As I was working on this current series of articles for CYC-Online I asked Ernie Hilton for some feedback. Unlike me, Ernie is still entrenched in the everyday challenges of Child and Youth Care, out there in beautiful Nova Scotia. While thoughtful and supportive, his comments clearly reflected an overriding belief that much of what passes for literature in Child and Youth Care is painfully detached from the day-to-day world of frontline Child and Youth Care practice. And I agree wholeheartedly. Surely, Ernie wasn’t accusing me of having my head in the clouds? After all, everything I have to say is about the direct experience of being with kids. But, the more I peered behind my words, the more I became concerned about how far I might have drifted from the realities of life on the frontline – it’s been a long time.
Though my stance was always relational and focused upon subjective experience. I began to detect little globs of arrogance and condescension wrapped up in petty paternalistic packages. Perhaps I was falling into the trap of blurring the distinction between making suggestions and dishing out ‘advice’. Could it be that I had become a traitor to my own cause by presenting myself as an expert? Woe is me!
As my final “Commandment” was to be about avoiding ‘experts’ it seemed opportune for me to impose upon Ernie to help bring this issue into focus. When he agreed to co-creating an article with me, I was delighted. So here it is folks. As you will see, Ernie sets the stage and leaves me to bring down the curtain – my prerogative of course.
* * *
Hilton’s “Rant”
Who are these experts anyway? There never seems to be a shortage of people telling front-line Child and Youth Care practitioners what to do or how to be. Pick up any journal related to our field, randomly select a chapter, and chances are you will find a plethora of advice being handed out to Child and Youth Care practitioners on how to do their jobs better. These folks, the practitioners, are expected to graciously heed the words of wisdom from these articles and integrate it into practice. The author then moves on to figure out other brilliant thoughts to bestow for next month scheduled deadline.
I realize I may sound full of contempt and ungrateful for the contributions of “experts”. I know their goal is to advance the field closer to a reputable, respected place of acceptance utilizing research and frameworks. Thankfully, our field has an abundance and diversity of talents enhancing this field of dreams called Child and Youth Care. Why then is so little of our literature filled with the experiences of the practitioner perspective? What are we doing, or not doing, to ourselves to exploit and embrace the richness of the frontline perspective from a professional and developmental growth perspective?
In practice, I have watched practitioners manage a seemingly endless list of tasks and responsibilities, practical to the daily living of those in their care, with proficiency and expertise. It is a wonder that all practitioners do not walk around filled with resentment as a result of the multi-layered expectations from all the “experts”; while expected to remain humble and, dare I say, subservient to, well pretty much everybody.
When is the last time you have thought about the endless list of expectations practitioners complete in the course of an often 12-hour shift? Aside from the expectation of being therapeutic from a relational perspective, they are also expected to meet timelines, professionally represent the organization through their phone manner, attire and report writing, be self-aware, be aware of ever evolving best practices know this, that and the other thing…seriously? I understand fractures among management, front line, academics and funding bodies in many professions; but our field, we are supposed to be the relationship people! Is there an unspoken jostle for hierarchy within our field? Ooops, did I say something about this “thing of ours” (Soprano reference to La Cosa Nostra) that is to remain sacred ground? I may be self projecting but there seems to be “in-fighting” about who are the experts, instead of appreciating the expertise from each role in the field.
Enough dirty laundry: what is this phenomenon that shapes what an “expert” is? Wikipedia defines an expert as a profound thinker, a reliable resource of skill and technique, accorded authority by peers and the public. Not a substantive qualitative or quantitative process for sure; in fact it might explain why there are many self-proclaimed experts out there. And there’s the rub; the expert often seems defined as “out there”, away from self, away from the mastery that lies within, especially on the frontlines. I could go outside our field and wax on about other professions and their contempt for our work and their top-down positioning of our role, but why when there are enough budding expectations right in our own community brewing resentment versus connectedness and support.
I happen to love research, frameworks, data and all the latest articles, regardless of their usefulness. That love of such ingredients can be seen as robotic, cold, structured, rigid, no flow, no “Be”, not pure or true to the essence of our mission of caring. Then there is the perspective that real care work needs to have existential flow, presence, rhythm, dance, and the art of practice versus the science and that is the path to expertise and excellence. There are those who sit on the fence and pontificate on the balance between navigating between both camps and perspectives and thus the war begins.
Meanwhile, back on the farm, practitioners are looking for something useful they can translate and enhance their practice, some realistic strategy to help them heal devastated hearts. All this can be done of course for $1000-$2000+ a training day from an expert.
Here’s what I know: if frontline practitioners ever decided to train their own, guide their own, support and educate their own, there would be a lot of houses up for sale in Expert-Ville. There is theory-land and actual-practice-land and if we are not attentive as a field, these two entities are going to go to war, or worse, have the other denied a place or meaning in the process of evolving the field.
I suspect there are divisions already, benignly sitting, waiting for the revolution – for a new budding branch of the field to emerge. Psychiatry spawned clinical psychology which spawned social work, which spawned, Child and Youth Care that spawned...? My order may be crude but my point is, what is next? Does our inevitable growth and evolution mean we have to divide? In the meantime, if I read one more word in an article that has contempt for the academic, frontline worker, supervisor, manager or administrator, I may have to lead the revolution myself. If I hear one more word that science, data, research, frameworks, models and strategies are not a useful part of practice, I will climb on the turnip truck and become what outsiders think we are anyway – a bunch of glorified babysitters. I can deal with them, the outsiders, those so-called experts, those who are ignorant of our field’s power and expertise to heal. It is the toxic contempt from within that will make our field ‘sick’. We must see our field with abundance of expertise across the profession and be mindful of our words and actions so they support and nurture our field. Then, the identity we search for most, like respect and notoriety will take care of itself. While we compete for rank and identity as experts, we will not benefit from the strengths of each other. In addition, you know who suffers from that in the end. It is within our diversity that our strength lies, to be experts in healing, not the self-importance of one role over another.
I am not asking for a love-in, just a respect-in; an understanding this field, like our bodies, needs to be nourished, challenged, supported, educated, trained, guided, mentored and, ultimately, connected. If experts are defined by the community then we need to set it up, so this is true. Academics need to be with frontline, frontline needs to be with academics, trainers need to give as do educators, and administrators need to find a way to support all these things. Enough with what the experts say, WE are the experts, as individuals and all that we bring regardless of the differential developmental contribution. A new worker is bringing it every day and exponentially and proportionality that contribution will grow if nurtured and supported. The internal contempt will make our field ill. Then we will have other experts put us on meds and give us shock treatment to heal us. That is not our way, our way is in relationship, in connection with healing words of support and understanding, and actions that reflect authentic caring to others, WE are the others too. Let’s be clear I am a hypocrite I have in the first paragraph levied contemptuous remarks … why is it so hard to be consistently grateful as a theme of practice? Why do we have to prove superiority by putting others down to achieve it? The expert lives within, and our actions and self-projections define our expertise or lack thereof. The community of Child and Youth Care can do well by focusing less on putting each other down and more on raising each other up or we may become what we hate.
* * *
Fewster’s Mea Culpa
Let me remind you of Ernie’s opening statement: There never seems to be a shortage of people telling front-line Child and Youth Care practitioners what to do and how to be.
Well Ernie, I’ve spent over fifty years scribbling, in books, journals and newspapers. Over the same period, I’ve presented at conferences, conducted workshops, led trainings and generally run off at the mouth whenever the opportunity presented itself. I got myself a Ph.D, not because I believed all the stuff dished out in academia but because I wanted to be successful and influential. I wanted people to listen to what I had to say – not what others once said (Freud included). And, of course, I wanted more money.
So, does this make me an expert? Of course not, but who the hell is going to take notice if I stand up and say “I don’t have any qualifications and I haven’t got a clue what I’m talking about but listen anyway”? Who would hire me to conduct workshops if I announce that I’m grovelling around in the dark just like everybody else? For over twenty years I ran a huge treatment centre for troubled kids and families. Do you think I’d have been given that job if I’d told the Board I knew nothing about kids, human relations, organizational systems and multi-million dollar budgets? If you do, you might as well apply to the post office.
So am I a charlatan, full of baked beans and cod liver oil? No, I firmly believe that what I have to say (or “share”, as the nice people put it) is worth listening to. Why? Because it comes from a heartfelt place grounded in many years of experience working with kids, advocating for kids and developing systems that serve kids. Even when I was teaching at the university, I maintained a private practice to pursue my life-long fascination with relationships and I continue to bring this experience into every aspect of my personal and professional life. Sure I’ve constructed a belief system that filters what comes in and shapes what goes out but I always make that clear from the outset. I also know that, even at my advanced age, this is not a closed system. In fact, some of the most negative feedback I’ve received over the years has been because I changed my mind. And this goes to the very heart of the matter.
I suppose, in some way, I am presenting myself as an expert. But in no way am I telling anyone what they should believe, how they should do their jobs or how they should lead their lives (unless they’re working in a program under my direction). I have no more idea about the “truth” than the folks sitting around me in the pub (except for that strange guy in the corner who keeps turning glasses of water into vintage claret). My only claim to being an expert is in interpreting my own experience, testing out my own hypotheses and expressing my findings to the world. Over the years I’ve acquired and developed many ‘techniques’ that happen to fit my current understanding of the way things are; and these I will gladly pass on to anyone who might be interested – yes, dammit, sometimes for a professional fee. But I take no responsibility for how others incorporate these things into their own lives and, when it comes to adults, I take no responsibility for the outcomes. Working with kids is a little more complicated but the same basic principles apply.
If all this makes me an expert, so be it. Unless I become deaf, dumb or deceased, chances are I will continue to reflect upon my personal perspective, articulate my ‘brilliant’ ideas and teach approaches that work for me – but always with the inherent understanding that others have the same rights and the resources to make their own personal and professional choices from their own perspective. But I don’t know what’s ‘true,’ or even what’s right, anymore than anybody else and I reserve the right to change my mind whenever I see fit. If, for whatever reason, others choose to see me as the guy with the answers, it says more about them than about me. Only they know why they insist on looking outside for answers that can only be found on the inside. And this applies to Child and Youth Care folks who want someone to tell them what to do when things aren’t working as much as it does to frustrated parents who want get their kids back into school.
For those who remain committed to the expert fallacy, I would like to offer the following thoughts: So, Who are these Experts Anyway? To cite my co-author again, … the expert often seems defined as “out there”, away from self, away from the mastery that lies within, especially on the frontlines.”
What Ernie seems to be saying is that an expert should be defined by his or her specified area of knowledge and expertise. Now that might be a straightforward proposition in the neatly defined field of cardiology, but in the misty ‘people business’ it’s more difficult to pin down. In the world of Child and Youth Care, it’s virtually impossible. So does Ernie’s concern stem from the fallibility of the experts or the in security of our ubiquitous profession?
Before addressing this question, I want to bring some life into the discussion by offering three brief examples of people likely to attain expert status in our field. From the outset I need to stress that these descriptions in no way represent real people – living or elsewhere. They are entirely fictitious and are offered for illustrative purposes only.
Expert A
Dr. Clare has been in ‘clinical’ practice for over ten years specializing in adolescent issues. She was raised in an upper-middle class home, the daughter of a cardiologist and, from an early age, there was no doubt in anyone’s mind that she was heading for medical school. After completing her M.D., she went on to a prestigious institute to complete her psychiatric training. In other words, Dr Clare was an expert as soon as she stepped into her new office. But what is the nature of her expertise?
Well, after ten years of study and ‘socialization’, she certainly knows how to interpret and implement the medical model. She likes people, particularly kids, but her training was generally limited to prescribed supervised ‘clinical encounters.’ In these brief episodes she learned how to identify and classify ‘patients’ according to established diagnostic criteria.
Her relationship training was virtually non-existent and, since psychiatry formally abandoned psychotherapy in favor of psychopharmacology back in the 1980’s, she has only a sketchy view of what Freud actually said. But Dr. Clare gets on well with kids and some actually enjoy their twenty minutes in her office each week. She supports parents and teachers and provides consultation to a number of child and youth facilities in his community. Of course she believes in psychiatry and would never be expected to challenge its basic premises and practices. In knowing and plying her trade, she is indeed and expert.
Expert B
Jim B. was born in the backwaters of a large industrial city. His parents divorced when he was seven and he was raised in the suburbs by a maternal aunt. At the age of fourteen he was placed on probation for a series of offences and was subsequently sent to a residential ‘school’ for three months. Jim scraped though high school and, unable to find work, he received financial assistance to enroll at the community college. Here he decided he wanted to work with deprived kids. Unlike his teachers and those who had tried to ‘counsel’ him, he knew what it meant to be unwanted and a victim of social injustice. He understood the kids they were talking about because he had been one of them. Helping them to change their lives became his passion.
Armed with a two-year certificate in Youth Work, Jim began work as a counselor in a juvenile remand center and his belief held true he really did understand the inmates better than the other staff and the kids identified with him. After only a couple of months, he decided that the program, the correctional system and, society in general, were giving these kids a raw deal and he committed himself to doing something about it. He left his colleagues and supervisors in no doubt about his discontent and, believing that he was also trapped in the same repressive system, he left after four months to become a street worker.
With freedom to work in his own way, Jim created a reputation as an advocate for downtrodden kids and was frequently called upon to appear in court on their behalf. He was the central figure in a feature article in a local newspaper and, subsequently, a regional TV station invited him to collaborate in producing six 30-minute documentaries on ‘Community Youth Issues’. Each program included a sequence with Jim talking to kids in a variety of locations and concluded with a five-minute segment in which he drew his own conclusions on camera. Jim continues to be true to his cause. While he has taken advantage of his many opportunities to become more public and political, he still uses and inner-city youth club as his home base. He has never written anything of note, but his experiences and radical views have become well documented through the media and various publications. He has a wide audience, and what he has to say makes sense to a lot of folks out there. This includes many CYCs for whom J is something of hero. He says what they want to hear so, by acclaim, he knows what he’s talking about. To them, he is an expert.
Expert C
Mike F. has been a leading figure in the field of CYC for many years. He began his career as a frontline worker in a large residential program where he was considered by his supervisors to be “an enthusiastic worker with potential”. That “potential” was put on hold when he decided to enroll in graduate school and complete an M.A. in Counseling. On graduation he accepted a position as the Director of Research in a community mental health project aimed at troubled kids. After two years, his report was presented to Government and became an influential document in the re-organization of youth services. He was then hired by the government department to oversee the implementation of their new ‘Policy and Procedures’ Manual. Three years later, Mike published a book on ‘developmental strategies for working with children and youth’. This publication was widely acclaimed in government circles and incorporated into their training programs for all youth workers in the system.
In the following year, Mike was invited to provide consultations and workshops for a wide variety of government programs and private agencies. He spoke at conferences and delivered a well-received keynote at a regional Child and Youth Care annual conference. This re-ignited his interest in practice issues and he left government service to become a free-lance consultant offering workshops and trainings for CYC practitioners. In the interests of his blossoming career, he returned to graduate school and added a Ph.D. to his list of academic achievements. A couple of years later, he published a book on working with children and families that is still considered by many to be a seminal contribution to the field. With more offers than he could handle, Mike established his own consulting company promoting his ideas and methods to the widest possible audience.
Without question, Mike had become a leading figure in his field. Since accepting a position at a university, his consulting company has continued to flourish and his latest publications are eagerly anticipated. As an expert, he is nationally and internally acclaimed.
Discussion
Without doubt, all the fictitious characters described above have something to offer frontline CYC practitioners. But, to address Ernie’s primary concerns, can we consider them to be experts in understanding and implementing the fundamentals of Child and Youth Care practice – particularly the relationship aspects? This is a question that can only be answered if we have some agreement on the specific nature of Child and Youth Care and how it can be distinguished from other professional approaches.
At this point, I would suggest that there is no such consensus, although the debate has been going on for many years. Ironically, much of this discussion has taken place among those Ernie might consider to be ‘outside’ experts. It may well be that this is simply a reflection of a widely diverse, dispersed and disorganized agglomeration of activities that can never be adequately contained within any definitive framework. If this is so, then perhaps we should just drop the generic label and create sub-sets. This is precisely what we did when we changed the name of The Journal of Child and Youth Care to Relational Child and Youth Care Practice. I suspect Ernie will not approve of my decimation of his beloved profession but what can I say?
So, having revealed my own ‘relational’ bias, I can briefly state what I personally consider to be the definable characteristics of a profession that can be distinguished from all others. To save time and energy I will simply repeat the words I used while participating in a debate initiated by Mike Wattie and put out on the CYC-Net some months ago:
In a nutshell, I believe that effective CYC practice works from the “inside out.” The focus is upon the subjective experience of the child rather than external judgments and labels applied by parents and professionals.
By the same token, the essential resources for change and growth are to be found within each individual child, rather than in specific forms of treatment or therapy. Practitioners who work in this way are more curious about the inner world of the child than the theories that purport to explain behavior and the techniques designed fix the problem. For these reasons, their essential skills are personal and relational rather than objective and technical.
By contrast, psychiatrists are primarily concerned with the brain, psychologists with deviations from their standardized norms and social workers with environmental circumstances. None of these folks are in a position to respond to the subjective experience of the child. Caught up in their own theories and traditions, they are not likely to challenge their own methods of external intervention and questioning each other’s would be very “unprofessional”.
I should acknowledge that the second paragraph was not well received by representatives from other professionals who believe that I diminished their practices.
This was not my intention but I can see their point. But my personal “opinions” still stand. I think Ernie might share their concerns but to explore this would involve another writing another article.
Conclusion
Given my idiosyncratic sub-set within the generic field of Child and Youth Care, I believe I’m in a position to identify the external ‘experts’ who might have something to contribute to the cause. I would have a framework in which to assess the validity of their contributions, without necessarily casting aspersions on their beliefs, theories or methodologies. Like Ernie, I believe that collaboration is in everybody’s best interests and certainly in the best interests of the kids we work with. So my conclusion is brief and simple: There’s no point in dissing ‘outside’ experts until Child and Youth Care folks have some idea what they’re actually looking for. As Ernie suggests, this means that CYC practitioners must begin to recognize and honor their own specific areas of expertise. But this will never happen until they are able to define the nature of their work and ingredients that make for exemplary practice.
Amen