the female cooks were. Were they beneficial? Absolutely. No hugs. Unconditional acceptance? I don’t know. I think their acceptance was conditional, but it was quite different from the acceptance granted by treatment personnel. Their acceptance was based on performance – not performance based on treatment plans and goals and point systems and such stuff, but performance based on completing the task at hand. And if the boys acted out, they got ‘fired,’ sent back to their unit having only earned a portion of the pay for the job – a real-world consequence. I think real-world consequences are the best teachers.
In an institution with multiple units for over 100 boys, we had a fully-fledged maintenance department headed by Cecil. Cecil often had odd jobs for the boys for which they could get paid. They got to work alongside men who were doing real work, cutting grass and landscaping, repairing faucets and doors and windows and things, refurbishing an empty unit.
Sometimes, Cecil worked with me to come up with some project when boys needed money. I don’t know what all the boys got from working with Cecil, but I do know they came back after their work with a sense of accomplishment that we could not provide for them, that feeling you get from a day’s work well done. In another program, there was Alvin who provided much the same. Both were down to earth men as it were, who taught the boys skills that they might otherwise not have an opportunity to learn.
In the program where I worked with Lucille and Mama Marie, we hired Henry as a part-time maintenance man. Henry was a local from this rural community outside New Orleans that had its own identity, culture, and pride. Henry was a retired roofer of about 72, as I recall. The boys loved to hear his stories about the old days. To be sure, all of us had our stories that we shared freely with the boys when we thought it appropriate. But with Henry, it was different. Henry was not a treatment person. Consequently, his relationship with the boys was somehow different, just as was that of Mama Marie and Lucille. He added perspective. His stories somehow gave additional perspective and more credibility to our stories. And more, they provided the treatment staff with more things with which to work.
Financial personnel
My experience with financial personnel in four different programs was quite different from my experiences with other support staff. These folks tended to stay more in their offices and have little contact with the children. Since they did not turnover nearly so frequently as treatment staff, they had considerable seniority.
More, financial matters, although equally as important as treatment (you can’t do treatment if you don’t have the money), are not nearly so ambiguous as treatment may be. There’s only one way to account for money. It’s either right or it’s not; the books either balance or they don’t. Because of their longevity and financial expertise, financial staff tended to have considerable influence with executives on policy matters that at times exceeded their financial expertise.
One problem: they came from the orientation of “Everyone knows how to raise kids.” It had more to do with making sure the kids suffered appropriate consequences for their behaviour than with treatment.
Upon accepting a position directing a program of three units for 32 boys in a large agency, I found that my program had not had funds for community activities for several months. It seems the bookkeeper charged any damages to the activity funds! Our activity funds had a substantial negative balance – even if there were no further damages, it would be months before there were funds for activities.
There were things like a broken window, someone playfully swinging on a heavy solid wood fire door and pulling the door out of the frame, some deliberate damage during a boy’s temper outburst, discharging fire extinguishers, and more.
Since the boys had not had activity funds for months and would not have any for months to come, there really were no immediate consequences for further damages. Damages were not only continuing but also accelerating. I spoke with the bookkeeper to see whether we might get a pardon as it were and a fresh start. Nothing doing. The boys had to pay. I spoke with the executive director. He supported the bookkeeper. Then I spoke with the maintenance man (Cecil, from above). He had a large project – he had to empty a building that had been used for storage and get it cleaned up for a new program. He was willing to ‘pay’ enough not only to cover the amount we owed but also to provide a balance for activities for the next month, provided the boys cleaned out the building to his satisfaction. They did so. Once the boys had the opportunity to take some active responsibility for paying off the damages and then to experience some activities in the community, damages somehow subsided.
In another case, two boys got into an altercation. One had his jaw broken and had to have it wired shut. There were $25 in medical expenses that were not covered by his insurance and were charged to the program. The bookkeeper charged the $25 to his allowance. The consequences for getting involved a fight (he didn’t have much choice) – broken jaw wired shut, liquids only by a straw for 6 weeks, and no allowance for at least five weeks if he earned maximum points.
Somehow, he failed to earn anywhere near maximum points, earning only $1 per week, so that it was going to take him months to pay off his charges. Needless to say, he did not do well in treatment after that. In that same program, a new business manager decided that the agency could save money by preparing meals in a central kitchen and transporting them to two satellite cafeterias, closing the kitchens on the units. Staff would escort the boys to the appropriate cafeteria for meals. Boys would no longer return from the day’s activities to the aroma of dinner being prepared. Cooks would no longer have any contact with the people for whom they were cooking and boys would no longer have the opportunity to have any relationship with the people who were cooking for them. What a terrible loss.
In Conclusion
The therapeutic relationships between children and child care staff are of critical importance in a residential setting. Other relationships with ‘normal’ (i.e., non-therapeutic) staff are also important. They should not be neglected. Not everything has to be treatment. The more relationships we can provide for children with people who genuinely like them, the better. After all, is not our goal to empower children to have and to enjoy normal, healthy relationships?