In recent years much of the conversation in Child and Youth Care practice as well as in several other human service disciplines has turned to resiliency as a conceptual framework for developing programs and services for people facing multiple and complex challenges. Identifying what sort of characteristics or factors might help people overcome adversity does indeed seem like a good idea. Of course, in spite of the theoretical potential of resiliency, I have previously written about its pitfalls in the context of trying to design programs and services with a view of enhancing the resilience of young people. Back then I wondered aloud whether we are simply finding yet another reason for trying to get kids to conform to what seem like reasonable and civil social standards and expectations. I am somewhat encouraged by the shift in thinking expressed by one of the leaders in the field of resilience research, Michael Ungar. His writings have always been a little more on the edgy side of the resilience juggernaut, but in recent years he has asked some interesting questions, including whether our need to get kids to abandon risk and danger in favour of conformity might eventually backfire on us and on the kids. I tire a little from this conversation. Ultimately, no matter how hard I try to strain my brain I keep coming to the same conclusion. Resilience is a bit of a no-brainer, a tautological approach to understanding what those we seek to understand understood a while ago.
When translated into practice, resilience moves from tautology to circular reasoning. What we need to do is to create programs and services where kids in trouble can avoid the circumstances that get them into trouble, thus resulting in kids who are not in trouble. The trouble is, of course, that kids are still in trouble, “40 assets” and other conveniently packaged approaches to practice notwithstanding.
All of this has got me thinking about the concept of vulnerability, perhaps as a counterweight to resilience, or maybe just because I think we spend far too little time thinking about the vulnerabilities of kids, of staff, of systems and perhaps even of culture. By vulnerability I mean all those things that render our everyday experiences a little less predictable, a little less reassuring and perhaps occasionally, a little more scary than they otherwise would be. For the young people we work with vulnerability is sometimes the outcome of violent or troublesome ecologies, in the family, in the community or even in the country and beyond. At other times, their vulnerabilities are symptomatic of the importance they give to what other people might think of them or of their conduct. But most of the time, vulnerability for young people is about not knowing what the hell is going on, either inside of them or all around them.
I like thinking about vulnerability because I think it is a concept in which all people can find some common ground. I am quite certain that everyone is vulnerable in some way, at some time, in some context. Some people find it difficult to deal with silence; their ability to know themselves is mitigated by the absence of self-orienting noise and familiar sounds.
Others are rendered vulnerable by darkness, which they experience as disorienting and confusing. Again others might find challenging being alone, especially if most of the time they identify themselves in the context of relationships. But just about everyone struggles with facing all of these conditions at the same time: total silence, alone, in complete darkness. Add to this an unfamiliar environment, perhaps one that could be associated with identifiable dangers even if these are unlikely to come to be (such as a forest at night), and suddenly we begin to recognize what vulnerability might feel like for those whose everyday lives are indeed lonely walks in the forest at nighttime. Indeed, many of the young people I have met in my time in group homes, special school programs or homeless youth shelters were on just such a walk. They really didn’t know what was coming next. They could not answer with certainty whether they would still be there the next day, who was going to be important in their lives tomorrow or even what their role in their current physical and social context really was.
Vulnerability is acute and intense in the lives of many young people we tend to associate with in our work. But it is also significant in the lives of the Child and Youth Care practitioners, the social workers, the parents, the neighbours and everyone else around. Interestingly, virtually no one is really allowed or encouraged to express their vulnerability, or even to acknowledge it. For the young person, doing so may expose weaknesses that are unacceptable in the tough and judgmental peer group. For the child and youth worker, doing so may mitigate the trust and comfort colleagues have in him or her. For the social worker, expressing vulnerability is just a short step away from openly acknowledging burn out. The families are supposed to be concerned about their kids and take responsibility for them, not whine about their own issues and concerns. Neighbours who do anything more than keeping their distance are clearly motivated by a right wing, individualist and ego-centric concern about property values and everyone else’s vulnerability is just symptomatic of their lack of professional credentials in a field that values (but never admits to valuing) toughness, resilience, and the uncompromising commitment to denying a lack of answers or solutions.
Funny how it goes. The one thing we probably all have in common is too dangerous to talk about. And so the kids go on pretending they are tough; the child and youth workers and the social workers continue to pretend they know, families deny everything or simply disengage, the neighbours stay away as much as possible, and everyone else goes about their business, hoping against all odds that the resilience magic will kick in eventually and make all the problems go away.