Pioneers in work with troubled children sought, with mixed results, to replace coercive discipline with democratic self-governance.
After World War I, Germany experienced a brief interlude with democracy. During this period, schools and youth programs were experimenting with new systems of discipline which involved youth in self-governance. In 1927, law student Clara Liepmann wrote her doctoral dissertation on the history of self-governance in correctional settings in Europe and the United States. Her father, Moritz Liepmann, was a law school professor who advocated for replacing punishment with education. Together they toured progressive correctional facilities in the United States. Clara combined data from that visit with historic and emerging developments in Germany and Switzerland. This article summarizes her research (Liepmann, 1928).
Early delinquency reformers believed that offenders must be given opportunities to practice responsibility if they were to become responsible citizens. Liepmann believed that traditional discipline by force had totally failed to transform and educate. Antisocial behavior is a lack of inner restraints and willpower. Only self-education will make lasting change.
In early 19th century Switzerland, a young teacher, Johann Jakob Wehrli, worked with orphans and children who lived in the streets of Swiss cities. He created a setting in which learning and work were intertwined. Wehrli believed that only community could prepare someone to live in a community. Initially, the groups were plagued with bullying and acting-out behaviour. His solution was a council of self-administration, where the older youth were expected to be positive role models. These youth mentors were deeply invested in guiding and educating their younger peers. The council was also involved in the decision about when a youngster was ready to leave the program.
Liepmann cites another early example of self-governance, the Boston House of Reformation, directed by Reverend E. M. P. Wells from 1826 to 1832. Wells strongly believed no child was inherently bad, no matter how badly he or she behaved. He tracked their growth in responsibility with a six-level system, and in only four weeks, a youth could reach the highest level. Students could lose a level by bad behaviour; however, if they admitted wrongdoing, the level did not change. Every evening, students rated their own behaviour, and peers provided feedback on how to develop more positive behaviour.
In mid-19th century Germany, Johann Hinrich Wichern directed the Rauhe Haus. Boys and girls up to the age of 14 lived together like families, guided by elected peer leaders called Friedenskinder (peace children) who were given the task of instilling positive behaviour within the group. Every four weeks, a new election was held so that many youngsters had the opportunity to show leadership as peace children.
After describing these progressive 19th century youth work pioneers, Liepmann documented self-governance systems which she observed in the United States. Among these was George Junior Republic in Freeville, New York, which created a democratic community of delinquent youth. She also visited various prisons for young offenders and adults. All of these settings developed close-knit communities where residents had responsibility for a wide variety of tasks, including ensuring positive conduct within the community. A common denominator was "no privilege comes without responsibility." These positive correctional communities thrived, but when committed charismatic leaders were no longer in charge, the programs regressed into punitive prisons. Notably, New York's Sing Sing was once a model of self-governance, but became a symbol of subjugation.
Liepmann describes numerous other projects in the United States which employed self-administration systems. Most failed after a short time because the culture deteriorated into empty routines. Level systems became punitive. Positive groups collapsed as rapid turnover prevented teaching newcomers how to operate in a community.
Change of leadership posed the biggest challenge to these programs. For example, after World War I, Karl Wilker transformed Berlin's worst delinquency institution into a model of self-governance called Lindenhof. But his progressive beliefs were at odds with political powers of the time and he was fired. This positive climate quickly deteriorated.
The challenge of maintaining positive programs was the subject of careful analysis by Liepmann. To be successful, self-governance programs must give tasks of real responsibility. Superficial rituals of youth empowerment will be seen for what they are and will fail to enlist youth in a partnership with adults in authority. Thus, when adult leadership changes, the techniques may continue but the spirit of democracy is lost.
In order to use self-administration for discipline, there must be an inner circle of youth who show strong positive leadership. Lacking this, groups revert to negative peer leadership. This is a continuing challenge as new members enter existing groups.
Effective education must make deep changes in the core of the personality if the young person is to be able to transfer what has been learned and live without trouble in a community. This begins with a good connection between the adults in charge and young people in their care. These positive adult-to-youth relationships form the foundation of a culture of self-governance. The task of the adult is to communicate his or her strong conviction that the youth can do the right thing.
Level systems are only effective if it is easy to get out of the lower levels quite quickly. If too many people are stuck in the punitive lower levels, there is something wrong with that level system.
Self-governance is more than getting youth to comply with rules. Only inner work on values and attitudes provides success in the long run.
Liepmann concluded that self-governance will only work if the adults in charge truly and fully buy into it. Those not able to use the system in the right way will execute force and power, not democracy.
Effective self-governance is not a set of techniques, but a way of thinking, trusting the good in every person.
From Reclaiming Children and Youth, Vol. 19, number 3.